Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why Smith and Gould are yesterday's men: How Labour broke

Socialist Organiser no. 524, 28 May 1992 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,282 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Cautiously butclearly BryanıGould and JohnıSmüth are proposing chatthen abour Pestshout cordopse hom The wiennis nonemoices conessed after abour ostitsathird Generall Electionan anowhe B50 This reply, by Brian Pearce, was published in the Trotskyist weekly i henNewstetter inJanuam/ml 961.

The attenptswhenitpacut Winkswwithithermons come tomnothingswith a massimovement developing for unilateralinuclear disarmamentu theirseifhenYoung Socialistsi andäncneasing mank-and iler in durs trial.

militancyathe labour Partyis ishiitiin herary-960s This week we reprint PartiT womi he articler hüch mer Ashdown advocates retaining the anti-union laws. Now Labour wants to go along with the Liberals on this -forgetting the history of a fight to become independent Ramsay MacDonald: his ideal was a labour movement just sufficiently lively to give him something to use in horse-trading thestrade untons. Ten are towards the ne he Liberal Party, reflecting employers towards the workers became colder than ever towards the attempts of trade unionists to get themselves adopted as Liberal-Labour' candidates. Some quite insulting rebuffs were handed out. This is what Ramsay MacDonald meant when he wrote explaining why such as he had taken the path of independent labour politics which they didn't feel at all enthusiastic about: 'We didn't leave the Liberals. They kicked us out, and slammed the door in our faces."

The 1897 engineering lockout, the ruthless beating down of the engineering workers and imposing upon them of humiliating terms of settlement (the basis for the York Memorandum' still with us, designed to make plain who was master in the works, left many of the most conservative section of the British workers in in those days with little grounds for doubt that times had changed.

In 1900 the socialists of the Independent Labour Party and the capitalists — and no more other groups made their historic first breakthrough into an organized relationship with the trade unions, with the establishment of the Labour Representation Committee. A limited number of trade unions at last agreed to associate with the socialist societies in promoting parliamentary candidates who should be independent of either of the ruling-class parties.

It was the ruling class which, still not grasping what was happening 'down below', gave several more still hesitant trade unions the necessary final shove to bring them in behind the Labour Representation Committee. Following a series of articles in The Times which called into question the very existence of trade unionism, the House of Lords upheld against appeal a judge's decision which dealt a practical blow, in terms of hard cash, at the whole functioning of trade unions This was the "Taff Vale judgment, when the railwaymen's union found themselves forced to pay out enormous damages to a company which had incurred loss through a strike they had called. If this was the law, no strike could take place anywhere on any issue without the risk of financial ruin for the union concerned. At long last a number of trade union leaders saw the point - the working class must put itself in an independent political position from which it could compel changes in the law in its own interest, instead of relying on the sweet reasonableness of one or other group of the ruling class. In 1901 and 1902, after "Taff Vale' the Labour Representation Committee received a big accession of strength - though still, it is worth recalling, the miners remained wedded to Liberalism and did not come in until eight years later, after a lot of 'unofficial"

activity had been put in at lodge and district level. The decision to create and adhere to the Labour Party was not hastily or lightlytaken by the British working class.

"The working class must put itself in compel changes in the law in its own sweet reasonableness one or other group of the ruling class."

As already mentioned, a lot of the leading men in the movement had had to be pushed every inch of the way into their new political stand, and they wanted even now to separate from the Liberals to as small an extent as possible. Few had any idea of operating as more than a 'pressure group' - though now at least nominally outside the Liberal Party instead of inside it. They did not in the least contemplate supplanting the liberals as one of the two major parties in the country and of course there could be no question in their minds of becoming the government of the country. When, therefore, the Liberals, shocked at last into awareness of the working class getting out of hand politically, took steps through private negotiation to show themselves 'conciliatory, a man like MacDonald, secretary to the LRC, was only too pleased to meet them halfway.

MacDonald's correspondence with the Chief Liberal Whip had to be kept a secret from all but a few of MacDonald's colleagues, lest some crude-minded types might take exception to it. So early began the practice of talks between Labour leaders and the ruling class behind the backs of the movement as a whole. The outcome was a 'gentleman's agreement' for the LRC to restrict its candidates to certain seats, in return for which the Liberals Liberals would not oppose them in some of these. Characteristic was Macdonald's reaction to the news of Arthur Henderson's victory as a Labour candidate at Barnard Castle, over both Liberal and Tory opponents: he welcomed it as strengthening his bargaining power in dealings with the Liberals, but hoped it would not encourage the 'wild men' to demand openly that Labour should go it alone in every possible constituency. Just sufficient life in the working-class movement to give them something to use in horse-trading with the capitalists, and no more; that has always been the ideal of the Right wing.

When, therefore, a group of 50 Labour MPs were returned in the 1906 general election, which gave a Liberal majority, there was heavy dragging of feet to do no more than accord critical support to the new government, merely pressuring it a bit in the direction of social reform. The socialists in the Labour Party (as it was now formally called) faced the task of forcing the pace against this entrenched resistance. In 1907 the socialist Victor Grayson was run as candidate, against Liberal and Tory, in a traditional Liberal seat, by local Labour organizations who defied the ban imposed by headquarters. His triumphant success encouraged the Left in the movement but infuriated the 'statesmen' of the Parliamentary Labour Party. They received him into their select company in the House of Commons with the same enthusiasm as the Gaitskellites lately received Michael Foot. A typical incident occurred in 1908 when Grayson tried to protest in the House against the welcome by the Liberal Government to a visit by the Tsar of Russia, but the official Labour spokesman at once got up to move the closure! from whichever side it comes. needs to be resisted tooth nail... the rights o the socialist societies, such as had initiated the very creation of ti party, need to be restored and confirmed."

Nevertheless, the growth of socialist influence within the party compelled the leaders to apply for admission to the Second International, so associating the Labour Party with openly socialist parties in other countries. This was the occasion on which Lenin proposed that the Labour Party be accepted into membership of the International on the carefullydefined grounds that fit represents the first step on the part of the really proletarian organizations of Britain towards a conscious class policy and towards a socialist

Scan page 11

age

----- pull-quotes -----

was monthe leftwather then the right. began in Socialist Organiserto23.

an independent political position from which it coula

interest, instead of relying on the

"Every move to divorce the part) from the unions,

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 524

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →