[Mean Lane (SO 522) is wrong to think…]
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-05-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Mean Lane (SO 522) is wrong to think the Mothers' Union's decision to debate the legalisation and regulation of prostitution - as a way of combating the spread of AIDS - is a new departure.
Since the nineteenth century middle-class women's organisations "Any socialist/ feminist stance those women in prostitution."
have seen it as their business to press for state control of prostitutes to prevent the spread of disease.
Spread to whom? Middle class women, via their husbands who use prostitutes, ie. locate the problem with poor, largely powerless women rather than powerful men. In the process, increase the power of the state (representing those same powerful men) against the poor women.
Jean doesn't mention male prostitutes; is the Mothers' Union proposing they have their own brothels? That would be a departure.
Those bourgeois women know whose side they're on. Jean should think about the implications of her position.
Any socialist/feminist stance should start from find it hard to believe that Socialist Organiser refused to back Ken Livingstone for Party leader.
Once the Campaign Group adopted Livingstone, then all socialists should have called for a vote for Livingstone.
Socialist Organiser's valid criticisms showed why the left MPs organised in the Campaign Group of MPs should not have adopted Livingstone. There are a whole host of MPs in the Campaign Group who would have been politically better candidates.
Tony Benn would have been the best choice. However, Tony Benn declined to stand. Ken Livingstone was the only available left candidate.
What is the difference between Livingstone and solidarity with those women in prostitution. It's not the answer, but they are still our sisters and deserve at least to be listened to.
Overwhelmingly, prostitute organisations call for decriminalisation, not legalisation and regulation. They do not want compulsory testing and control of where they live.
Smith and Gould? Both Smith and Gould believe Labour should move further to the right, and erode its links with the trade unions.
Livingstone defends the links with the trade unions, believes Labour needs to shift to the left and adopt a more radical programme, and has called for a commitment to cut defence spending. This is far from being a Marxist programme, but it is better than what Smith and Gould offer.
Of course, Livingstone's anti-democratic manoeuvres by declaring his candidature before the Campaign Group had made a decision were a disgrace, and the left must not forget this.
Many of Livingstone's economic proposals are quack proposals and deserve a sharp critique from any journal claiming | to | be and Future If resources are made available - free condoms, HIV testing, health checks, needles, contraception, etc - they will (and do now) use them. They do not want state pimping which leaves them open to abuse by policemen and other agents of control.
Gerry Byrne West London Marxist. Livingstone's view that the tax proposals lost Labour the election is nonsense. Even the Economist states that Labour's tax plans did not cause the defeat. Labour's absence of a radical programme led many voters to stick with the devil they know.
The reaction of the left to the election defeat should be to argue for radical socialist policies to convince voters to break from the Tories. Central to this is the defence of the trade union link.
In the past Socialist Organiser has called for a vote for Livingstone in the NEC elections as he was standing as part of a left slate. The same argument applies to Livingstone's leadership candidacy.
Cleo Hill Manchester
----- pull-quotes -----
should start fron solidarity with