When the Bishop Caseys told an Irish governmen Noel Browne and
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
James Connolly, trade union leader, socialist, republican, much of his political life fighting Catholic reaction Joel Browne has been aptly described as "Ireland's Nye Bevan". He was for decades the main Irish voice of reform socialism. He tried, valiantly, as Minister of Health in the 1948-51 Dublin coalition government, to build an Irish National Health Service like the one Labour Minister of Health Nye Bevan was building in Britain.
Unlike Bevan, Browne failed. He failed because the Irish Bishops opposed his plan, and set out to crush him; and, when the Bishops moved, because his colleagues betrayed him, and tried to hound him out of public life. His party, Clan Na Phoblachta, led by Sean McBride, was one of a group of small parties - including two Labour Parties - clustered around the big Fine Gael to form the coalition. It expelled Browne after a ludicrous "trial".
Within weeks the coalition fell. Until he retired in 1983 Browne was regularly sent to the Dail for South Dublin.
Browne himself might be a character out of a Charles Dickens novel. He was born in 1915 into a big poor family afflicted with consumption (TB), the deadliest mass killer of the time. His father died, and then his mother, dying, fled to London with her children, to keep them out of the workhouse. Her 20-year-old eldest child, Eileen, had a job in London.
Her strength exhausted by the effort to save her children from being sent to the workhouse, Noel Browne's mother died almost immediately, and was buried in a pauper's grave. The family was partly dispersed.
In his autobiography, Against the Tide, (1986), Noel Browne tells the almost unbearable story. His older brother Jodie was humpbacked and tubercular. He died aged 21, after a terrible life, when a workhouse doctor, needing experience, decided to operate on his cleft palate: Jodie did not survive.
And then miracles happened for Noel Browne, the pauper child himself likely to develop consumption and die of it. (Eileen, too, died of it at the age of 29).
His sister worked in an institution catering for the children of British colonial administrators; they offered to educate Noel, without fee. Afterwards he won scholarships to the very bourgeois Catholic Beaumont College, and, Dickens again, the family of one of the penniless boy's friends then offered to pay his way through medical school.
He did develop consumption but, nursed in wartime England, he survived.
Working in British hospitals in the later period of the war he says that he shed much of the snobbery he had picked up in the course of his education. His socialism, like that of a whole generation of British reform socialists - Michael Foot, for example - was heavily influenced by life in war-time Britain.
In his book, Browne movingly shows himself to be a socialist dominated by tender feelings of human solidarity, and anger at the vile, warping, inhuman ethics that go inseparably with capitalism.
After the war he went back to Ireland and joined Clan Na Phoblachta — a "New Start" leftish Republican party, led by Sean McBride and others who had been the leaders the earlier.
Clan Na Phoblacta was to prove itself part of the old story of postcivil war Southern Irish politics, not the start of a new one, as Noel Browne was to learn painfully. But first came tremendous achievement.
As Minister of Health Browne made war on TB and in an amazingly short time came within sight of wiping out this disease which had been killing tens of thousands every year. That achievement alone would mark Browne as one of the greatest men in Irish histoThen he turned to creating a new health care system. But now his "Mother and Child Scheme" brought him smack up against the Bishops. After 30 years of 26 County independence, the Bishops had the real power, and were used to exercising it.
They objected to doctors and paramedics instructing women on matters to do with sexuality and children: sexuality and children were moral questions; morality was the preserve of the Church. Hold on, Mr Browne!
And they objected most emphatically - hand in hand with the Irish medical establishment -to Browne's insistence on making the services free: a means test was essential, they insisted. Anytilg else was immoral Ordinarily it would have been enough for the Bishops merely to pronounce their judgement. Politicians would obey. Browne was made of better stuff. I will let Browne tell what happened.
"On 10th October 1950, I was peremptorily ordered to Archbishop [of Dublin] McQuaid's palace by a telephone call from his secretary. I was told to attend a meeting, to be held on the following day, concerned with the proposed mother and child health service and the bishops' position in regard to it.
"I could not understand why any bishop should not be prepared to meet a government minister in his department. Yet my Cabinet colleagues informed me that it was in fact the practice, under Irish government protocol, for a minister to be expected to attend, when told to do so, at a bishop's palace. There would be three bishops present while I, though requesting permission to do so, was bluntly told that I might not bring my Departmental Secretary.
"In opening the conversation Dr McQuaid chose, of all subjects, to discuss child prostitution, informing me: the little child prostitutes charge sixpence a time. Concluding this strange interlude, he invited me into a larger and more imposing room, where two bishops were introduced to me as Dr Staunton, the Bishop of Ferns, and Dr Michael Browne, the Bishop of Galway. As soon as we were settled, a letter from the hierarchy was read to me by Dr McQuaid.
"Dear Taoiseach [Prime Minister], The Archbishop and Noel Browne Bishops of Ireland at their meeting on October 10th had under consideration the proposals for a Mother and Child health service and other kindred medical services. They recognise that these proposals are motivated by a sincere desire to improve public health, but they feel bound by their office to consider whether the proposals are in accordance with Catholic moral teaching.
In their opinion the powers taken by the State in the proposed Mother and Child Health Service are in direct opposition to the rights of the family and of the individual and are liable to very great abuse... if adopted in law they would constitute a readymade instrument for future totalitarian aggression.
"His socialism, like that of a whole generation of British reform socialists - Michael *The right to provide for the health of children belongs to parents, not to the State. The State has the right to intervene only in a subsidiary capacity, to supplement, not to supplant.
It may help indigent or neglectful parents; it may not deprive 90% of parents of their rights because of 10% necessitous or negligent parents.
'Gynaecological care may be, and in some countries is, interpreted to include provision for birth limitation and abortion. We have no guarantee that State officials will respect Catholic principles in regard to these matters. Doctors trained in institutions in which we have no confidence [this meant students -like Noel Browne - at Trinity College, the "Protestant University", , where Catholics were then forbidden to study] may be appointed as medical officers under the proposed services, and may give Disgraced Bishop Casey gynaecological care not in accordance with Catholic principles...
The Bishops desire that your Government should give careful consideration to the dangers inherent in the present proposals before they are adopted by the Government for legislative enactment'..."
Dr Noel Browne continues:
"Having read the letter to me, the bishops appeared to assume that the interview was over. In spite of this I chose to tell them that there were a number of mistaken assumptions and assertions...
Browne talked back!
"Dr McQuaid asked why it was necessary to go to so much trouble just to provide a free health service for the 10% necessitous poor. This comment was not only wrong, since the percentage involved was thirty and not ten, but surely represented a strange attitude from a powerful prelate of a Christian church towards the life and death of the 'necessitous poor' and their children... As a doctor, I believed that a free health service was an essential pre-requisite to an effective and a just health service...
"Bishop Browne then took up a question dear to his heart, that of the burden of rates and taxation. He claimed that it was unfair to tax the rest of the community in order to give the poor a free health service. I pointed out that taxation was surely not a matter of morality; as far as I was concerned, it was a problem for the government, the Minister for Finance and myself.."
So far their concern had been strictly with temporal issues.
n fact, the hierarchy proved adamant: they insisted on a drastically diminished, means-tested service. They peremptorily refused to answer the question why they had not denounced the British National Health Service which Northern Ireland Catholics used. Together with the medical profession, they organised a tremendous campaign to break Noel Browne.
Browne continues his account:
"In Cabinet I decided to make a stand on two issues: the fundamental rights of the electorate, with power coming from the people to the elected government, and
Scan page 11
the Bishops The Citizen Army began as a trade union militia to defend workers - some of whom fell, clubbed to death by police - during the 1913 Dublin Lockout. When James Connolly led the Army into the 1916 Rising, they did not go out to fight for the anti-working class Ireland which the bourgeoisie and the Catholic Church created when they assumed power after 1921 hat 1 the right of the public to a proper health service. Under no circumstances could we concede to the bishops the right to set aside a law already passed by the Oireachtas.
"Archbishop Kinane of Cashel... is quoted in the Irish Independent of 2 June 1951 as saying: 'I have recently emphasised that certain graduates of TCD, while openly parading their Catholicity, have, at the same time, publicly set themselves up in opposition to a fundamental part of Catholic religion, namely the teaching authority and the bishops. These people are now claiming the right to determine the boundaries of their jurisdiction. They should not oppose their bishop's teaching by word or act, or by any other way, but carry out whatever is demanded by him. They must carry out political, social and economic théories which are in harmony with God's laws'.
"I was the only impediment to the joint plans of the hierarchy and the medical consultants to deprive the public of a fine health service; the hierarchy had become the factual instrument of government on all important social and economic policies in the Republic. Our prospects for the preservation HE SERVE of an effective Cabinet and a badly needed health scheme were now changed utterly.
"The bishops objected most emphaticallyhand in hand wi the Irish medica establishment Browne's insistence on making the services free: means test was essential they insisted. Anything else was immoral.
*Of the two issues involved, the more important was no longer the mother and child scheme. The real challenge being mounted by the hierarchy was their implicit claim to be the effective governKAISE ment... As Sean O'Faolain was to observe so acutely about the power of the hierarchy: "The lightest word from this quarter is tantamount to the raising of the sword.
"Mr Sean MacBride [leader of Browne's party, Clan Na Phoblachta] insisted that I should call on Dr Michael Browne, a member of the Episcopal Committee. [Dr Browne was one of Bishop Eamonn Casey's predecessors].
"Dr Browne was a big man, well over six feet tall, his height enhancing the long black soutane with its thousand and one split pea-size scarlet buttons. Meeting him, I wondered how on earth he'd have the patience to do and undo all those buttons. A concealed zip, perhaps?
"The bishop had a round soft baby face with shimmering clear cornflower-blue eyes, but his mouth was small and mean. Around his great neck was an elegant glinting gold episcopal chain with a simple pectoral gold cross. He wore a ruby ring on his plump finger and wore a slightly ridiculous tiny skull-cap on this noble head. The well-filled semi-circular cummerbund and sash neatly divided the lordly prince into two.
"He handed me a silver casket in which lay his impeccable handmade cigarettes. "These cigarettes' he intoned, I had to have made in Bond Street'. Then he offered me a glass of champagne. I always like champagne in the afternoon' he informed me in his rich round voice... My feeling of awe was mixed with a sense of astonishment that this worldly sybarite considered himself to be a follower of the humble Nazarene Jesus Christ].
"I reflected that one more Judas was bad enough, but twelve of thei must be some kir *Our discussion on the mother and child health scheme was cursory. He showed no sign of having any serious interest in or objection to the scheme other than its cost... Socialist Organiser No. 525 page 11 Our discussíon was mainly concerned with what he feared must be the increase in the 'burden of the rates and taxes' needed to pay for the scheme...
"Finally, on 31 March 1 set out to meet Cardinal Dalton, of Armagh. He was a pleasant, withdrawn, scholarly-looking man. Our conversation was stilted, formal, and with the exception of one brief period, banal and inconsequential. The Cardinal gave the impression that he was politely wondering what on earth he was doing sharing his luncheon table with this odd, earnest, young man who was clearly preoccupied with an abstruse and awkward health problem... It is important to note, however, that the Cardinal made no attempt to answer the one crucial and pertinent question that I did put to him, about the use of Aneurin Bevan's National Health Service by Catholics in Northern Ireland. His disdainful reply smacked of royalty standing on its dignity: 'We are prepared neither to apologise, nor to explain'."
The coalition Cabinet bowed to the hierarchy. Browne was forced to resign. Let Noel Browne describe his Cabinet meeting:
*I reflected that one Judas was bad enough but twelve of them must be some kind of record, even in Ireland.
"Grudgingly the Taoiseach allowed my request that I ask every one of the Cabinet the question 'Do you accept?' ... First I asked the Labour leader Everett, then the patrician McGilligan. Difficult to believe, there was no difference between the landlord and the peasant. Then from [Labour deputy] Norton, prostrate obeisance. Michael Keyes, a Labour minister... was the only one to demur meekly, "They shouldn't be allowed to do this' But he too nodded his head. Sean MacEoin [a hero of Ireland's war of independence] was outraged that I had even dared to question him. Angrily he blustered, 'How dare you invite me to disobey my church?' The hierarchy had spoken, in no uncertain terms.
"He asked, 'Who would oppose the positive teaching of those entitled to teach?' Then he went on ingenuously, and with a welcome edge of blacksmith's humour, I don't want to get a belt of a crazier'..
"Later Taoiseach [Prime Minister] Costello was to say, 'As a Catholic, I obey my authorities." [Sean] MacBride was quoted as saying, "Those in the government who are Catholics are bound to accept the views of their church' Mr Costello shrugged off any claim he might have had to being Taoiseach in a sovereign government by the letter he sent to the Archbishop saying that the government would readily and immediately acquiesce in a decision of the hierarchy."
did
Scan page 12
Socialist Organiser No. 525 page 12
----- pull-quotes -----
Foot, for example - was heavily influenced by life in wartime Britain."
of record, even in Ireland."