Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Unite the eft

Socialist Organiser no. 523, 14 May 1992 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,339 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

block vote should not be scrapped Encouraged by their April 9 General Election victory, the •Tories are again on the warpath.

There is to be another round of anti-union legislation. Many thousands of public sector jobs are to be butchered. The reorganisation of the NHS continues: the Tories are now creating a two-tier system in which those who can not pay will be at the back of the queue for inferior treatment. The mines and railways are to be denationalised. Teachers and working class children face a savage Tory drive • words in the dictionary to lock vote are the dirtiest many socialists by the end of a Labour Party annual conterence.

In debate after debate we hear strong and persuasive speeches for a left-wing motion, with the feeblest opposition. Then the General Secretaries get out their voting cards and the motion is crushed Now Bryan Gould and John Smith both hint, cautiously but definitely, at cutting back or abolishing the block vote. John Graham Bash dadimiriDerer errystagleton Jatin Haria (Labour Party BlackI Sectionsi Horothy Viacedo John Nicholson Peter Tatchlell Members of like Almisery apree are save same Tomor the went nobo opposed to the Labour Party's nilshSocials Janis Vie W exE SISE rticlesmire the rese uthoromnd notiot the Ansory Editorial Board.

to turn the clock back 30 years on education. Unemployment continues to rise. The poll tax is still on the statute books. And the Tories are probably in power for the next 5 years. We can not "wait for Labour". The labour movement needs to organise now to stop the retreat and to begin the fightback.

A number of conferences are planned in the next few months in which the labour movement and the left will try to take stock after Labour's fourth General Election defeat in succession. The Campaign Group of Labour MPs has such a conference coming up: Edmonds, General Secretary of Boilermakeas Union (GMB). the Genera. Municipal and agrees.

Should we support them?

No, for three reasons.

One. The way the block vote operates today should not be idealised, but it should not be caricatured either.

Not even the most bureaucratic General Secretary can do what he or she likes with the block vote. They are bound by their union's conference decisions and by the majority of their union delegation. The last general secretary to try to buck those rules was Sid Weighell of the NUR (now RMT), in the early 1980s, and he was forced out of his job as a result.

The block vote is no more democratic than the unions are generally, but no less so either. The way to make it more democratic is to make the unions more democratic - a task which is necessary anyway.

Two. The trade unions are not pertect organisations, but they are the mass organisations of the working class. Without the working class there can be no struggle for socialism; and without its organisations, the working class is not a force to change society, but only a collection of victims of exploitation.

If the Labour Party broke its links with the unions, it would transform itself into nothing better than a second-rate Liberal Party. In fact, John Edmonds doesn't want that. He wants to retain the trade unions' influence in the Labour Party. Only he wants that influence to be exercised more bureaucratically! so have Tribune and the Kinnockite Labour Co-ordinating Committee. The Socialist Movement has a conference scheduled for September.

We need not many weak, seetional conferences but one properly organised, democraticall -run conference, a great labour movement convention of those who want to organise and unite the working class fightback against this new Tory offensive.

We need to set up a representative organising committee able to organise such a conference. Democratise the block vote, don't destroy it The block vote is embarrassingly public, and therefore open to accou everything suitched de behind closed doors in cabals of union leaders and Labour frontbenchers.

Three. "One member, one vote" their alternative to the block vote, is not as democratic as it sounds.

Firstly, all Labour Party members have a vote now - which they can cast at a meeting. Secondly, they clearly mean one member, one postal vote" -Democracy is about more than just voting. Look at America. There is more voting there than anywhere else in the world.

"The trade unions are not perfect organisations but they are the mass organisations of the working class"

Thousands of public officials, from local dog-catchers to the President, are directly elected, and even the main candidates for President are chosen by popular vote through the "primary" system.

Undoubtedly, it's better than the pre-Gorbachev USSR, with its compulsory 99.9% "votes" for bureaucratically-appointed rulers. But it's a very pale, corrupt form of democracy.

Politics is In the early '80s the left - a Socialist Organiser initiative -united in the "Rank and File Mobilising Committee for Labou Democracy", and did great thing in the Labour Party. We can do similar work now, organising the labour movement to stop the retreat.

The Campaign Group of MPs and, in the first place, Tony Benn, should now take the initiative in the setting up of a "Rank and File Organising Committee". We must "Stop the Retreat". For that, we must organise.

TIk business. It has very little to do with informed debate on issues. Political campaigning consists of spending millions of dollars on TV advertising about your opponent's alleged sexual, medical, psychiatric or financial flaws.

Elections don't decide political issues in the USA. They just give some individuals a four-year lease to take part in the complex haggling among the powers-that-be (many of them, like big business bosses and Pentagon chiefs, unelected) who do decide. The people get a yes-or-no-vote on those individuals, that's all.

Parliamentary democracy n Western Europe is also limited. We too have our unelected powers-that-be in the boardrooms, the banks and the State machine. But there is more substance to West European democracy because of the existence of proper, organised, political parties, (the Us Democrats and Republicans don't really count as such), and in particular of parties based on the organised labour movement.

People vote mostly for parties rather than individuals. And those parties have meetings, committees, delegates, conferences - imperfect but nevertheless real processes of collective debate, working out policies which cannot be discarded overnight without a kick-back.

Collective working class political organisation is the product of many decades of workers' struggles against the atomisation which tne private-profit economy tries to impose on us. It has become WE WILL EAN: K955 WE WIL LOKE BRASS WE WONICIE INTO Lessons of the miners' strike: it's better to have fought and lost... bureaucratised. But the answer is to democratise it, not to dissolve it back into a scattering of isolated individuals connected to politics only by the television screen and the postal vote.

"One member, one vote" in the Labour Party would mean policies decided by stitched-up, unelected elite "policy commissions" , and the members having a vote only to endorse the media-backed leaders.

The main reform needed in the block vote is not a reform in its formalities and mechanics, though those might be improved, but a comprehensive drive for democracy in the trade unions on which it is based. And the labour movement will never be ready to fight for socialism until it has carried through that drive.

if emancipation of thel working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race.

KariMarxe spcibus urganisen iN BoK BEBA London SET 6 4NA Nervsdesk: 00m-659 7965 4test watenforweports Mondays Editor: John O' Mahony Published by: WL Publications Ltd, PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Printed by Tridant Press Edenbridge Registered semewsp Jara Post Office Articles do not necessarily reflect the viewsar Sacia Ind alesh a personal canada

Scan page 4

Socialist Organiser No. 523 page 4

----- pull-quotes -----

Advisory Editorial Board

Joe Martno JohnVictro

THE STUPID ASS MACRECOR CIVE IN YOUR FICHT IS LOST ARTHUR SCARCILL IS OUR BOSS THE MINERS WIVES

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 523

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →