"The key thing is to unite the Irish working class."
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-05-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
From page is entwined and interlinked with another "Irish Question" - the question of the Protestant minority in the whole island.
Two thirds of the people in the Six County state - numbering one million - want the British army there: the hated "British army of occupation" in Armagh is "our army" in Antrim and Down and other areas where the ProtestantUnionists are the overwhelming majority.
If that army were to withdraw without a political settlement - in basic terms, if the existing state were to abdicate - replacement states would be created in what is now the Six Counties by way of open war between Catholics and Protestants for control of villages, towns, bridges, hills, roads. You would get what you got between Arabs and Jews when the British state abdicated in Palestine back in 1947-8.
You would get what you have now in the former Yugoslav state: communal war in the form of freewheeling sectarian-ethnic murder, and what in the former Yugoslavia is now called "Ethnic Cleansing" -the killing and driving out of pockets of aliens in territory controlled by "the others".
A "Yugoslav scenario" would be a certainty - unless: unless some other military force were to play the role Britain plays now; the United Nations, a European army. Should the 26 Counties attempt to do it, you would most likely get a Protestant IRA doing what the Provisional IRA does now against a "Dublin" army. It is one of the central patterns in 20th century Irish history that there is. migration of postures and attitudes back and forth across the Protestant-Unionist, Catholic-Nationalist divide. The first Irish to revolt against Britain this century were the Protestants, who organised and armed - backed by the Tory Party - to stop the preWorld War I Liberal government setting up a Home Rule government in Dublin, with control over the whole of Ireland.
In a "Yugoslav scenario" sizeable chunks of the Six Counties -areas like Armagh - would probably secede to the "Southern" Irish state. The Protestants, having been expelled from the United Kingdom - that would have to be the first act of the scenario summed up in the slogan "Troops Out Now" - would form a state of their own.
So, if we do not want that, we must support the status quo as the best we can get? But the status quo is monstrous, untenable except by the repression of the Six County Catholics!
Britain has stopped sectarian civil war for the last 20 years -using systematic violence against the Catholics - but, by maintaining the partition framework that collapsed in sectarian disorder in 1969, it has simultaneously been priming, and continues to prime, a Catholic-Protestant civil war on The sectarian divide. Photo: Andrew Moore the Yugoslav scale.
The people of the Six Counties need a radical, democratic solution, not bloody stop-gaps.
So then, since the present Six County "solution" is unviable, we should demand that Britain takes the only other option: "troops out, soon" - that Britain should announce a date for British withdrawal and force the Protestants into a united Ireland under Catholic majority rule?
This is - paradoxically - what both the Provisional IRA and Fianna Fail, the main nationalist party in the South, demand, though the demand is not always put in plain English. Both Provisional IRA and Fianna Fail belong to the old strain of Irish politics which looked for a British solution to the intra-Irish conflict: that was what the pre-World War I Nationalist Home Rule Party stood for, turning itself into a helpless appendage of the British Liberal Party, which was expected to coerce the Protestant Irish into a united Ireland. The Liberals betrayed them, uniting with the Tories to partition the country along the present grotesque lines. It is Northern Ireland's one-third Catholic population - a bigger minority in the Six Counties than all of Ireland's Protestants would be in a 32 county state - which has been coerced and oppressed for 70 years.
Can our conclusion be that Britain has been coercing the wrong Irish people? That a united Ireland now is the only solution, and if the one million Protestants have to be coerced to get it, then so be it?
This is where Bishop Casey and the banning of the Guardian must be brought into the picture. They tell us why the idea of a forced unity in a majority - Catholic -run 32 County Ireland is as big a nonsense as the present Six County partition settlement is, and why a 32 County state on the basis of coercing the Protestants could not be any more tenable or viable than the present Six County state is.
Protestants believed that "Home Rule would be Rome Rule" and - though there was more to it - refused to be a minority in a united Ireland. 70 years of 26 County "Home Rule" has proved them right, not wrong.
The Bishop Caseys have ruled independent Ireland; the Bishop Caseys still rule Ireland as the clerical hand in the pseudo-Republican political glove. Casey has fled, but the Guardian cannot get past the customs because it tells Irish women who want one where and how to arrange an abortion in defiance of the diktats of the other Caseys.
The Bishop Casey business is ugly beyond words: a sexually normal man agrees in boyhood to undertake a life of self-suppression; he then evolves into the sophisticated, rich and worldly prince of the modern church who breaks the rules he enforces on other people, and lives a life of malignant hypocrisy. It is the tale of a cold-hearted father and of a hurt, revengeful ex-lover, which became the centre of an awful media circus: all of it is ugly and hateful and pitiful.
In the course of Catholic-Nationalist Ireland's struggle for independence, the Catholic clergy gained tremendous power and influence. Long persecuted, the priests of Irish Catholicism merged with the people. The bishops attacked revolutionary nationalists - hell is not hot enough nor eternity long enough to punish them, said one bishop of the Fenians -but the priests, on the whole, kept in step, a little behind, with the people.
Bishops - such as Dr. Fogarty — as well as priests played a central role in building up the Sinn Fein movement that won three quarters of the Irish Parliamentary seats in the election of November 1918 (for less than 60% of the vote). The Irish clergy had more than a little in common with the Iranian mullahs who set up the Islamic Republic in 1979.
Partition cut off the bulk of the Protestant population - including the big bulk of the Irish proletariat, and thus, amongst other things, it crippled the labour movement south and north of the border. In the Dail debate on the Guardian affair, one deputy talked of the 26 County state as an "infantile theocracy". In fact, 70 years ago, the 26 County state did evolve into something not far from a theocracy - a theocracy mediated through the form of a liberal-democratic state, but more a theocracy than a modern liberal-democratic state. Many things have changed since then -the Catholic church has changed -but the Catholic church still has immense power in the 26 Counties.
The Irish state is not now a state into which the Six County Protestants will peacefully agree to merge or be merged.
Neither defence of the status quo; nor advocacy of forced union; nor the irresponsible Troops Out Now (and then we will see after the big bang) + none of these are acceptable policy for socialists:
The key thing is to find a way to begin to unite the Irish working. class, Protestant and Catholic. north and south of the border.
The only way that can ever be done is through consistent democгасу: mutual recognition of the legitimacy of each other's fundamental traditions by Protestant and Catholic alike;
* commitment to fight chauvinism in both camps and an active campaign against the oppression of the Catholics now;
* commitment by the Catholic workers to oppose any future oppression of the Protestants - the future oppression which they fear in a unitary Irish state where they would be a helpless minority.
The "war" of the Provisional IRA is now almost wholly a war against the Irish protestant unionists, and it should be condemned - in the same breath and for essentially the same reasons as we condemn the Protestant murder gangs - by all who care about Ireland. The "Constitutional Question" dominates the north of Ireland to the virtual exclusion of everything else.
The two sectarian "solutions" to the "Constitutional Question" the status quo, or a unitary, all-Ireland state, against the will of the Protestants if necessary - are central elements of the present crisis: neither of them can ever be a solution. We repeat: the key thing is to provide a political basis on which Protestant and Catholic workers might unite.
The solution has to be one which rises above the present impasse: a consistently democratic solution can only be a United Federal Ireland in which Protestants have self-governing autonomy, if they want it, in their areas, and Catholic groups in mainly Protestant ones can have it too, if they want it. The other necessary part of a "constitutional framework" within which the working class could begin to unite is increasingly a reality: resumption of appropriately close voluntary links between Britain and Ireland.
That is the way the workers of Ireland - victims now of exploitation, unemployment, emigration, and poverty - will begin to put themselves in a condition to fight and win the necessary radical solution to their problems under capitalism north and south of the border - a socialist solution!
Scan page 6
Socialist Organiser No. 524 page 6
----- pull-quotes -----
"The Bishop Caseys still rule Ireland as the clerical hand the pseudo- Republican political glove.
"If the Army were the Army to withdraw without a political settlement... you would get what you have now in Yugoslavia.