South Africa: towards the final showdown?
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
1 action on a scale you have mass have never seen before"
That's how Nelson Mandela spelt out the new confrontational approach that the leadership of the African National Congress seem to have adopted towards their erstwhile negotiating partners, the National Party government of F. W. De Klerk.
The ANC leaders are now talking about a general strike. They want to force the Pretoria regime to back down from some of its more outrageous attempts to build in a white veto during what is rather euphemistically called "the transition to democracy".
It would be tempting to dismiss all this as so much hot air: yet more ultimata from the ANC, yet more threats of mass action designed merely to get negotiations going again. Especially when Nelson Mandela has talked of working class resistance as "the most reliable deadlock breaking mechanism".
But that would be a big mistake. As David Beresford, a Guardian journalist, normally sympathetic to the ANC, has put it:
"Peace has never seemed so far away as now; the political killings are running at an average of about 12 a day and the government's attitude towards the climate of violence is reflected in its continued failure to act over allegations that the head of military intelligence is a brutal murderer and that the head of the police forensic services is a mass poisoner...
"On the admission of the government's own officials, the hope of the De Klerk administration is to lock the country for a decade, if not longer, into a transitional constitution, which - as interim compromises already being urged by Pretoria would suggest - would fall far short of a democratic ideal."
Beresford then goes on to suggest ever so obligingly that the ANC leadership are both over-optimistic and rather complacent.
"There is an argument, used by ANC officials, that there is a dynamic in South African society which will force the government into a settlement acceptable to the majority of the population. "The government is in a crisis so deep that it has no choice but to settle, was how their chief negotiator, Mohammed Valli Moosa, put it in the immediate aftermath of the breakdown of talks at Codesa.
"But that is a perception the government may not share. On present evidence it seems quite happy with only halt a miracle, seemingly in the expectation that it will still be enough to have its international audience on their feet, cheering."
So, it could just be in Pretoria's interest to draw the ANC, and the broader liberation movement, into "In short, the Interim Government confrontation. A general strike would open up a series of possibilities:
• the government backs down, the action is called off and the ANC are able to force the pace of change; this will only delay confrontation since significant concessions will rekindle the far-right;
• Pretoria digs in its heels. The general strike passes beyond the level of a controlled protest and takes on the dimensions of May '68 in France; the question of 'who rules?' is raised;
• a massacre of the poorly, if at all, armed black workers' movement, as the clock turns back to 1948;
But the most likely scenario by far is:
government cial kind (MGOASK). To quote the South African socialist paper Vukari Basebenzi:
"While more and more people are beginning to speak about the possibility of a coup, most of them still talk about a counter-revolutionary right-wing coup. But this is muddled political thinking. The further development of capitalism in SA requires that certain social, economic and political changes have to be brought about in a world, by the way, where the immediate threat of socialist revolution is absent. If such changes cannot be brought about by peaceful and democratic means, they are going to be brought about by vio lent means, i.e. by means of military government.
"In short, the - Interim Government everybody is prattling about is more likely to be a military government than anything else.
"Such a MGOASK would "level the playing field' and after a while call together a Constituent Assembly. The Assembly would meet under circumstances where most of the genuinely representative organisations of the oppressed and exploited people, including the trade unions, would have been destroyed, handcuffed to the state or capital, or weakened through decapitation. Under such circumstances, a "non-racial", "democratic' even if disunited, South Africa will emerge from the Constituent Assembly, one that will be 'safe' for capital and for imperialism."
Such a government could expect to continue to get the support of foreign capital. That is the logic of Beresford's argument when he talks about the international audience cheering "only half a miracle"
Vukari Basebenzi has underlined this point:
"We are living through the most dangerous period of our history. In saying this, we are not even thinking of the hardships that our people are suffering. We are not thinking of the mindless murder, the state-inspired and state-supported terror against activists and civilians. We are not thinking of the soaring crime rate, the muggings, rapes, brutal robberies and murders. We are not thinking of the chaos in most black schools. We are not thinking of the shameful unemployment, the many grown men and women who sit along the roads begging for work or for food.
"All these things, and many others, are but the symptoms of a system that is dying rapidly but is not yet dead.
"We are thinking of something that more and more people are beginning to speak about openly, if belatedly. We are thinking about the spectre of military rule in South Africa. While everyone fondly expects that before the end of 1992, we shall have a (not democratically-elected) Interim Government of National Unity (IGNU) 'in place', , one in which the ANC and the NP will be 'the main players'. , some of us are less certain.
"We have said before that there is not only one outcome to the present situation. Just because most people desire a peaceful negotiated settlement, this does not mean that it and it alone will happen. So far, we have had much negotiation but precious little peace...
"In our view the highly likely outcome of the process of transition is in fact a military government of a special kind...
"Whatever De Klerk & Co. say, they represent only a tiny fraction of the people of this country...
"This is not a fairy tale. We are very likely to be faced with this reality. For those of us on the left, this means that we have to consider our strategy and tactics much more carefully. We would make a fatal mistake if we were to think that the peaceful negotiated settlement is 'the only game in town' as every liberal in South Africa is telling us every day."
Vukpri Bazalı sa ama kemo LO „ a bredh wa tslay South African grouping.
Scan page 8
It is time to fight back against the onslaught on education By a Central Line guard Most readers of Socialist Organiser will have seen our articles about the current attacks on tubeworkers. Since November last year when the Company Plan was announced, we have had regular and in-depth corerage of the bosses' attempts to implement their plan and the response of the unions.
The Company Plan would mean 5-10,000 job losses, workers forced to reapply for their own jobs, personal contracts, performance pay, contracting out, massive productivity changes... the list goes on.
It represents the most fundamental attack on the jobs and conditions of tubeworkers in the history of the Tube.
An attack on this scale clearly requires a response on a wider scale if there is to be any chance t defeating it. And a determined figl from the tubeworkers would have helped to rally the broader movement and stop the retreat. Nevertheless, as we reported last to which the RMT NEC responded by dropping the strike. As we said — a disaster for tubeworkers.
But not everyone thought so. At the May DC Patrick Sikorski argued that on a "mature assessment of the balance of forces" it had been correct to call off the strike (of course no mention is made of this in Socialist Outlook), and that we had in fact won a victory because the threat of a strike had supposedly saved the PT&R including seniority, kept the policy of no compulsory redundancies and ensured all negotiations would take place through the current machinery.
However, both the machinery of negotiations and the PT&R are up for negotiation immediately! Management have made it clear they want them to go. There's no concession here.
The claim about compulsory redundancy is breathtaking in its cheek: management said "it remains LUL policy to avoid compulsory redundancies... it will only be possible to maintain this policy if there is no disruption to the runUNDEMOCRAȚS UNFAIR
----- pull-quotes -----
everybody is prattling about is more likely to be a military government than anything else.