Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Their polemics and ours

Socialist Organiser no. 525, 4 June 1992 · scan pp. 12–13 · Sean Matgamna · about 2,130 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

The truth is: we supported Yeltsin and the people against the authoritarians, and this Outlook! Every so often we invite them to debate with us, or work with us where we have political agreement. Year after year we have invited them to come along and debate with us at the annual Workers' Liberty event.

Year after year the organisation and its leaders refuse! Always. On every subject. There is one exception. Over two years ago they did consent to debate with us. We had two debates, in Manchester and London, on the class character of the then USSR. Then they reverted to their old position: no debate.

We repeat the invitation this year: come to Workers' Liberty '92 and debate!

Socialist propagandists who believe in their own ideas are normally keen to find an audience, but not the shy boys and bashful women of Outlook. Why?

Perhaps there is - as they sometimes put it - "no point". Maybe they think that the Alliance for Workers' Liberty consists of hardened middle-aged incorrigibles, whose minds closed 15 or 20 years ago? No, they don't think that. They insist publicly that the AWL is based on students and other young people; indeed, they exaggerate, pretending that we neglect trade union work.

Our trade union work is probably better than theirs (compare the coverage in the two papers). But it is true that the AWL is mainly young people. The average age of the AWL is at least 10, possibly 15, years lower than the average age of Outlook. If there is a moribund group of tired older people here, then it is Outlook, not the AWL.

It is upon open-minded, young people that the venerable leaders of Outlook refuse to bestow their political wisdom, refusing them even the right to hear their "official Trotskyist" criticism of the AWL. Strange people, Socialist Outlook!

Their strange attitude to the AWL is expressed in the following snatch of dialogue a year or so ago, between Mark Osborn of the AWL and Phil Hearse of Outlook, at an anti-war meeting. Outlook and the AWL had a more or less identical attitude to the Gulf War.

It went approximately like this. Osborn: •The differences between us do not justify your sectarianism towards us. Here we are with an identical position on the war. In fact a good case could be made for the fusion of the two groups. Within a democratic organisation, the differences would be containable'.

Phil Hearse, who, I understand, is editor of Outlook and the political leader of the main tendency in Outlook, replied: "Says the wolf to the sheep!"

Those were his exact words, I'm told, not in a friendly private conversation, but in a wrangling confrontation with a known factional opponent!

Strange dialogue! Strange people! Strange fear! Evidently they scare themselves with their own propaganda demonising the AWL.

To help the reader bring this into focus, I should add that there seem to be more of them than there are of us, though most of them don't do much.

So the explanation, then, is that the leaders of Outlook are a bunch of peaceful, plodding, tired old political herbivores, content' to graze their hedges and green borders, uninterested in political combat, polemic, or even comradely dialogue to try to unite the forces of Trotskyism - just a timid bunch of well-meaning wimps who do no harm to anybody but themselves?

Unfortunately, no. They run and hide from confrontation, they refuse debate -but then they try to regain their own political self-respect by sniping at us in the pages of Outlook.

But, you say, written debate is good! It might be, but it isn't. Even their sniping at us is just another form of running away! without abandoning our politics They do not debate with us - take up what we really say and do, and then discuss or refute it.

They write silly polemics, denouncing us for positions we do not hold and could not hold, and for things we have not done and could not do.

They wax publicly indignant, attributing to us ridiculous "positions" which they "prove" by "quotations" made up in their own editorial office. They merely pretend to debate with us; it is not us, but figments of their own imagination, they debate with.

"Why does all this matter? Hearse's polemic is a product of a radically disoriented tendency from under whose feet the political ground has been well and truly cut by the collapse of Stalinism. They are people who will, in real debate and discussion, either radically rethink the theoretical basis of the revolutionary socialist politics we share with them, or disappear."

In a minor key it is all curiously like what the - then still political - Healyites were doing in the mid 1960s.

Outlook no. 21 had just such a piece of polemical nonsense, signed by Paul Clarke, which I believe is a pen-name of bold Phil Hearse.

Strange people, Outlook! Take this passage: "Sinn Fein president Gerry Adams lost his West Belfast seat at the general election, a fact greeted by Socialist Organiser (SO 520) with the headline: 'Good news from West Belfast'.

"For Socialist Organiser this amounted to a rejection of sectarianism' by West Belfast workers.

"At the level of facts this is absurd. Adams lost his seat despite the fact that his vote, absolutely and in percentage terms, went up. Some hundreds of loyalist voters switched to the SDLP to vote Adams out.

"SO supporters say the SDLP is the 'party of the Socialist International'. It may be thus affiliated, but it is not, like the Labour Party, a party based on the workers' movement. It is a bourgeois nationalist party, full stop.

Of the three passages in single quotes, one, 'Good news from West Belfast" ', is accurate. The other two passages are wholly invented!

They are not honest summaries of what we say, put into single quotes for economy (Outlook's style, anyway, is to use only single quotes for all quotations). The words they invent for us flatly contradict what we believe and what we said. We said: "The SDLP is a bourgeois party". From what I've seen of him in two debates, Phil Hearse is an over-cautious, serious fellow, bordering on the pompous, who prepared and fussed over detailed notes before debating a subject he must have debated a hundred times before. How then does this careful, painstaking man wind up inventing quotes in the style of Gerry Healy and his "red professors" - Cliff Slaughter and others - of the mid 1960s? On Ireland, and on other things, there are important differences between Outlook and us. They do not deal with them.

About West Belfast we say - to spell it out - that both the SDLP and the Provos are bourgeois nationalist organisations. The Provos are now a narrowly and murderously Catholic-sectarian organisation which pursues the "count the Catholics" politics of the pre-1970 Nationalist party in tandem with an "armed struggle" which supplements those "count the Catholics" politics with a "shoot the Protestants" policy.

The bourgeois SDLP is, without ceasing to be bourgeois, closer than the "Republicans" are to Wolfe Tone Republicanism, which was also bourgeois, but whose irreplaceable starting point was and must be recognition of the equality of all the Irish, "Protestant, Catholic and Dissenter".

Such things as the Provos killing of Protestant workers as "collaborators" are indefensible from a socialist, an anti-imperialist, or a Republican point of view.

Our views may be wrong. They may be tion at the level of fact, logic, or principle, democratic, socialist, or both.

Outlook, disagreeing with our views, should feel a responsibility to tell its readers exactly what is wrong with what we really say. Instead they invent quotes which sum up neither what we think nor what we say, and indulge in junior-school Gerry Healy style polemics. They spread silly political smears, and try to foment a hate campaign.

In other words, they run away, comforting themselves with the polemics they could justly write if only their opponents were idiots, using fantasy polemics, pretend polemics, to wall themselves off from the world they do not know how to make sense of, and from questions we raise they cannot deal with.

Hearse also accuses us, though without an invented quotation to back him up, of giving "almost uncritical support to Boris Yeltsin"

We say Yeltsin is a Mussolini! We urge the left in Russia to push him aside. Here too Outlook is running away, flinging abuse over its shoulder.

Here too, it tells us more about Outlook than the AWL. At only one point have we ever expressed positive (not uncritical, nor politically self-denying) support for Yeltsin - the moment when he, with admirable courage and determination, made himself the focus of resistance to coup last August.

Then we supported Yeltsin and the people - against the authoritarians. In the same way we would support bourgeois democracy, even a Mrs Thatcher, against a fascist coup, without abandoning our own politics or preaching confidence in the bourgeois democrats or in bourgeois democracy. There is a big Marxist literature on the question.

If we were wrong to back Yeltsin in August, why, according to the basic politics of Trotskyism in such cases, were we wrong? The only possible reason would be that despite their authoritarianism, the coup-makers represented something good -the defence of what Outlook still, I believe, call the workers' state.

I think the point here is not that we *support" Yeltsin, but that a lot of people in and around Outlook had to stifle in temselves an urge to back the coup as the "last hope" of the workers' state (and they did: Outlook "supported" Yeltsin just as we did).

They resent us for posing things clearly. Here it is temselves they are running away There is a lot of other nonsense in Hearse's polemic, which is aglow with outrage that we dare be rude to Ken Livingstone - and another invented quote, too - but it is not worth pursuing.

The current issue of Outlook (no. 22) carries a letter from Martin Thomas about Hearse's article. He accuses Outlook of inventing quotations. They publish the accusation without comment!

Implicitly, it would seem, they plead guilty as charged. If not, then they would surely defend temselves. But they offer not one word of explanation! They seem to be unaware that explanation is called for.

But no, they are aware of it all right. They handle it like kids in a playground who respond to a jeer by throwing it back: you too!

They publish a mildly hysterical letter about Socialist Organiser, and make a headline of a phrase in it describing SO as a "Red Lie Machine?" The question mark is the editor's.

There, you see! We've been caught out inventing quotations, but still, the real liars are Socialist Organiser!

But SO has not lied! (The alleged "lies" are to do with our interpretation of Outlook's politics, which the writer rejects). We do not invent quotations. If, inadvertently we misrepresent or simply misunderstand, then we allow those who object the right of reply. (On at least two occasions in the last year, Outlook refused us that right).

The casual way Outlook deals with being caught out inventing quotes, as if they are not aware of the enormity of it, reminds me of a well-known piece of verse:

"For how can you compete, Being honour-bred, with one Who, were it proved he lies Were neither shamed in his own Nor in his neighbour's eyes".

Why does all this matter? Hearse*s polemic is a product of a radically disoriented tendency from under whose feet the political ground has been well and truly cut by the collapse of Stalinism. They are people who will, in real debate and discussion, either radically rethink the theoretical basıs of the revolutionary socialist politics we share with them, or disappear.

"Disappearance" can mean either dissolving or turning into a destructive and irational - and congenitally stupid - sect of the Healyite or Lambertist sort, who are characterised in politics above all by charlatanism - pretend politics, and by the substitution of words and phrase-mongering and of textual "orthodoxy" for Marxist analysis of reality.

Those, on the whole, have not been the methods of the tendency of which Outlook is part. It is no part of a Trotskyism capable of living and growing in the new conditions.

As far as we can judge, the motive for Hearse's Healyite polemics is to stop Outlook working "on the ground" with the AWL, as many of them do now. The Healyite poison-pen polemics had a similar motive.

I will return this subject

Scan page 13

cialist Organi

----- pull-quotes -----

EYE ON THESERT trange people, those who run Socialist

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 525

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →