Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Neither Copenhagen nor Brussels, but workers' unity!

Socialist Organiser no. 526, 11 June 1992 · scan p. 11 · about 518 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

By Colin "Wonderful, wonderful, Copenhagen" sang left-wing Labour MP Dennis Skinner in Parliament after the Danes voted to reject the Maastricht treaty.

Tony Benn also welcomed the vote, and called for a referendum on Maastricht in Britain.

But what did the Danes' "no" mean? The article on this page from Age Skovrind - a Danish socialist who voted no - recognises that it reflected "many contradictory positions".

In the Danish Parliament, the oppositio to Maastricht came equally from the Left and from the nationalist Right. There wel some left-wing motives behind the no vote - fear that European integration would cause higher unemployment and more cuts - but they were confused (in fact, unemployment and cuts would be just as bad in a capitalist Denmark outside the EC), and there were right-wing motives too.

Right-wing voters feared that closer European integration would mean more immigrants, and more Danish money spent on aid to poor areas in southern Europe.

How can a majority for that mixture of confused left-wing feeling and nationalis right-wing feeling be a victory for the lef No socialist would have wanted to voti yes to Maastricht. The Europe of Maastricht is a bosses' Europe; a racist Europe, committed to closing Europe's external borders while it eases internal frontiers; an imperialist Europe.

No socialist could approve the way the Maastricht treaty was worked out, either, by haggling behind closed doors between different governments, while the elected European Parliament functions only for show.

No socialist could say yes to the Danish Conservative government's cynical posing of the referendum. The referendum presented no real choice; there was no way that the Danish government could or would carry out the mandate of a no vote.

Such referendums are called by governments only when, and in terms such that, they can win. Unfortunately for them, the Danish Conservatives miscalculated.

The Danish left should have registered a protest against both Maastricht and Danish nationalism, by abstaining in the referendum, as Workers' Fight, a forerunner of Socialist Organiser, advocated abstaining in the 1975 British referendum, and as the French socialists of "Lutte Ouvriere" advocate abstaining in the referendum now called in France.

Probably the European Community governments will find some way to manoeuvre over the coming months and save the Maastricht treaty, with or without Denmark. Possibly the Danish vote will trigger other upsets and send the EC governments back to the drawing board.

Neither outcome will make Europe any less capitalist, racist, and imperialist.

Capitalism has outgrown the limits of. the relatively small European nation-states of the last century. The governments know that: and the EC and Maastricht reflect their awareness. For four decades now, in a fumbling and bureaucratic way, they have been trying to create a broader "home market", and framework for Euro-multinationals capable of competing with the Americans and Japanese.

The socialist answer cannot be to defend the outdated capitalist nation-states. Our answer is workers' unity across Europe, to meet the bosses' international plans with an international working-class strategy, and to fight for levelling-up of rights and conditions across Europe.

Neither Copenhagen, nor Brussels, international workers' unity!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 526

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →