Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The lef need?

Socialist Organiser no. 525, 4 June 1992 · scan p. 14 · about 472 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

PLATFORM

pt indeed that Sean Matgamna's colourful antiLivingstone polemics "The 'Left' Pantomime Candidate" (SO 521) and The Left and Ken Livingstone" (SO 523) speak of "the left we have and the left we need"; the articles illustrate the difference perfectly.

There is wishful talk of a "draft Benn campaign". Yet Benn - who is now 67, and by all accounts only stood for the leadership in 1988 under extreme pressure and against family wishes - took the understandable personal and political decision not to run. That, surely, is his right.

Why assert that Benn "could probably - given reasonable time - have got over the "55 MPs barrier"? Only 38 MPs backed his bid four years ago, and the new intake contains few left-wingers.

"Privately, very few people on the left - inside or outside the Labour Party - have a favourable word for Livingstone", Matgamna continues, before branding him *an unreliable self-serving cynic with few scruples and some very Rexible loyalties".

Many on the left privately voice strident criticisms of Matgamna; I know neither man personally and therefore offer no judgements in either case. But since when was personal like or dislike of an individual a relevant factor when considering whether to back a political project?

Having some sort of Campaign Group intervention into Labour's leadership stitch-up - however imperfect one might consider it — is surely preferable to no left activity in the so-called "contest" at all.

Matgamna correctly mentions SO's "isolation on the left" in openly attacking Livingstone, then contradicts himself with the claim: "The only 'movement' Livingstone has behind him is a small cluster of left' sects: the strange Stalinoid grouping Socialist Action, Briefing and the elderly legions of the Morning Star."

Livingstone is also backed by Labour Left Liaison, which includes the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, Black Sections, Labour Women's Action Committee, and Labour CNDan integral and significant section of Labour left opinion, influenced by but certainly not reducible to Socialist Action. Principled, crucial support has also come from Socialist Outlook and Socialist Worker, despite Livingstone's frequent attacks on the SWP in the Sun.

When Matgamna points to the differences between Livingstone's own policies and the Campaign Group platform Livingstone sought to stand on, he only underlines that the campaign goes well beyond a fan club affair.

Whether or not it serves as a catalyst for a rejuvenated Labour left depends crucially on the attitude existing left activists take towards it.

By all means stridently criticise Livingstone and his co-thinkers' project for realignment inside the Labour Party (as indeed I did in socialist, 12.2.92), or their confused ideas of socialis economic strategy.

But please do it in a serious and comradely manner, without deriding anyone as a "scumbag".

"The left we need" is a left that debates differences openly, without stooping to playground-style name-calling.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 525

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →