Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A. S. Neill for the 'nineties

Socialist Organiser no. 523, 14 May 1992 · scan p. 11 · about 739 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

..Bryan Gould tion in the world's markets, as workshop of the world', became apparent in a big way, with the rise of German and American competition.

To safeguard their developing industries the Americans even put up a tariff barrier against British goods. The reaction of British capital was twofold: on the one hand, the path of the export of capital to backward countries, with a shift from texareas then (if not now?) for the working-class movement. 'Independent Labour Unions' arose in centres like Bradford and Manchester, and working-class papers like the Workman's Times organized to bring them together in a national association. In 1893 a big step towards the Labour Party as we know it today was taken when the Independent Labour Party came going to succeed in spite of them did they change their line. The band-wagon was rolling along before they climbed on it! At first the ruling class of this country, or its responsible representatives, did not realize the significance of what was happening. We have a very acute and very flexible ruling class, but they weren't born that way, they had to learn it by being T has had its back pinned to he Marxist left in education the wall for a long time now, fighting back against the Tories' ideological onslaught. It is heartening therefore that the recent TV programme about A. S. Neill's anarchistic Summerhill school should have sparked off a debate in this paper. (Martin Thomas, SO 519; Mark Nevill, SO 520). For, whatever Neill's faults, his ideas about the education of the whole child are fundamentally subversive and akin to the spirit of socialism.

Mark states that adults will and "But there are ideas there that we need to hang on to for they will still be vital long after the Tories' National Curriculum has crumbled to dust.

must take decisions for children; he also talks about placing boundaries and decisions upon children [my emphasis]. Now, Summerhill takes children aged 10 to 16; it seems to me that we should be talking about taking decisions with children at this age, if not before, as indeed is the best practice in state primary schools, certainly from the age of eight.

The fundamentally democratic decision-making process of the school meetings is in the socialist tradition and stretches right back to Makarenko and the Gorky Colony he founded in the aftermath of the Russian Revolution.

Unfortunately, not all state schools adopt best practice. It is worth remembering, therefore, that Summerhill still takes more than its share of kids who have had a hard time elsewhere and take time in Summerhill's relative freedom to work out their frustrations. These kids no doubt formed part of Mark's "unhappy children, potentially violent, cruel adults." Having said that, many urban classrooms in the state sector could probably show Mark a fair cross-section of such children.

Mark may well have a point about lack of adult intervention over the decapitation of the supposedly diseased rabbit.

Mark is right to remind us that A. S. Neill's ideas are now quite old, but I would rather we tried to update them than condemn them as outdated. I do think Martin was a bit misty-eyed when he saw "the absence of fear and bullying, and the absence of tension between children and teachers".

The fact is that recent developments in the state sector, in particular the attempted implementation of equal opportunities, have brought many state schools, especially primaries, tremendous distances forward. The vigorous application of equal opportunities policies is going a long way to eradicate fear and bullying. Remember Culloden School?

It's easy to condemn Summerhill as Utopian self-indulgence for the privileged few. But there are ideas there that we need to hang on to for they will still be vital long after the Tories' National Curriculum has crumbled to dust.

As Engels said of some of the Utopian socialist systems set up in the last century: "The more completely these systems were worked out in detail, the more they could not avoid drifting off into pure phantasies... We can leave it to the literary small try to solemnly quibble over these phantasies, and to crow over the superiority of their own bald reasoning, as compared with such 'insanity"

"For ourselves, we delight in the stupendously grand thoughts and germs of thought that everywhere break out through their phantastic covering, and to which these Philistines are blind".

Plan Hollingworth, East London

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 523

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →