Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Stalir through ti looking. glass

Socialist Organiser no. 525, 4 June 1992 · scan p. 13 · Martin Thomas · about 495 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Wilcox Television wing of the umbrella movement aclay Klaus's party, the right which led the revolution in 1989, may well keep its control of CzechoSlovakia's government after the election this week.

As one of its leaders told Channel 4 TV ("Dispatches", Wednesday 27 May), it promises "Wild West capitalism" The prospects for Czecho-Slovakia's workers are not much better than for the American Indians.

Klaus is determined to privatise at breakneck speed. Shops, cafes, and so on are being sold to individuals by auction (the "small privatisation"); for bigger enterprises (the "large privatisation") the procedure is more complex.

According to law, only CzechoSlovakian citizens can buy businesses in the "small privatisation". Since many businesses have gone for prices far exceeding the maximum any Czecho-Slovakian citizen could possibly have saved from legal earnings, clearly crooked bureaucrats and black-market profiteers from the old regime are the chief buyers, along with wealthy foreigners.

Under the "large privatisation", successive selections of enterprises are obliged to present to the government plans for privatising themselves. The shares for which they cannot directly find individual buyers - foreign capitalists, banks, or whatever -have to be distributed to the population through a voucher system.

Every adult citizen can buy a book of vouchers for about £20, and with those vouchers buy shares in the businesses being privatised, the price of the shares being fixed by supply and demand.

This "people's capitalism" is a poor bargain. The voucher-holders only get the shares which individual capitalists will not buy; and, unless they have inside" bureaucratic connections, they can get no information about the businesses being privatised.

The voucher scheme was saved from collapse by the rise of "investment funds", which take people's vouchers and promise to invest them knowledgeably.

But a lot of the investment funds" are certain to prove to be ripoffs: people who want to cash in their shares will find that the "fund" boss has disappeared. Those that are not straight rip-offs will be eager for quick cash, so will use their shareholding power to "asset-strip" businesses. The TV researchers estimated that 40% of the privatised companies will go bust.

Czecho-Slovakian government economists know all this and accept it. Yes, they said philosophically, there will be mistakes and swindles, but central planners would have made worse mistakes and swindles!

Privately, I guess, they are glad that the crooked bureaucrats and the black-market mafia are buying up businesses, and thus coming into the realm of the purging, cleansing, efficiency-making free market.

These free-market economists are strange mirror-images of the enthusiastic central planners of high Stalinism. Regardless of the human cost, the mass pauperisation, the ruined lives, the hideous waste, everything must be subordinated to the magic mechanism of economic progress, be it free market or central planning.

They are getting their way, at present, because the alternative of democratic workers' control and planning has few advocates in Eastern Europe. Employee share-ownership schemes are the most radical venture of Czecho-Slovakia's trade unions -so far.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 525

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →