Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A clash of values

Socialist Organiser no. 525, 4 June 1992 · scan p. 13 · about 646 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

The Wilcoxes go in for Film business. They re practical, matter of fact people, no nonsense types.

They know who they are, and wha they want - simply the best of Belinda Weaver what's going. "Howards End" The bridge between the two Mrs Wilcox, who befriends *Holanaton for the se owards End" could well Margaret Schlegel, and tries to leave her her house, Howards Ent adaptation for the screen When Mrs Wilcox dies, Margaret It's faithfully done, following the becomes the second Mrs Wilcox, text and tone of the book fairly and the film shows her coming to closely - but it doesn't engage you. terms with what that means for Based on the 1910 novel by E. herself, for her sister, Helen (who M. Forster, it's about the clash of despises the Wilcoxes), and for her values between two middle class own values and beliefs. English families, the Schlegels and The battleground for the the Wilcoxes. The Schlegels, half- clashing values is a clerk, Leonard German, don't grub in the world of business. Living on their income, and try to help. To them, Leonard they indulge their taste for is no ordinary clerk. He has dreams literature, music and "ideas"; they and yearnings, about literature, see their lives as leisurely, cultured. about nature, about a life beyond the narrow confines of his poverty.

They romanticise him, and harm him in the process. By the end Leonard realises that to live "To us, the Schlegels and the Wilcoxes are all of a piece, only lot have more of a bleeding heart."

like the Schegels takes money. The Schlegels, whose wealth allowed them to take so much for granted, Bast, whom the Schlegels "take up" could never understand Leonard's circumstances.

Henry Wilcox understood them, but felt no pity, and found the Schlegels' patronage of Bast absurd and out of place.

This clash forms the heart of the story. The Schlegels represen the waning tradition of "noblesse oblige" , transmitted through the leisured rentier class. They feel responsible for the poor, and try pathetically (and ineffectually) to help. The Wilcoxes, as working capitalists, are more up to date. The poor will always be there, one's sorry for them, but there they are - that's the Wilcox way.

Both Margaret and Helen rail this heartlessness, but they themselves are just as bad. For all their breastbeating, they do Bast no good at all; he's worse off for having known them. Henry's view -materialistic, selfish and selfserving - carries the day.

Perhaps what's dreary about the film is the narrowness, the weakness of these opposing views. To us, the Schlegels and the Wilcoxes are all of a piece, only one lot have more of a bleeding The film seems to be looking back to a more caring England, a time when private profit was not the order of the day. It's hankering for a more settled world, where rich and poor have their place, but the rich help the "deserving" poor.

When Bast says he had his niche, and should have stayed in it's the voice of Forster yearning for the certainties, the secure hierarchies of an earlier age.

The house, Howards End, is meant to represent, in brick and stone, traditions, a settled attachment to home, to land, to nature - all the things that get lost in the hurly burly of capitalist speculation and grab.

If only people could get off the rushing, money-making treadmill, and find "true" values again, then a Leonard Bast would be worth as much as a Henry Wilcox - that's the message.

As "Howards End" was written, in 1910, trade union battles were becoming fiercer and fiercer, right up to the outbreak of World War 1 In those class battles, workers were claiming access to literature, art, and leisure by right, not by individual patronage of the rich. Forster never understood that.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 525

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →