Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

"The no vote reflects many contradictory positions"

Socialist Organiser no. 526, 11 June 1992 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 612 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Danish socialist Age Skovrind assesses the Maastricht referendum in Denmark. This article was written before the referendum result; it is translated (and abridged) from the French socialist weekly Rouge.

The figures show a huge gap between the voters and the political Establishment.

Among the 175 members of Parliament, only the 15 members of the Socialist People's Party; the 12 of the right-wing, populist and nationalist, Progress Party; and one member of the Christian People's Party, voted against the Maastricht agreement.

Why are the Danes so opposed to European integration? Several factors need to be taken into account. There is a widespread (though not entirely true) idea that social standards are higher here than in other European countries; and so, more integration would mean a loss of social gains.

The methods of decision making in the European Community are perceived as profoundly anti-democratic. The distancing of Denmark "Culturally, Denmark feels closer to other Scandinavian countries than to Germany"

from Brussels reinforces this feeling, and all the more bec Denmark only has three otes of 76 in the council of min ster:

Culturally, Denmark feels closer to other Scandinavian countries than to Germany, towards which, moreover, there remains for historical reasons a certain hostility.

Unlike the countries of central Europe, Denmark has only belonged to the European Community since 1972, and so EC membership is not yet seen as an established fact of life.

Finally, since 1972, internal politics has been dominated by cuts policies and by a big rise in the rate of unemployment, and these are seen - although wrongly - as the result of entry into the EC (for several years, Sweden and Norway did better economically).

The parties to the left of Social Democracy have always been unconditionally against EC membership. However, those positions have changed in recent years. That is due to the fact that, despite great scepticism towards the EC, more and more people think it is no longer possible to quit.

The great weakness of the novote camp is its division on an overall alternative. A no majority will reflect many contradictory positions.

However, such a result would be a terrible blow to the traditional parties, and would probably lead to the resignation of the Schulter government, which has already been weakened by a series of scandals. In such a situation, new elections would represent a great chance for the Left Alliance [of far-left groups] to get representatives in Parliament and to strengthen the mobilisation for a socialist and internationalist alternative to the policies of the European Community wait until a "democratic solution" has been achieved.

Stalin would have blushed with pride at seeing how his perspectives of 1927 in China, so discredited at the time, have now been taken up so avidly by some of those who claim to follow his bitterest enemy, Leon Trotsky.

Abandoning elementary Marxist principles, you don't see that only a consistent Marxist perspective, of princi pled opposition to British imperialism, of the struggle for socialism, of transitional demands in the tradition of Lenin and Trotsky, can unite the Irish working In this, you break with not only Trotsky — you also junk even Connolly's tenuous anticipations of such a position. All you offer instead warmed-over liberalism: "Be nice to each other"!

Socialist Organiser draws an'analogy with the situation in Yugoslavia: but the communal bloodletting there is the result of capitalist restoration, following decades of market socialism' that undermined the collective property relations of a deformed workers' state.

Try putting your "be nice to each other" line to the Serbs and Croats. You would, unfortunately, be met with derisive laughter.

Ian Donovan, Sutton

Scan page 12

Socialist Organiser No. 526 page 12 LENIN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 526

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →