When they 1
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-05-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
aboun lost ithe Apriligeneral election because for mone than a decader the Labour and trade undo leaders have been on their knees before the Tories.
Onerofithe gneat mysteres in labour emprenentistory si why in me 80 andrafter the deaders of the daboun er trade union movement - trade union leaders who had been widely-believed in the mid-'70s to have more power than the Labour government - peacefully lay down under the wheels of the Thatcher juggernaut, sutJack Jones: union leader who justified the unions' failure to resist Labour government cuts by the danger of a coup rendering without a fight.
John Of Mahonyioffer's amerplamation. Snot have clicive owner- ocialism is impossible withnot have collective ownership of the means of production that is not also day-by-day democratic controlling ownership. Collectivism without controlling democracy would turn into practical ownership by those who had control. This is one of the key lessons and irrefutable conclusions socialists draw from the experience of Stalin's counterfeit socialism in the USSR and Eastern Europe. Where there is no democracy, there will never be socialism.
And because this is so - what follows?
Therefore, workers lose the right to resist injustice when it is inflicted by a democratic parliament - injustice like the poll tax, or the successive waves of anti-union laws?
Therefore, it cannot be an option for socialists to fight back with direct action and illegal resistance against class legislation - the Tory anti-union laws for example - when it has a parliamentary majority behind Therefore, workers must always bow down low - as low as Neil Kinnock and his predecessor as Labour leader, Michael Foot -bowed before the existing British system of democracy?
Or is it, on the contrary, possible for workers to fight back against a parliamentary majority, elected democratically, and still remain democrats! Despite Neil Kinnock, Michael Foot and their cronies, is it possible for the labour movement to resist capitalist attacks, refusing to le down belore blatantly unjust class legislation, even when it has the backing of an elected parliamentary majorıty, using direct action and illegal actior where necessary without repudiating democracy?
That question, in major and minor keys, was posed to the labour movement again and again throughout the 1980s. It was posed sharply in the late 1980s by the poll tax. Millions of people retused to pay; they defied the law, that is, they defied parliament. It was their resistance that broke the poll tax - and Mrs Thatcher. Yet that resistance, according to the Labour leaders, was nothing less than a crime against "democracy".
No matter how wrong, regressive, or iniquitous a piece of class legislation may be, said Neil Kinnock and his friends -and they never denied that the poll tax was a piece of vicious class legislation - parliament must govern. No-one has the right to resist parliament. and still remain democrats?"
In the early 1980s the same question was posed with even greater sharpness, and much greater consequence to the labour movement. The Tories had won the 1979 general election and immediately launched a relentless many-pronged attack on the labour movement and on the working class. Not since the *National Government" of 1931 had there been in Britain so open a classwar government, a government willing to use every weapon they thought necessary to beat down the labour movement.
The Tories deliberately worsened the conditions of slump after 1980, the better to cut down the labour movement. Whole swathes of industry -and the militant labour organisations erected within them -were wiped out. Whole communities were devastated. A big part of a generation of young people was thrown out of industry. The first of a long series of anti-union laws was put on the statute book, laws which by now add up to the most illiberal labour legislation in Western Europe. The welfare state was undercut: the Tory demolition of the National Health Service, which has continued throughout the 1980s, was starting. The Tories had decided to kick over what was left of the post-war Tory-Labour-Liberal consensus and set out on a radical bourgeois programme to reshape British society. They ruthlessly used state power.
Later, during the 1984-5 miners' strike, they would organise the police as a semi-militarised force under the control of one national centre, to physically beat down striking workers. In the course of doing that they sometimes acted quite outside the law, for example arbitrarily and illegally controlling the movements of miners. In 1986, they sent the police to strong-arm printworkers at Wapping.
But, though Thatcher had won only a minority of the vote in both the 1979 and 1983 elections, and though until the 1982 Falklands war opinion polls showed her to be as unpopular as she would again become by 1990 when the Tory MPs dismissed her, the Tories did, of course, through all this, have a majority in parliament. Yet resistance was possible by direct action, as it had been in the '70s.
At the beginning of the 1980s. before mass unemplovment had cut into the sinews of the labour movement, before so much of industry was destroyed, the labour movement probably had the strength successfully to challenge Thatcher, as Tory Prime Minister Heath had been challenged a decade earlier and driven from office. But did the labour movement have the democratic right to organise extraparliamentary resistance? Did it have the right to try to dislodge the Thatcher government by extra-parliamentary action?
Serious socialists - Socialist Organiser, for example - advocated resistance and confrontation on every front possible, from industry to local government (where nominal left-wingers were strong) to parliament. We invoked the right of revolt and resistance to oppression and tyranny proclaimed by the serious bourgeois democrats who led the American and French revolutions in the 18th century. We argued for a fight by the labour movement to defend democracy against Thatcher's strengthening of the central state and abuse of parliamentary power and for a fight to deepen and develop democracy in the spirit of the old Chartists.
The Labour establishment, including its left and ex-left segundemocratic to resist parlia- ment said: undemocratic to resist parliament. The Labour Party left -people like Ken Livingstone -said: Yes, resist; but most of them soon thought better of it.
It was the time of the great left-wing upsurge in the Labour Party, triggered by the dismal record and the comprehensive failure of Labour in government between 1974 and 1979.
The political labour movement was trying to draw the conclusions from over a decade of serious class struggle. Tony Benn was able to secure 83 per cent of the CLP votes when he stood against Denis Healey for deputy leader of the Labour Party. The left won a succession of victories at Labour Party conferences in Blackpool, Brighton, and Wembley. Our weakness was in the trade unions.
Objectively it was possible, had the Labour Party and the trade unions chosen to challenge the Tories head on, to reforge the British working-class movement into a radical anticapitalist force.
Objectively it was possible for the labour movement, defending the post-war welfare state, to have rallied all sorts of petty bourgeois around itself, and eventually to have won a parliamentary majority for its policies.
That did not happen. The trade union leaders did not fight. Soon undercut by the slump, neither did the rank and file to whom it had fallen in the 1960s and "70s to set the pace -not on the scale necessary, anyway.
The radicalisation was mainly a Labour Party affair - and a heavily lower-middle-class affair at that, often on "minority" and sectional issues.
The local government left did not fight in the early 1980s, when mattered. Ken Livingstone's Greater London Council bottled out of a confrontation with the Tories, though that did not save the GLC. Lambeth stumbled into a sort of conflict in the mid-1980s and Liverpool, under Militant leadership, made some mobilisation in 1984, then did a deal with the Tories, leaving the miners in the lurch, and stumbled into collapse.
The Tories, like an army seeing the enemy in unexpected disarray, improved on their initial victories. Round after round of anti-union legislation was rammed through. The Thatcherites pushed the entire axis of British politics - and, slowly, the Labour Party too - a long way to the right. Ultimately they hegemonised the Labour Party which, in the beginning, had - on certain questions - challenged them fundamentally.
...the Tories were like victorious cavalry riding around in command of a battlefield looking for targets, casually picking off and destroying the National Dock Labour Scheme in 1989, something that government would have dared to contemplate a decade earlier."
The early 1980s was the decisive period. Large-scale, escalating, perhaps triumphant, resistance was possible then, but later became, for logistic, political, and psychological reasons, very difficult. The miners' battle of 1984-5 came very late. It should have ignited the labour movement. If the dockers had struck for longer; if Liverpool council had gone for confrontation... But in retrolemocłacy, hn-fact ther feared -the-sorimtroopels e
Scan page 9
lared a cou Michael Foot: Labour leader who promised "a storm of Neil Kinnock: he built on the defeats of the ¡dignation" but retreated for fear of "the stormtroopers" pect it is not at all surprising nat it did not. It was too late. he Tories had become too trong.
By the later 1980s, the Tories ere like victorious cavalry ridig around in command of a attlefield looking for targets, asually picking off and destroyig the National Dock Labour cheme in 1989, something that o government would have ared to contemplate a decade arlier.
The early 1980s was the decive time. Because of the slump, esistance to the Tories then ould probably have had to be purred and organised initially y a political campaign, albeit La growing industrial imension. When he defeated denis Healey for the position of abour Party leader in 1980, fichael Foot promised to rganise a great crusade and hip up such a "storm of indigation" against what the Tories ere doing that they would be riven from office as they had een seven years before. It was hat was needed and what, ten, was almost certainly possile.
But Foot never did it. He did ot even make any serious ttempt to do it. Instead this eft" leadership of the Labour arty turned their fire on the abour left, and confined themelves to in-house parliamentary osturing. It was the beginning f that frozen impotence so haracteristic of the Labour arty leaders today that even purgeois journalists - no, even le Liberals! - can sneer at their ck of fire against the Tories ad wish for a more vigorous ficial opposition, if only in the iterests of preserving the salth of Britain's political sysThe future historians of the bour movement and of British bitics will have to record the range and even astonishing ct that when the Tories were dically reshaping and diminishing British democracy, when they were curbing local government, destroying the rights of the labour movement and many of the reforms it had achieved -just at that time the leaders of the Labour Party, Michael Foot and his pale understudy Neil Kinnock, were crusading in defence of democracy: but they were defending it not against the Tories but against the Labour left! The Tories were using parliament as a base for the operations of a one-party minority dictatorship ruthlessly pushing through cranky bits of social engineering, destroying much of Britain's industry and many millions of jobs - and the Labour leaders at exactly this point in Britain's political history chose to crusade in defence of "democracy" against their own left wing!
In parliament and in the Observer, the big business newspaper, the old-time left-winger, then Labour leader, Michael Foot concurred with the violent campaign of denunciation in the mainstream press, indicting the left as the main enemy of democracy, and identifying the left as the immediate threat to British democracy. Those who noe trical leaders of sad labour movement while the Tories were mercilessly grinding it down and encroaching on democracy, were those who wanted to use direct action to stop the Tories!
The cry "democracy first" became the main ideological weapon in the drive by the Labour right and soft left - that is, the Labour establishment -to disarm the labour movement in face of the Tory onslaught. They used "democracy" to discredit the idea of direct action. It was their "good" , respect-wor thy, public "reason" for a craven surrender.
And much that they surrendered in the name of democracy was the democratic rights of the Labour Party democracy labour movement, and British citizens!
"Democracy" versus direct action was the issue on which the "soft left" first separated itself from the more serious left. Later it was the blade of the knife the Labour establishment plunged into the back of the miners during their great strike. It was the ultimate justification for their craven inactivity all through the 1980s.
The history of reformist labour movements like the Labour Party includes many grimly obscene episodes - such, for example, as the day in 1933 when the German Social Democratic leader Otto Wels got up in the Reichstag and offered his loyal collaboration to the new - legally appointed -Chancellor, Herr Hitler. It is their nature. When they kow tow to the bourgeois establishment, their deepest instincts are in operation!
They fear action and they fear the rank and file. But they also come under the pressure of their members, and when their organisations are threatened, they sometimes try to defend them. Even the most wretched creatures defend themselves when driven into a corner, when they can no longer fool themselves into thinking that things will turn out all right. The great mystery of Britain's labour movement and trade union leaders in 1980 and after is that they did not. Trade union organisations which had eemed as poweru as in abour government itself in th mid-'70s now sank away into nothingness before the first attacks of an enemy they could probably have beaten had they fought.
To look for one simple explanation for that behaviour is probably misleading. Yet I want to highlight one part of the explanation, which Michael oot brings out pretty cleariv 1 ne articles bv Michael Foc reprinted in the Workers' Liberty pamphlet on democracy.
At the beginning of the 1980s, the Labour and trade union leaders were terrified of a campaign of resistance to Thatcher by direct action because, as Foot phrased it, they feared "the stormtroopers". They feared to resist Thatcher because they feared a military coup in Britain.
...the Labour leaders were ...far from confident that democracy in Britain was stable ...they knew that the ruling class was prepared to smash British democracy if that was the only way it could win against a wor class movem ent that dared to fight."
They were far from confident that democracy in Britain was said in their demate i de theyciations of the left - they knew that the ruling class led by Thatcher were prepared to smash British democracy if that was the only way they could win against a working class movement that dared to fight. They knew, having been in government, how close British democracy had come to a breakdown in the mid-1970s. Behind all their confident assertions about British democ racy lived the fear and terror o men and women who felt tha they had looked into the abys in the mid-1970s. Michael Foo did say this in his anti-lef polemics in the Observer though not with complete can dour; the mid-1970s TGWL leader Jack Jones said it plainly.
The astonishing failure of the Labour and trade union estab lishment - powerful politicians so recently in government, an‹ powerful leaders of powerfu organisations, so recently ir strong partnership with govern ment - even to defend thei own immediate interests in the early 1980s was a late by-prod uct of the bitter class struggle: of the first half of the 1970s.
In 1974 a Tory government wa: forced out of office and, according to the then Chief of Staff, Lori Carver, speaking in a debate witl the pacifist Pat Arrowsmith *Fairly senior officers were ill advised enough to makı suggestions that perhaps, if thing got terribly bad, the army would have to do something about it..."
The Labour and trade unior leaders confronted the new Thatcher government in a blue funk at the possible conse quences of a new round o 1970s level class struggle. Sc they demobilised the labou movement and surrendered.
Thatcher took on the labou movement after 1979 with the bigger stick of the military, witl whom she had close ties, raisec behind the big sticks she used -the semi-militarised police she used against the miners, fo example.
In face of Thatcher, Socialis Organiser advocated direc action and confrontation with the Tories all across the board industrial direct action, loca government defiance, parlia mentary withdrawal of cooperation. We said to the labour movement: fight the Tories by every means possible or face a historic defeat. Our comrades were active in the trade unions, and in the Labou Party.
We initiated the Rank and File Mobilising Committee for Labour Democracy, which united most of the left in the drive that, for a while - before the labour movement and especiall the unions were ground dowr by the Thatcherites - took the Labour Party sharply to the left.
We argued that the labou movement should fight to kick out the Tories and replace them with a "workers' government" a Labour government radically different from all previous Labour governments, doing for the working class the sort of things Thatcher spent the 1980s doing for the bourgeoisie.
We fought the passivity of the right and the soft left, and criti cised the empty verbal 01 sectional radicalism of the local government left who essentially also pursued, at a verbally critiContinued on page 10
Scan page 10
Organiser Miners fight police at Orgreave: Between equal rights, force decides' - Karl Marx N DEPTH A fortnight ago, US astronomers announced to a bemused world that they had detected the ridence for an event that had occurred some 15 billion years ago.
The burden of this evidence was that, instead of being a form 2.73 Kelvin (K degrees above absolute zero), the average temperature of the universe varied by some 30 millionths of a degree either side of this.
On the face of it, this does not seem very significant. All the more surprising to hear
----- pull-quotes -----
"Is it possible for workers to fight back against a parliamentary majority, electea democratically,