Labour and the mood changes
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Even as he was throwing in the towel as leader, Kinnock was preparing for a renewed drive to distance Labour from the unions. At first it looked as if the pro• cess was unstoppable: one member one vote for constituency selections of parliamentary candidates, ending the unions' 40% block vote there, went through May's meeting of the Labour National Executive with minimal opposition. The same meeting also agreed to dust off the 1990 plan to reduce the union block vote Meanwhile, Smith and Gould were engaged in a public Dutch auction to play down their union connec tions and to present a vision of a new-look, union-free Labour Party (though that did not prevent Smith from accepting the backing of the AEEU leadership, who did not feel it necessary to consult their members on In the last week or two things seem to have changed. John Prescott, the only candidate to have clearly defended the union link during the leadership contest [although for several years he has backed Kinnock consistently on the National Executive), has emerged is a possible front-runner in the deputy leadership race. The executives of NUPE, the GPMU and the RMT have all backed Prescott; ASLEF and UCATT At the recent MSF conference, no final decisions on he leadership elections were taken, but a distinct proPrescott mood was in evidence. At NCU conference his week Gould seemed to have made a "left turn" to read off Prescott, no doubt helped by his detailed More importantly, there is a growing feeling among ictivists throughout the unions that Kinnock's unionlashing has gone too far. Tom Sawyer, deputy general ecretary of NUPE and for many years Kinnock's clos ist confidant in the union bureaucracy, is a useful In a remarkable speech at NUPE's conference, jawyer came out with the catchy little slogan, "No ay, no pay". For anyone who didn't get the message, iawyer spelled it out: "While we fund the party, we'll It was a big change from his earlier kite-flying for innock, and a close examination of Sawyer's speech eveals that he said nothing specific at all about last reek's National Executive vote. But what else are Bill Morris of the TGWU has been a little more iplomatic, but arguably clearer. He wants a "council I peace between the unions and the Labour Party, Delegates at the recent round of union conferences re all reporting the same thing: rank and file activists ncluding those who in the past have been critical of te way the block vote has been manipulated) have ad enough of Labour's union-bashing. There is a rowing understanding that while the block vote may eed to be reformed, it has to be defended. At stake is athing less than the future of a nolitical lahonr mava.
she flailed Selection rage and despair, Neil Kinnock UNIONS seems to be doing a passable impersonation of King Lear in one of his more selfpitying moments.
Everyone was to blame but himself.
Publicly, the tabloids bore the brunt of his No jobs, no hope, no future? anger - which was at least understandable.
But privately, Kinnock Sleeper and his clique were more than ever convinced that were the real cause of defeat.
AGAINST THES at conference from 90 to 70 percent.
TIDE the matter). Acadence at the diat few weeks ago I gave Bailey during the trial of two youths charged with murder.
At lam on a Monday morning last June, I found an old man, Giuseppe Melito, semiconscious on the pavement ure expected to follow suit.
across the road from where I live in South London, (as I reported in this column soon after). His head lay in a pool of blood, one knee doubled upright, the foot drawn in under him, his right arm wavcowledge of BT and its functioning. ing feebly, as he struggled back to a final brief state of consciousness and, with my help, rose to his feet and sat on a low wall.
Shocked and confused, he repeated in a weak voice veather-vane. What happened? What happened?"
What had happened was that he was attacked by a group of youths who met him by chance and robbed him of ave a say - it's as crude as that". about £100. They smashed This head with one blow from a club, took his wallet, and ran off, leaving him bleeding and unconscious by the roadside, as they might in a difreather-vanes for? ferent mood have shattered a street side lamp with a stone and ran off leaving the broken pieces where they fell.
Struggling back to conefore irreparable damage is done"
sciousness, Mr Melito displayed a great will to pull himself together, and walked, with help, to the ambulance.
But the will to live was not enough. Soon afterwards he fell into a coma brought on by internal bleeding from which he never awoke. He died two days later. He was ment in Britain. LUTC Italian, an unemployed waiter, 62 years old.
When I saw that old man, with the rivulets of blood which had worked through his hair running down his face, rising up out of the bloody mess on the pavement, struggling to regain control of his faculties, walking slowly to the ambulance as if balancing a great weight, I felt that I could myself have smashed the heads of the savages who attacked him. I felt that way for a long time afterwards.
"The urge to hit and retaliate is a natural one. But no-one, and especially no youngster, should be consignec to the medieval archipelago of Britain's prison network.
And now, there they were in the dock, a few feet from the witness stand in which I stood, two clean-faced and sensible-looking boys, one 17 and the other 16, children essentially, sitting still and impassive in sharp formal suits as the shape of their future lives was being determined by officials dressed in strange, archaic clothes and wigs.
They had been on bail for a year, and now docilely turned up to submit to the court.
I no longer felt like doing them over. I was not sure what I felt.
They had been willing to plead guilty to manslaughter, that is, to killing as an unintended and accidental byproduct of the robbery, which they admitted. The Crown prosecutor insisted that it was murder.
I had not seen the killers even from a distance, so my own evidence had to do with finding Mr Melito and the state he was in. I did not have to ask myself if I should help convict boys who might in some way have been victims of a police frame-up.
The doctor who took the dead man's skull and brain apart insisted that the damage could only have been done with a powerful and deliberate blow from a club or a stone.
They used photos to illustrate the evidence. In one of the photos taken the morning after the attack, the pavement where Giuseppe had lain is covered with red dog-paw marks all around the thick slick of blood at the centre.
The argument in court was between, on one side, very teeble defence attempts to argue that Giuseppe : Melito might have broken his skull by accidentally hitting the fender of a car at the footpath's edge as he fell, and on the other gruesome medical evidence of the nature and effects of the blow which killed him.
After a trial lasting three days, the jury brought in a gullty verdict. The 17 year old boy who struck the blow was sentenced to be detained at "Her Majesty's Pleasure" -and the 16 year old to four years detention. I was not in court to see what that did to their composure.
Last June it had seemed to me unlikely that the attackers would ever be caught. There were no witnesses who could identify them.
They were caught because one of the gang, in circumstances I do not know, told on the others and gave evidence against them.
An edgy, glum boy of maybe 19, with a little clipped moustache, he seemed a lot more disturbed and unhappy, as he hung around waiting to have his say, than did the two composed, or hardfaced, boys in the dock.
Given the way the British police operate — as shown recently in the Birmingham Six case - was I right to "help the police" and give evidence, even of the sort I gave? I think I was, though there is a fine line on the other side of which it would not have been right.
We are not anarchists. The state is necessary. It is right, other things being equal that highway robbers and murderers should be suppressed, even by those courts and police whose prime activity is to preserve bourgeois property.
The fate of the two young murderers, condemned to the hellish conditions of British prison life, is a separate question.
All my urges towards vengeance or retaliation were gone, or paralysed, at the sight of those youngsters in the dock. The older of them would not long ago have been on trial for his life, facing the hangman with his Statelicensed rope, and now there he was facing an eternity of painful days in a dehumanisbrutalising prison system.
The trial was a quaint pantomime, from the splendid scarlet-robed judge, looking like a cartoon but intelligent and businesslike, to the more tackily-costumed penny-plain black and white barristers.
It was all quite unreal and far removed from Giuseppe Melito's bloody head and the unseen blood seeping out inside his head, killing him; all removed, too, from hellish netherworld to which it was the entrance for those two boys.
The urge to hit out and retaliate is a natural one. But no-one, and especially no youngster, should be consigned to the medieval archipelago of Britain's prison network - to a torture and degradation from which he can not possibly emerge a better or a more civilised human being, more fit to live with his fellows.
Scan page 5
A coke found ry in Poland spews out fumes that contribute By Les Hearn he 19th century clergy man Thomas Malthus argued that whereas human populations would increase exponentially (like compound interest on a loan), the supplies of food could only increase arithmetically (ie steadily, like simple interest). The result would be poverty, famine and a crash back to previous levels of population.
Malthusian ideas remain popular, being simple and apparently logical. They also tend to place the blame for poverty etc, on those who are having large families, usually people in the Third World.
Even though this hypothesis was the catalyst to the formation of Darwin's theory of evolution, it has been comprehensively disproved in the ensuing years. The population supported by the Earth is some 10 times that at the time of Malthus and yet, at a global level, there enough food and more, to He also reckoned without the self-limiting factor that leads couples to restrict the size of their families when infant mortality fails and when economic pressures that favour large families abate. So, along with the Catholic Church, we have say that the size of the world's population is not t "So, along with the Catholic Church, we have to say that the size of the world's population is not the major factor in causing poverty malnutrition and pressure to cultivate forest areas." major factor in causing poverty, malnutrition and pressure to cultivate forest areas.
However, the availability birth control is an importan issue of human rights to co trol fertility. It should be available (but not enforced, as it has been in India and If there is a population times or even mo in the Third Worl here is almost universa mate scientists that emissions of "greenhouse" gases, most notably carbon dioxide from burning fossil fuels, have set in train a warming of the atmosphere.
There is also almost universal agreement that this will be, on balance, bad for the world's climate, sea levels, agriculture. And yet the USA has forced the dropping of a key section of the Climate Change Convention, due for signing at the Earth Summit.
This would have laid a legally-binding commitment on signatories to merely "stabilise" CO, emissions at 1990 levels by 2000. That would be nowhere near the 20% cut called for by many scientists. It was however too much for the USA and the target has been replaced by a "guideline" . Now Western governments will only take action if everyone else does first! only now being appreciated. For instance, in one Peruvian bush, 43 species of ant have been found, more than occur in the whole of the British Isles. A survey in the forests of Brunei has found 400 species of beetle in one tree, has found 162 plants of food or medicinal value so far. The Third World is a major source of genes for improving food crops and of new medical drugs. For example. the Madagascan periwinkle the basis of a $160 million Organiser would have required signatories, mainly Third World Countries, to catalogue and protect their wildlife and would have required richer countries to compensate them for the extra expense doing this.
----- pull-quotes -----
INSIDE A around in post-
Too many peo- ple?
Global Warming