The poverty of anti-Zionism
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-05-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
The point here is not to polemicise about our current political positions on Israel and the Palestinian question. Israel has given itself the most reactionary government of its history, and the Palestinian people need our solidarity now more than ever.
But, for many decades, shady areas have remained both in our awareness and our assessment of the fact of Israel. It is of that we wish to speak here.
For many years, anti-Zionist violence allowed people to escape "white man's" guilt cheaply. Directing anti-colonialist thunderbolts at the former oppressed allowed them to evade the responsibility which the West should rightly feel about the Holocaust.
The Trotskyists of the time followed behind, and despite violently anti-Zionist slogans, the Trotskyists were sometimes accused of... Zionism.
It is true that for a number of the Trotskyists there were big issues here. They were concerned to step up their anti-Zionism in order to distance themselves from any suspicion of belonging. Thus, for those militants of Jewish "origin" (the expression behind which these ashamed Jews hid themselves), Jewishness found no place in their commitment. Although their Jewish identity and Auschwitz represented, in many cases, the starting point of their rebellion, that identity, experienced as the shame of a religious particularism, or, worse, a political (Zionist) particularism, could not decently be taken up.
To be suspect, as a Jew, of belonging to an international plot rather than a people, was alas not new.
Zionist hydra, State of many tentacles: the words speak for themselves. No other State in the world, however racist and colonialist, has ever received such adjectives. The demonisation of Israel can only remind us that here we are dealing with a special other State in the wi however racist and colonialist, has received such adjectives. The demonisation of Israel can only remind us that here we are dealing with a special State... a Jewish state, perhaps".
State... a Jewish state, perhaps.
Official anti-Zionism is only the presentable display of the secular anti-semitism of many countries.
In the bookshops of Arab or Latin American countries, one can without fear of any censorship (that which is called anti-imperialism is not condemned here find openly anti-semitic works such as the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. In Cairo, Mein Kampf, that celebrated Third-Worldist work, is freely on sale in Arabic.
It is true that the nation of the late Nasser (who widely influenced Arab nationalism granted the Jews a delay of a few days to leave the nation: all, bourgeois or proletarians, communists or others, had to be deprived of their nationality. They could be stateless in France, in Britain, in the USA... or choose the only country which, in spite of them not choosing it, chose them despite themselves and offered them citizenship, Israel.
[After 1948] the Jews of the Arab world could no longer envisage a return to the ancestral ways: a half-muted life in the shadow of the Islamic crescent which, after the departure of the European powers, affirmed itself as the bulwark of a new-found identity.
Real refugees, many of them - Syrian, Iraqi, Egyptian Jews - Jews who were refugees in their heads, because they came from countries where there was no longer any future possible for Jews - these people found Israel rather than choosing it. As the outlet for their exile, much more than the cause of their departure, Israel represented, for two-thirds of the Israeli population called oriental Jews, the only possible coun try.
Anti-Zionist discourse prefers to talk about the blond Western warriors. The idea of Israel being the "spearhead of imperialism" gives credit to this partially erroneous thesis. Although Israel's policy corresponds today to imperialist interests in the region, it is false to consider the creation of the state as a simple manipulation by the imperialist West. It took wars, years of negotiation, and struggle against British power, before the State of Israel was recognised. The Soviet Union was the first state to recognise this "puppet state" ... of imperialism.
β’he rhetoric of Arab nationalism has not hesitated to identify Israel as a new Crusader state, and thus to give another symbolic meaning to expelling the "foreigners" from the sacred land It is an obvious historical error, because the Jews who arrived in Israel were not emissaries of a Christian and Western empire, but refugees and survivors from one of the greatest massacres of our time, victims of that "barbarous West" whose racist and imperialist ideology would find its most point. But the violent and total form in Nazism.
It is almost dumbfounding to observe that the argument [that certain peoples are not real nations with rights] although no longer applied to the Palestinians [as it was by the Zionist pioneers] continues to figure in the ideological array of some militants.
The Jews are thus not a people, much less a nation, but at most a religious minority who can enjoy freedom of worship in the democratic - and Arab - Palestine.
It seems odd that, for internationalists It seems odd that only people in the world can be an exception to the common analysis -the Jewish people - tha the right of self-determination cannot function in this case.
like us, only one people in the world can be an exception to the common analysis - the Jewish people - that the right of self-determination, which seems in the light of history to be one of the apposite of Marxist principles, cannot function in this case.
Finally - and this would deserve a longer discussion - it may appear regrettable, for the Jews as for the other peoples, that the Holocaust should have contributed so heavily to a form of national identification.
For sure, there should be no question of accepting Israel's claims of direct inheritance from the Holocaust. The memory of the victims of the Holocaust belongs to no- one, just as it has served no end: this untypical massacre cannot explain anything, for it simply is not explained itself.
Nonetheless, it remains true that Israel, more than any other State, can claim a portion of legitimacy from it.
Those are the fruits of history: a history which we did not write and in which we had so little influence!
To us it falls to transform that history, without forgetting and without obsession, knowing that oppression engenders oppression and that no one oppression can justify another.
angll abrid from the April-May issue of "Critique Communiste", magazine of the French Trotskyist group LCR. Almost the whole issue is given over to Palestine, Israel, and Zionism. Besides interviews and historical articles, there are two other articles debating current attitudes to Israel.
The Lebanese Trotskyist Salah Jaber criticises a book by Abraham Serfaty for refusing to recognise that an Israeli Jewish nation exists, and that "any real democrat ic solution of the Israel-Palestine question must include the recognition of the fact of an Israeli nation and guarantee it the rights of a nation, and thus the freedom to maintain itself as a separate entity on the express condition that it be no longer founded upon the national oppression of the Arabs".
Christian Picquet also declares that "it cannot be a matter of answering one injustice by another. It cannot be denied that a long and complex historic process of Israeli nation". However, he refers to a leftCOEL 1970s, "a democratic state in which Arabs and Jews would enov equal nationa rights and the same responsibilities", withBe nightse shou ude the
Scan page 13
CULTURAL FRONT Organiser