Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Left we have and the Left we need: The left and Ken Livingstone

Socialist Organiser no. 523, 14 May 1992 · scan p. 7 · Sean Matgamna · about 1,866 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Vote Livingstone? I'd sooner vote for Smith!" - the editor of a small left-wing paper speaking to Socialist Organiser after Ken Livingstone announced his "candidacy" for leader of the Labour Party "Back Livingstone!" - Labour Briefing I have been a supporter of proportional representation for many years -Ken Livingstone "No to proportional representation!" - Point One of the Campaign Group of MPs' platform imposed on Ken Livingstone, on the basis of which he sought support for Labour leader. -Labour lost the election because of its progressive taxation policy - Ken Livingstone "Without solid commitments to progressive taxation, we will not be able to shift resources from the rich to the poor. Labour will lose its core constituency and its political identity" -Point Four of the Campaign Group of MPs' platform for Ken Livingstone.

The undemocratic rule that a candidate for Labour Party leader must be nominated by 55 MPs has prevented Ken Livingstone from actually standing in the leadership election - as everyone knew it would. There might have been a serious left-wing leadership campaign around Benn -now there is nothing.

Livingstone's continuing "campaign will be a few meetings -and a column or two in the Sun -at which Livingstone will put his own ideas. Mainly, he will be putting his peculiar idea that the Tories were, after all, right and that Labour's tax proposals in the General Election would have penalised workers (see Socialist Organiser 521).

The only surprise has been in the number of Livingstone's nomwhich "endorsed" Livingstone, only 13 MPs nominated him! This ceases to be surprising when you know that there were only 7 MPs at the meeting which endorsed him and that only 4, including Livingstone himself, Socialist Workers Party members read voted for Livingstone: 2 voted against, and one (Tony Benn) abstained. Like everything else in this campaign, the "support" of the Campaign Group for Livingstone was not real; it was all sham, all trifling pretence.

Evidently, the views Socialist Organiser has expressed on Livingstone are not as "extreme" or as "unrepresentative" as our isolation on the left in giving public voice to them might lead you to believe!

Privately, very few people on the left - inside or outside the Labour Party - have a favourable word for Livingstone, or expect anything good irom him, now or in the future. Privately, most people on the left say of Livingstone what we say of him, that he is an unreliable, self-serving cynic with few scruples and very flexible loyalties. Some add their own touches of personal venom. Yet, publicly, they rush to anoint his self-selected candidacy as a candidacy of Where privately most of them agree with us about Livingstone, publicly they mutter darkly about our "sectarianism" ", or "self-indulgence"

When you take the almost unanimous public support the left expressed for Livingstone's "ca didacy" - which everyone kne could not be a real candidacy all - and compare it with wh most of them really think Livingstone, what strikes y most is how much she hypocrisy there is on the left no The quotations at the head of th article illustrate the confusion ar instability as well as the hypocri which vitiates the left now.

They know Livingstone and h record. Probably, without exce tion, they think Livingstone is shyster. • They knew he had no chan: of breaking through the "55 MP barrier to become a candidate. • They knew that by rushing with his pseudo-candida‹ Livingstone short-circuited ar chance of a "Draft Benn" campaign, occupying preemptively the room of a serious and genuinely left-wing campaign.

• They knew that he might wind up throwing any support he had gathered to Gould. In fact, by nods and winks now, by repeatedly saying in every speech he makes that Gould is better than Smith, he is already campaigning for Gould.

• They knew that his ideas on Labour's tax proposals in the Election campaign - the political core of his "candidacy" - are just an ill-thought out, shallow, left gloss on Tory General Election propaganda.

• They knew that he was backed by, and eagerly accepted the backing of, the sun, which boasts, and not entirely ridiculously, that it won the Election for the Tories.

More than that, they knew Livingstone's record as Greater London Council leader:

• Retreat after scuttling retreat before the Tories.

• High taxes for workers (rates).= • Pioneering Marxism Today Lib-Lab politics with his campaign against GLC abolition which consisted of lobbying the House of Lords in company with Tory bigwigs like Edward Heath.

"We really should have stood Benn and Skinner as our ticket Bernie Grant They recall, as we do, Livingstone's public account of his GLC record: "The cynical soft-sell approach" (Tribune, 19 July 1985).

They know that by his weak-kneed policies on the GLC at a crucial turning-point for the labour movement - during the miners' strike - Livingstone did more than Neil Kinnock to bring down demoralising, needless defeat on the labour movement: all Kinnock did was draw his own conclusions from the consequences of the working class defeats Livingstone had helped bring about in the early '80s.

They know that in the struggle around the GLC, Livingstone openly broke with the left. He came back to the left as an MP only because it suited his career as a media "personality".

They know he worked for years with the Libya and Iraq financed Workers' Revolutionary Party, which subsidised the paper Labour Herald for him. Some know he continues to have strong links with one of the WRP splinters: it is no secret. They know that when GLC leader Red Ken kissed the Queen's hand as she opened the Thames Barrier, he was simultaneously holding hands, so to speak, with people who were kissing a different part of Colonel Gadaffi's anatomy. They know that Livingstone carries on the WRP tradition of casually denouncing his enemies on the left - for example, the Leninist in the General Election - as "agents of MIS" : (Though, come to think of it, Livingstone has never told us who, besides Gerry Healy of the WRP, gave him his "security clearance" They know that Livingstone uses his column in the Sun to snipe at sections of the left - for example, he has attacked the Solid left-wingers, like Tony Benr Corbyn, could have rallied the lef least on a limited range of issues far.

And so on and so on.

Now, you might remember and say all these things about Livingstone and yet, nevertheless, "support" him because he already was the leader, or the catalyst, of a left-wing movement better than he himself is; you might get involved in such a movement and try LO help outgrow Livingstone's political charlatanry. That is what Socialist Organiser would have done had Livingstone represented such a movement.

But nothing like that was going on or likely to be going on around Livingstone's pseudo-" "candidacy". We repeat: Livingstone's jumping in may have played some part in heading off the development of such a movement, around Benn.

Those on the left who backed Livingstone can not plead that they were supporting a left-wing movement, or an honest left-wing candidate, or even a careerist candidate who, for his own reasons, promoted left wing ideas. There is movement around Livingstone; Livingstone is neither honest nor genuinely left wing; the key ideas on which he is campaigning are not left wing.

Those who rushed to back Livingstone rushed to back someone they know will sell them out - perhaps within a few short weeks, to the Gould campaign - if and when he thinks it will advance the cause of Ken Livingstone, as he sold out the GLC fight in the mid-'80s. They know that the only "movement" Livingstone has behind him is a small cluster of "left" sects: the strange Stalinoid grouping Socialist Action, Briefing and the elderly legions of the Morning Star.

They jump in to support Livingstone - and inevitably to help push the "tax" and other nonsense he is talking - when there is no movement around him, helping this disarmingly candid charlatan help rebuild his credibility in the labour movement.

What does all this tell you about the state of the left?

The Livingstone affair reveals the left now to be: • Politically confused and disorientated, • Desperately lacking in self-definition and self-confidence, • Politically eager to "purchase" even blatant charlatanism - like Livingstone's stuff on taxes - if it promises some "action" • Incapable of taking itself seriously.

What kind of a "left" is this! Take, for example, Briefing. Throughout the early '80s Livingstone led Briefing around by the nose (and they have been at a loss to know what to do with their nose since Livingstone let go of it: most of the old guard have retired or half-retired). Mesmerised in the early '80s by their own fantasies that the left was "Taking Power" in local government, they Followed Livingstone, endlessly making excuses and half-excuses for him, through all his GLC zigzags and sell-outs right up to the point in 1985 when he broke with the left.

They never, as far as we know, seriously criticised their own role in all this, but they were all the more fierce in their criticism of Livingstone in 1985. They know as much as we do about Livingstone! But, still, they back him. To torm a sharp judgment of your own, hold to it, and speak and act on it - that, comrades, is sectarianism!

Briefing, now as in the '80s, when it fawned on the "powerful" Livingstone, is no more than a small group of friends who like to sniff around "power" and "influence", and are usually willing, like all groupies, to pay the price. Yet Briefings approach, here as in the past, is symptomatic of the "left": it is part of the explanation why someone like Livingstone can, despite his recent past, still be taken seriously on the lett.

"Livingstone did more than Kinnock to bring defeat on the labour movement... all Kinnock did was draw his own conclusions from the working class defeats Livingstone helped bring about in the early '80s."

People who call themselves left and yet behave like this will never rebuild a real left - a "left" confident enough to learn from its own experiences and honest enough to draw the indicated lessons from them.

Such a left might support a movement led by a Livingstone: it would not rush to endorse a Livingstone in whom it does not believe, with whom it does not agree, and who stands at the head of nothing substantial!

It would be a left which would not be afraid to tell itself the truth.

We in the Alliance for Workers' Liberty exist to promote, develop, regroup and build such a left. We tell the truth about Livingstone's "left" sideshow at the carnival of farce the Labour Party establishment made of the Labour leadership contest. It is an irreplaceable part of our work now.

----- pull-quotes -----

AGAINST THETIDE

inations. Though there are over 30 MPs in the Campaign Group,

but they wouldn't stand."

turned the left's intervention into SWP at least three times this year so

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 523

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →