Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Prescott is the lesser evil

Socialist Organiser no. 526, 11 June 1992 · scan pp. 2–3 · Chris Reynolds · about 722 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

The Labour leadership between John Smith and Bryan Gould about who could promise the quickest SDPisation of Labour's politics, has shifted a little under the pressure of the rank and file.

Despite the ridiculously

stitched-up way the contest has been run, Bryan Gould has felt obliged to turn on some leftwing speechifying, and Margaret Beckett has had to dust off her CND card.

What does this mean for the left? The contest for leader still gives us no openings at all. There is still no issue of substance where Bryan Gould has taken a clear stand to the left of John Smith.

In the deputy leader contest, however, John Prescott has now differentiated himself fron the other candidates on a clear issue. He has opposed the exclusion of the trade unions from Labour Party leadership This position is hypocritical and unreliable. Since getting on to the National Executive in 1989, Prescott has consistently backed Kinnock's witch-hunting and Kinnock's drive to scrap left-wing policies.

Even now that 'oppositionist, he did not manage to register a vote against Kinnock on cutting trade-union links at the May National Executive meeting.

Yet a win for Prescott will undeniably boost the defendi of the trade union link. And Prescott is hypocritical and unreliable. Since getting on to the backed witch-hunting and the drive to scrap leftwing policies. Yet a win for Prescott will undeniably boost the defenders of the trade union link. "

another thing that has changed since the contest began:

Prescott's candidacy now looks like a serious challenge, not jus an exercise in self-promotion. He might even win.

Consulting comrades round the country last week, the Socialist Organiser editorial staff concluded that the balance of the argument had shifted in favour of voting for Prescott as the least bad of the right-wing candidates. A spoiled-ballot protest, the only alternative, is very difficult to make effective.

If even 99% of the members of a Constituency Labour Party, or a trade union, spoil their ballots, the vote of the CLP or the trade union will be decided by the one percent who cast valid ballots, and the spoiled ballots will disappear from the reckoning.

Some readers will complain: 'So! You back a right-winger like Prescott, and you would not back a left-winger like Livingstone! Sectarian fools!' But to try to tip the scales fo the marginally least bad of various right-wing candidates, when there is no better choice, does not compel us to support joke 'left-wing' candidates who are just standing for personal o sectarian self-promotion.

And anyway, the issue of whether or not to vote for Livingstone never came up! Even before he declared as a candidate, he had tacitly admitted that he could not get the 55 nominations necessary.

The fact is that his candidacy was never a matter of left against right, but an attempt by a shyster to promote himself as the leader of the left. That was what we refused to support. put it right.

The most pressing problem, however, is perhaps that of the world's forests.

The rate at which these are disappearing has actually increased over the past decade. In addition to the loss of species of plants and animals, many unidentified before their extinction, this is causing climate changes of its own.

This is in the form of reductions in rainfall on nearby farming land which can only increase pressure on the remaining forests from hungry peoples. To tackle this requires that multinational food and timber companies renounce the profits they are obtaining from the destruction of the forests, either voluntarily or under pressure from their own governments. Anyone who expects either of these things to happen is truly naive.

Instead, the drift is towards putting the burden of resisting forest destruction on Third World countries. Understandably, these are unwilling to pick up the tab from someone else's meal. The only real alternative is mass pressure on companies and governments to force changes and this is why the environment must become a labour movement issue.

Scan page 3

SUICIDAL DI DI HURLED WORLD suicide Sünt INSIDE TODAY ide to POURED Mail You 60p THE ROYAL CRISIS WORD KALVENE Despairing Diana and Fergie made an amazing pact NEWS fe Organiser the cu claims I

----- pull-quotes -----

contest, which started out as a competition

NEC in 1989, he has consistently

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 526

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →