The madness of the CAP
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-05-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Millions of people are starving in southern Africa because drought and war have shattered their fragile agricultural economy.
At the same time, the European Community has decided to pay European farmers to take 15 per cent of their land out of production.
That is the way the capitalist market works -the laws of supply and demand and 'consumer sovereignty". More and more effort goes into concocting titbits for the overfed rich, while the poor starve because, having no money, they count for nothing in the marketplace.
The Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), which the EC has just decided to reform drastically, was launched in 1962. It was designed to smooth out the modernisation of West European agriculture, protecting it against competition from the US and easing the impact for the farmers who were an important part of the political base of many of the capitalist governments in the EC.
Modern technology has raised productivity in agriculture more than almost anywhere else. The average farm worker in the Netherlands produces $40,000-worth of output per year; in the US, $33,000; in "The socialist alternative is public ownership of the land and the large farms".
Italy, $18,000; in Poland, $2,000; in Mozambique, $73 (all figures for 1988).
Even within countries, the difference in productivity between the most modern farms and old fashioned small-holdings is much bigger than the difference between one factory and another.
The CAP fixed high guaranteed prices for agricultural products, based on the productivity of the less efficient farms; used EC money to buy up stocks to maintain those prices; exported the resulting surpluses outside the EC at knockdown prices; and put tariff barriers round the EC to stop imports bringing down the prices.
It has succeeded in smoothing the transformation of agriculture - in France, for example, larming's share of the workforce has fallen from 28% in 1950 to 6% today - but at the cost of pumping vast subsidies into the pockets of richer farmers. These mainstays of the political right become "socialist" advocates of state welfare pay-outs as soon as their own income is at stake!
A lot of the subsidies have been passed on to landlords, because CAP guarantees push up rents on farmland. The EC has decided on reform now for three reasons. Firstly, to help get an agreement in the crucial "Uruguay round" of world trade talks; secondly, because CAP payouts have become so expensive; and thirdly, because the decline in the farming population makes it easier to cut their pay-outs.
The reform will cut the guranteed prices and compensate farmers by direct payments on condition that they set aside 15% of their land.
The socialist alternative is public ownership of the land and the large farms, aid to the smaller farms to operate as cooperatives, and reorganisation of farm production in line with people's hunger rather than their wallets.