Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

More than an icon

Socialist Organiser no. 523, 14 May 1992 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 1,493 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Obituary With the tabloids already gearing themselves up for steamy revelations, and with a "shocking" book by her daughter about to be published, Marlene Dietrich, who died last week, aged 90, won't be allowed to rest in peace.

I liked her, or rather I liked the younger Dietrich, the actress in films like "Morocco" and "Blonde Venus" . She was different from the home-grown American stars; she had character as well as looks.

Though presented there was always something earthbound about Dietrich. She had irony, and a sense of humour. She never took love tragically, as Garbo did.

She played a range of roles from spy to housewife to femme fatale ("It took more than one man to change my name to Shanghai Lily"), but she never gave up her independence. If the roles were stereotypes, she wasn't.

Even in films that did little more than celebrate her looks, she was not just an icon. There was a human being in there somewhere, having a laugh at the expense of the men who worshipped her.

Women responded strength, to the way she broke the rules. She made trousers for women fashionable. Her very Image, smart, ironic, her own person even in the throes of love, was liberating.

Marlene, the trend-setter

Scan page 14

£8,000 fund target for Socialist Organise have in the wake of the Labour Our socialists stand firm against Fiddling the facts Our paper and the of the Labour right.

Alliance for Workers' Socialist Organiser is a Liberty are raising extra vehicle which can help to monies to develop our bring the socialist left strength in the Labour together.

Party and the trade unions. If you agree that Socialist We believe that the labour Organiser plays a useful movement needs a strong role It is particularly important us grow!

Getting organised..

Socialist Feminism" Friday 15 May Socialist Organiser No. 523 page 14 WE Boss raised towards £8,000 expansion target. voice for socialism.

"The Case for Alliance for Workers' Liberty College Thursday 14 May Essex University, 6.30. Speaker: Julie Mitchell Royal Holloway and Bedford, 7.30. Speaker: Alice Sharp Kent University, 1.00. Alliance for Workers* Libertyvublici forums Mondayı 18 May Which wayıfor new-BoOm Wallaser Urewnpioven entrem 7149 Vednesday 20 MaN Germanyıand Last Argeles:

essansufrom the reDeMor SEN Houghton Street..ЛЗК nureday 211 May "What next for the Labour left?" Swarthmore Centre, Leeds, 7.30 hihe molitics sil tenAtML. Bright hele Centre Biginow 7.30 "How to fight fascism", Manchester Town Hall, 8.00. Speaker: Dan Judelson. Wednesday 27 May Racerand Class after thor!

hern Town- all London SW2. Speaker: Mark isborn.

hursday 28th Mey ulturet ity Halls Glasgow 5U election defeat that Gould, Smith and the rest the labour movement, why not help Speaker: Jeni Bailey Lancaster University. 1.00. Speaker: Alice Sharp Richmond College, 1. Speaker: Jeni Bailey Monday 18 May Bath CHE, lunchtime. Speaker: Alice Sharp Wednesday 20 May Dundee University, 2.0 Speaker: Janine Booth Thursday 21 May QMC London, 5.30. Speaker: Janine Booth Birmingham Poly. lunchtime. Speaker: Alice Sharp Friday 22 May Oaklands, St Albans, 11.15.

Speaker: Alice Sharp Tuesday 26 May WISHE, Sussex, Lunchtime. Speaker: Alice Sharp.

North Riding College, Scarborough, 12.30. Speaker: Jeni Bailey York University, 5.15. Speaker: Jeni Bailey. Ripon and York St Joh York, 8.00. Speaker: Jeni Bailey.

Wednesday 27 May Lewis Tertiary College, 1.00. Speaker Alice SharpBrighton Poly, 5.30. Speaker: Alice Sharp. Selby College, 12.30. Speaker: Jeni Bailey Thursday 28 May Nene College, Northampton, 1.00. Speaker Alice Sharp. Thanks this week go to supporter in London for £50 donation and to supporter in Nottingha for £25.

You can make a donation by sending cheques or Postal Orders payable to "Workers' Liberty" t PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Labour Thursday 7 May Students for Bernie Grant. SOAS, ULU Complex, Lond 7.30 Monday 11 May "Where now for Labour?" Speaker Bernie Grant. Grosvenor Ball Room, Wallasey, 7.30 Thursday 14 May "Where now for Labour? Newcastle LPS meeting. St John's Church Hall, Granger Street, 7.30 Tuesday 19 May Socialist Campaign Group meeting, with Bernie Grant, Ken Livingstone, Alice Mahon. Civic Hall, Leeds, 7.30 Sociawst Movewvern Conference SWO Valya Conway•4B/ Red Lion Square, London Anti-racist convention The Anti-Racist Alliance is holding a conference, Saturday 13 June at ULU, Malet Street, London, WC1 Registration is £6 (delegates)/£4 (individuals)/£1.50 (unwaged) in advance Get your organisation delegate you. Write to ARA, PO Box 2578, London N5 1UF or phone 071-607 3988.

n the future, when the has rebuilt a large, revolutionary, working class organisation, some scholar of the movement, some David Riazanov or other, will compile a textbook for the education young militants under the title: "Why the "left' in the last decade of the twentieth century was so sterile"

It will print on the title page the words Karl Marx hurled at the fierce revolutionaries Willich and Schapper in 1851, when he told them that the working class and the socialist movement needed to go through 20 years in the wilderness in order to purge itself of nonsense and to make itself fit to take power.

That textbook will reproduce examples of articles and headlines from the left press today to illustrate the characteristic faults of the lett during the period. Certain of a place in this future textbook will be the headlines and articles with which the weekly "Socialist Action" - a forerunner of both Socialist Outlook and the quarterly magazine Socialist Action -greeted the vote won by Sinn Fein in Northern Ireland in the 1983 General Election* 'Sinn Fein wins 42%*.

That was what the headline told the paper's readers. The article offered no qualifications about the 'information' in the headline 'Sinn Fein wins 42%* In fact, it was 42% of the Catholic vote Sinn Fein had won! (The rest went to the Constitutional Nationalist Social Democratic and Labour Party). The Catholic are 1 in 3 of the 6 County population: 42% of the Catholic vote was about 12° of the total vote.

This excerpt from Socialis Action will, we confidently predict, find a place in the future textbooks because it a classic of its kind. It does not deserve to be forgotten.

The key question in Northern Ireland is the division - political, social an religious - between the Catholic-Nationalist and the Protestant-Unionist communities. That is what shapes events. That is what determines what Sinn Fein and the Provisional IRA car achieve of their Catholic-Nationalist aspirations. Everything Sinn Fein and the Provisional IRA have done for 20 years has only made the Protestants more obstinate in their hostility te what Sinn Fein and the Provisional IRA want to do unify Ireland under an independent Dublin government. Yet, they cann achieve it without Protestan agreement.

If Britain were to withdrav without a political settleme the issue would then be settled between the two Iris communities, by way of Yugoslavian-style civil war. At the end you would not have a United Ireland but. still, two Irelands, though probably with redrawn boundaries.

These are hard facts for romantic, vicarious, Irish nationalists to face up to They prefer to pretend tha "Northern Ireland" is a cli case of an Irish national liberation struggle against British imperialism.

In fact it is impossible, outside of the ideas of mystical Catholic nationalism to maintain view. But British 'left' romantics need that view. So?

Ignore the facts that do not fit! Tell yourself ideological lies. Pretend, even in your news reports, that the Protestants do not exist. Count Sinn Fein votes not as a proportion of the votes cast in the actually existing six counties, the political entity in which the Protestants are a big majority, but as a proportion of the vote in the minority community and then, in reporting it, pretend it is a proportion of the whole. Hey presto! The problem of the Protestants is gone. Sinn Fein - with 12% of the vote - is only 8% behind the magical electoral 50 per cent.

Classic late 20th oentury Toy Town left fare!

Socialist Outlook's Irish coverage is plainly in the hands of people who want. continue that memórable tradition. Their report of Gerry Adams' defeat in West Belfast did not this time ignore the Protestants. It could not, in the circumstances. But it blamed Protestant workers who voted SDLP for Adams' defeat. thereby implicitly proclaiming that Protestant voters should not count. echoing the obscene Catholic sectarianism of Sinn Fein.

Sinn Fein supporters demonstrated at the count, chanting that the Constitutional Nationalist who beat Adams was, because he got Protestant votes, the candidate of the Orange murder gangs.

Under the headline Loyalist vote defeats' Gerry Adams, Socialist Outlook offered a pale echo of the Sinn Fein diagnosis.

The writer hastened point out that Adams' share of the nationalist vote - the real vote, the vote that matters! - had risen.

It is a pity that people who call themselves Marxists should - even in the typically small and faltering voice of Socialist Outlook - echo Sinn Fein's increasingly blatant Catholic sectarianism.

----- pull-quotes -----

EYE ON TE LEFT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 523

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →