Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Liberal and outdated? M my review of Channel 4 TV's

Socialist Organiser no. 523, 14 May 1992 · scan pp. 11–12 · Martin Thomas · about 661 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

tiles to railway materials as typical goods exported, the path of 'imperialism' accompanied by political and military grab; on the other, an intense drive to force down the standards of the workers at home, to make them accept unrestricted speed-up, abolition of restrictive practices' and lower wages all round.

A wave of lockouts and provoked strikes swept the country in the 1890s. A body called the Free Labour Association was set up to organize mobile squads of assorted strikebreakers ("finks' is the American term), ready to go anywhere and do anything. (Mr.Martell, of the New Daily, seems to be ambitious to carry on where Collison, the leader of the FLA, left off.) Not only police but also troops were used against strikers on a scale unprecedented since Chartist times. There were shootings and killings -one case, at Featherstone, became a bitter byword in the movement, especially as a, Liberal Home Secretary was responsible.

In response to this sharp dose of basic political education, the idea of an independent workers' party began to catch on in areas where it had been resisted by traditional 'Radical' prejudices up to then - in particular in Yorkshire and Lancashire, key the ILP as 'wreckers'. Only as it ism..

of Independent Labour was compulsory in 1880.

sheri capitalis Mark Nevill should have read programme on Summerhill school (SO 519) more carefully before writing his polemic against it (SO 520).

I did not write "I wish I could send my daughter to Summerhill". I wrote "I wish my daughter could go to Summerhill". I hope it is unnecessary to labour the point that my wish is not just for Daisy but for all children to have the chance of going to a school like Summerhill, where adult-imposed rules are minimal and the children have a large measure of democratic Mark claims that the ideas on which Summerhill is based are "outdated and very much liberal".

Summerhill is liberal in the sense of a generous concern for the rights of the individual. But socialists should build on and extend that aspect of liberalism, not just denounce it.

Mark objects that the film showed a teacher responding neutrally, and not with criticisms of the cruelty and vio lence, when a boy captured and beheaded a rabbit.

Summerhill does not stand or fall by right.

Yes, as Mark points out, there is unhappiness and even potential violence at Summerhill. But there is more outside! No school operating within present-day society, or maybe even within a future socialist society, can turn young teenagers into calm, dispassionate philosophers.

The idea that it is wrong to behead rabbits is not innate. In many human societies, catching and butchering ani mals are highly-prized skills. Even in a modern capitalist city, every child sees that butcher shops are a normal part of life.

Children may come to feel that beheading rabbits is wrong. A moral lecture on that, given that the child's comparative inability to keep up an argument, is simply an exercise of superior force.

It could have had the same effect as a beating - compelling the boy not to catch rabbits again, or, more likely, to make sure that the teacher did not find out when he did - but it could no have made the boy develop his own moral sense. Summerhill's regime is designed to help children develop their own moral sense for themselves.

Mark also saw "spoiled brats" . It would be amazing if Summerhill did not have some children marked by over-indulgent and wealthy families. But children are necessarily more absorbed in their own desires than are adults, and usually they are hemmed in by a continual uproar of condemnations and instructions. Children should be what is conventionally called "spoiled".

As socialist and libertarian experiments within capitalism go, Summerhill has been remarkably successful. We should cherish it.

Martin Thomas Islington

Scan page 12

Organiser

----- pull-quotes -----

that teacher's response in that instance, but I think she was probably

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 523

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →