Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

How the Labour Party came into being: Why Smith and Gould are

Socialist Organiser no. 523, 14 May 1992 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,362 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Cautiously but clearly, Bryan Tand ohn is michae proposing that the Labour Party should cut loose from the trade unfons.

The denise teas canvassed after Labour lost its third General Election in a row in 1959. This reply by Brian Pearce, part one of which we publish this week, first appeared in the Trotskyist weekly The Newsletter in January 1961.

Yne attempts hennest

with menur on sucnmeno nothing: with a mass movement Demelopingator unilatena nuclear barmanent en ise pithen pungiSocialists canc increasing rank-anskile Partyisushk yas tone feather then the right. Tabbiel tell us that the revisionists around Labour Party has outlived itself in its traditional form, that it needs to break with socialism and perhaps also with its trade union basis, and go ' over to a non-socialist, non-class, quasiLiberal position.

Though put forward as 'new thinking, these ideas amount to a reversion to the 'Lib-Lab' position which preceded the emergence of the Labour Party. Some revisionists frankly say that the conditions and factors which led to the formation of the Labour Party are now without relevance to the present time, that a political line which may have been wrong seventy or so years ago is correct now; history having, so to speak, come round to it. It may be illuminating to examine how and why the Labour Party did in fact begin; this can help us to judge how far the reasons for having a Labour Party have ceased to apply, to estimate what the consequences of liquidating the party would be, and to see more clearly what forces fought for the creation he dri for u latic e 11 creas g une ime pov Isecur 1- th cont and development of the party and what forces resisted it as long as possible and thereafter tried to restrict and weaken it from within.

Down to the 1880s there was no labour movement' here in the continental sense at all. There were strong trade unions (of the skilled workers), and these unions were politicallyminded - but the only parties were the two ruling-class ones, the Tories and the Liberals. The trade unions expressed themselves politically by serving as the arms and legs of one or other of these parties - usually the Liberals, though in an area such as Lancashire and Cheshire where the employers were strongly Liberal the trade unions might retort to this by supporting the Tories! The political prospect of the trade unions was to get one or other of the ruling-class parties to pass • laws favourable to the workers; and they tried to consolidate their 'poor-relation' influence with these parties by persuading the Liberals to accept a few trade union officials among their parliamentary candidates.

During the 1880s there occurred, in a very small way at first, the rebirth of socialism in Britain after an interval of forty years. Old Chartists, reinforced by immigrant workers from Germany, had kept the flame burning in obscure clubs, but now a certain expansion began, with the establishment of the Social-Democratic Federation. In part under the guidance of Frederick Engels, pioneer socialists began a twenty years' propaganda for the launching in Britain of an independent class party of the workers with socialism as its aim. The setting-up of the Labour Representation Committee in 1900 constituted the first break-through to success of a campaign which for long had seemed to many Just the bee buzzing in the brains of a few cranks and fanatics, inspired by antiquated (Chartist) and foreign (German) notions. The workers learnt the hard way the need for a Labour Party. The eventual success of the socialists' efforts was made possible by Os h by ty ng of IOn. Yesterday's men: John Smith...

profound changes in the economic and social situation of the British workers. It is important to get clear just what these changes were, as against the legend spread by the revisionists.

Was it that the workers were 'getting poorer' in this period between 1880 and 1900? On the contrary, these years saw a drop of about 50 per cent in the cost of living: even allowing for increased unemployment there was a big advance in real wages. In that important aspect the workers had never had it so good!

But there was more unemployment than there had been in the previous period, and this led to a new feeling of insecurity and doubt about the social system. There was also a big drive on for speed-up and stricter discipline in the factories - 'American methods' as the phrase was. Increased mechanization was undermining the strong position of the craftsmen, the skilled workers introducing on a large scale the category of the 'semiskilled'. The growth of the scale of industrial ownership, the concentration of capital into ever-larger holdings, was reflected in greater remoteness of employer from worker and also in the appearance of an important new stratum of office workers who interposed themselves between the employers and the manual workers and came more and more to take the place of the old 'aristocracy of labour'.

All these changes unsettled sections of the working class which had been most uncritically loyal to the 'great Liberal party of Mr. Gladstone, the people's friend'. Other factors which came into play were a growth at the end of the nineteenth century in lavish, ostentatious spending by the ruling class, providing clear proof that whatever was happening to the poor the rich were certainly getting richer; and the rise of a generation of workers educated under the Act of 1870, who knew a lot more "The setting-up of the Labour Representation Committee in 1900 constituted the first break-through to success of a campaign which for long had seemed to many just the bee buzzing in the brains of a few cranks and fanatics, inspired by antiquated (Chartist) and foreign (German) notions."

about the details of ruling-class life than their fathers had done.

The socialists sought out the most politically-minded rank-and-file workers in the places where they were - especially in the Radical (left-wing Liberal) clubs in traditional working-class centres of that time like the East End of London. Besides their propaganda, the socialists carried on agitation around issues of interest to these we kers and fights which would help them to clear their minds of the confusions that kept them in the Liberal ranks. Struggle for tradeunion organization in trades and factories where the employers were well-known Liberals; struggle to defend and extend the right of free speech for streetcorner orators and in places like Trafalgar Square, against police attempts to encroach on this right; above all the campaign for the eight-hour day. (At this time many workers worked a ten-hour day or more, and with the appearance of unemployment and the intensified strain of speed-up and so on the need for a shortening of hours was felt more and more keenly.) The battles fought around these issues made many questions clearer to the workers who were involved in them, and prepared their minds to understand a great deal in the socialist message which previously had seemed strange and unreal to them.

A factor of very considerable weight in helping the idea of an independent workers' party to take root was the example provided by the Irish nationalist party at this time. A small but well-disciplined group of members from Irish constituencies kept themselves independent of both of the British parties, concerned themselves exclusively with pushing Ireland's claims for 'Home Rule' , and by their obstructive tactics compelled attention to their case. Increasingly, many politicallyminded British workers came round to the view that British labour needed a party of its own that would act like this.

What made up the minds of a wide section, and in particular influenced a number of trade union leaders who had no wish to take any new step unless they were obliged to by unbearable pressure, was the employers' offensive which began in the 1890s. It was as much, or more, under the blows of the employers that these people came round as under the pull of their militant members. This was the time when the ending of Britain's former monopoly posiRY ise

Scan page 11

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 523

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →