Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Utterly unlike Hollywood

Socialist Organiser no. 522, 7 May 1992 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 586 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Belinda Weaver reviews Raise the red lantern Show the bite tate of a et in China in the 1920s.

shows the bitter fate of a teenage, orphan girl, Songlian, who marries a wealthy, older man. She is not his only wife; he already has three others, and Songlian is little more than a concubine to him.

She feels humiliated that she, a girl who has been educated, who has attended university, for a short time, should be relegated to the role of Fourth Mistress to a man she hardly knows.

But Songlian has no choice. With no family, and no means of support, marriage is the only career open to her.

The world she enters is comfortable, even luxurious. Songlian has her own rooms, and servants to wait on her. While she pleases the master, she can have what she wants, but only while she pleases him.

To do that, she must win out over the other women, all of whom want the master's favour for themselves.

Red lanterns are lit both within and outside the rooms of the woman with whom the master chooses to spend the nig jht. As evening approaches, the wives gather to see who will be the lucky one tonight.

It's the world of the harem, though on a smaller scale, where the women have little to do but plot and scheme against each other in an effort to come out on top.

Songlian is bright, and she soon sees how to get the treatment she wants. Yet her efforts can't bring any meaning to her life.

she and the other are slaves to a master's whim society where women are expecter She doesn't love the husband who has bought her, and there is no-one else to care for. She cannot trust the other wives; the servants have their own axes to grind.

The women have no lives of their own, no outlet for their energies or their emotions, apart from the pointless rivalry and jokeying for position amongst temselves. They are all out for what they can get; their lives a constant dissembling towards the master they must please, since he holds all the cards, having literally the power of life and death over them. It's easy to see why Songlian is driven half-mad by her life there.

The film is slow-moving and rather static, as befits this story of a rigid, enclosed world. After her arrival, Songlian is never again seen utside the walls of her master's house. Despite this, the film never seems claustrophobic.

It makes its points quietly but tellingly. For all the comfort Songlian enjoys, she and the other wives are chattels, with no rights. They are slaves to a master's whim in a society where women are expected to produce sons, and where to give birth to a gırl brings disgrace.

Ihe fılm is utterly unlıke Hollywood movies, where filmmakers rely on sex, violence and special ellects to stır up the audience. The meaning in this film is largely conveyed through closeups of Songlian's face as she moves from indifference to fear, from defiance to despair. Had the film been made in Hollywood, the emphasis would have been on the man, with the women all lumped together, instead of displaying, as they do here, their individual ways of coping with unbearable lives.

Scan page 14

ise

----- pull-quotes -----

"For all the comfort Song lian enjoys,

wives are chattels, with no rights. The

to produce sons, and where to give birth to a girl brings disgrace.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 522

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →