Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Fighting the Nazis

Socialist Organiser no. 522, 7 May 1992 · scan pp. 12–13 · John Cunningham · about 1,586 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Those who didn't escape: "The Transport", Pierre Mania, Buchenwald, 1943 Book John Cunningham reviews Escape through the Pyrenees by Lisa Fittko There is something to be said for the autobiographical account of a specifSic period: the boundaries both define and limit the scope of the writer's life, enriching it in a way which vast, rambling tomes can not. Free from the clutter of superfluous detail and unnecessary "background' , often merely padding, the shorter work focuses the reader's mind and whatever is lost in terms of the 'long view' is more than compensated for by the attention of historical detail, relevancy and sharpness.

Lisa Fittko's modest account of her life in France in the early 1940s is welcome in more ways than one.

It fills a number of small gaps in our knowledge of the situation in France in the aftermath of the 1940 Nazi invasion. This has never been an easy period to get to grips with and is a source of continuing controversy in France. Fittko's 'on the spot' account, as it were, is thus very illuminating.

Her book is worth getting for one chapter only. She was one of the last people to see Walter Benjamin alive. This GermanJewish writer achieved posthumous fame for his work on aesthetics and politics, in particular an essay entitled Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction. Difficult at times to read, Benjamin trod a curious path which oscillated between the mysticism of the Jewish Kaballah and Marxism. His was a precarious and often lonely life and Fittko's loving description of him gives us a rare glimpse of a man perpetually living on the edge of a precipice.

The book's strongest theme is the absolute necessity for good political organisation. Courage, audacity and nerve are also needed but organisation is the extra ingredient without which they are wasted. There was no shortage of brave people around in the 1940s, but without organisation they died just the same as the cowards.

Born in 1909 in Berlin, Lisa Fittko's life would probably fill a number of volumes. A socialist and an anti-fascist, first in Germany then in France, she escaped to Cuba and then moved to the USA in 1948, where she has remained politically active despite her advanced years. In her book, she recounts one period in that busy life, the months when she guided political refugees over the Pyrenees, out of the clutches of the Nazis into Spain, then onto Lisbon and eventual safety in the USA.

Thousands of German anti-fascists were stranded in France at the collapse of the French and British forces. After the surrender, most of them tried to escape to the South or the South-West where the "unoccupied zone"offered them a precarious and, as it turned out, temporary safety.

Lisa Fittko and her husband were apprehended in Paris shortly after the surrender. The French authorities simply rounded up as many foreign refugees as they could and shipped them off to a concentration camp in Gurs near the border with Spain. As long-standing anti-fascists, socialists and Jews, Lisa and Hans Fittko were particularly vulnerable in the confusion and paranoia that swept through France at this time.

Paradoxically, this very confusion worked to their advantage. Conditions at Gurs were not good but just about bearable, even so, it was necessary to escape as they would almost certainly be handed over to the Germans who would kill them. The problem for the camp authorities was that they had no idea who was in charge. One day the prisoners noticed there were no guards! it wasn't clear why. Perhaps the guards simply went home when demobilised without waiting for replacements.

Whatever the reasons, the Fittkos and others were quick to take advantage of it. They walked out in freedom, but with no money, no papers and nowhere to go.

They eventually found a safe route over the Pyrenees, used by smugglers, but before they could use it, they were asked by a political refugee organisation in Marseilles to act as guides to help other refugees escape over the mountains to Spain.

So, for almost a year, they postponed their own escape to help hundreds of others. Most of her book is taken up with this period, which came to an end in April 1941 when the time arrived for them also to leave.

The situation, particularly for German political refugees, was extremely precarious. The puppet Vichy government worked hard to prove its credentials with its new Nazi masters, and informers were all too ready to denounce any suspicious person to the police. As a large number of the refugees were Jews, they were also the target for keen French anti-Semites, of whom there were many.

Documents and papers were a particular problem and numerous sections in the book deal with the search for, or the forging of the various travel and identification papers which were needed. Bribes sometimes worked, though not always in cash. Food was scarce, rations often inadequate, and the Panamanian Consul, for example, became well-known for his predeliction for salami bribes instead of hard cash!

The Fittkos would assist with the search for papers and were accomplished forgers, but their main task was to take refugees over the Pyrenees to Spain. Based first in Banyuls-sur-Mer, they carefully and meticulously mapped out a route which, under the very noses of the French border guards, led to the Spanish town of Port Bou. Here, the fortunate refugee could, with the right papers, register with the local police and then proceed to Portugal and Lisbon.

One of those refugees was Walter Benjamin, whom Lisa Fittko had met briefly in Paris before the Nazi invasion. Benjamin's health was not good and the mountain path proved arduous for him. Fittko was impressed by his discipline, however. He would stop at exactly ten minute intervals for a brief rest, thus he was able to master the mountains and cross the border.

Under his arm, throughout the climb, he carried a brief case. In it was a manuscript, to him the most precious thing in his life. "The manuscript is more important than I am," he explained to Fittko. Sadly, this manuscript has been lost. The night after his arrival in Port Bou, Benjamin committed suicide.

The Spanish police had told him that a new order had just arrived from Madrid allowing no one to enter Spain without a French exit visa. Benjamin, having no such document, was to be returned to France, where he would certainly be handed over to the Gestapo. He preferred instead to take his own life. Tragically, but not untypical of the times, the order was rescinded the very next day.

Not all refugee stories ended so disastrously; the Fittkos were able to help many to safety before an order came that the border area was to be cleared of all foreigners. They hastily left for Marseilles, eventually found themselves the necessary papers and travelled to Lisbon themselves, not over dark, stony mountain paths, but in the relative comfort of a French locomotive.

France at this time was a deeply divided country, the ignominious collapse of the French army and the collaboration of major political figures left a demoralised and confused population easy prey to all sorts of suspicions and prejudices.

However, reading this book it is impossible not to be struck by the number of times ordinary people, workers, clerks, peasants and even, sometimes, police, helped the refugees, often at great risk to themselves. Sometimes this manifested itself as simply "looking the other way" sometimes it meant using a rubber stamp which didn't mean anything but looked impressive.

In the Pyrenees, the Fittkos and their charges often mingled with early-morning vine-workers, attempting to blend in with them as they wound their way up the foothills. Not once were they exposed though it seems highly unlikely, in such a small rural community, that their activities were not common knowledge.

Lisa Fittko is, no doubt, a remarkable person, but you get the impression that this isn't all. Alongside the courage there is also political conviction and belief to which is also brought the knowledge and experience of 8 or 9 years underground activity in Germany. Time and time again, it was the German political emigrés who saved the day.

It was they who built up an organisation of safe houses, centres for forging papers, funds for bribing officials and escape routes. It was they who kept clearly in mind the political goal - the continuation of the fight against fascism and responded by organising. By contrast, the social-democrats we encounter in the book appear lost, unable to act, unable to believe that these things were happening. In Fittko's own words: "People fall into a trap; they watch while it slowly closes. Some are benumbed at the sight of their incomprehensible fate. Others are panic-stricken and run around in circles. The ones who have objectives search for a way out. Determination to get out of the trap demands every effort and suppresses all doubt about its feasibility."

Unfortunately, Fittko says little about the political make-up of the German emigres in France; disputes and divisions, particularly when the Soviet Union is invaded, are mentioned but never detailed. This is a major fault with an otherwise excellent book.

Published by Northwestern University Press, USA, 1991.

Scan page 13

THE CULTURAL FRONT nise

----- pull-quotes -----

"People fall into a trap; they watch while it slowly closes... Determination to get of the trap demands every effort and suppresses all doubt about its feasibility."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 522

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →