A 'German model' for British workers Workers defy 'consensus
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-05-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Streik Robinson spring of discontent as a ermany is undergoing massive strike wave hits the Western half of Germany, with over 300,000 workers involved in action over the last week. In many cities there is no post, rubbish collection or public transport; some hospital workers, nursery nurses, airport ground crew, long-distance railway workers have also been involved. It is the biggest strike in post-war German history.
The public sector union OeTV has called a new wave of workers into action this week, giving about 250,000 on strike in the public sector. International air traffic is likely to be closed down this week. The engineering sector, including the car industry, went on warning strikes last week and may also stop work altogether when their compulsory cooling-off period expires this week and the union (IG Metall) is able to vote on strike action in response to the emplovers' provocative 3.3% offer. Building and print workers are also due to vote soon on their own negotiations.
Often in Germany, strikes are On the march in Hamburg averted by a compromise emerging from the long sequence of to break the strike, or just waiting for it to fall apart. Strike-breaking negotiations and ballots imposed would be unpopular with the by law. This time no compropublic, who are sympathetic to mise was possible, because of the the strike, and many civil sereconomic crisis brought about by vants have indicated they are the costs of the reunification unwilling to do it. with the East. About two-thirds of the costs of reunification has Alternatively, he could wait fallen on wage-earners. The offi- for the strike to collapse but this is unlikely to happen quickly and cial inflation rate is already 4.8% in the meantime it will be him and the prices of food and staple who becomes unpopular, rather goods is rising at between 10% than the strikers. Only a new deal and 20% according to union could get him off the hook and if spokesmen. Rents are soaring as the strike now wins anything a result of movements from East above 4.8% it will mean a humilito West. Despite election Eating defeat for Kohl and quite promises, Chancellor Kohl raised taxes to pay for reunification probably the end of his governalmost immediately on getting ment. back into power and then called While public sector workers for 0% wage rises. are particularly badly off, traditionally earning about 10% less he government, directly than the private sector, the disapinvolved in the public sector pearance of their traditional negotiations, and calling for well-being and security has hit all belt tightening to help the badly- workers hard. In the public secoff Easterners, sees this pay tor, the workers, seeing their round as critical to putting the living standards plunge because costs of reunification onto the of the economic crisis, voted in backs of the working class, and scarcely credible percentages for Chancellor Kohl has unwisely action: in the public sector union put his prestige at stake in hold- Delv, 89% for; in the post ing wages down. 95.4%; on the railways, 96.6%;
The two options to end the the support staff in the police strike satisfactorily would be union, 90%; and the traditionally using civil servants (who are not professional white-collar union, allowed to strike) and the army the DAG, 74%.
DO DOO
Right-wing press hate trade union Public opinion is also sympathetic to the strikers, with 54% in a recent poll giving support and half that percentage definitely with a large December 1990, is very unpopular, with the CDU (Conservative) share of the vote down to 34% and 75% unhappy with the government, which is generally blamed for the strike.
The public sector unions originally made a claim for 9.4% on wages. The claim went to arbitration and the arbitrators awarded 5.4%. While the unions were prepared to accept this, the employers, in a rare move intended to show their determination, rejected the award and stuck to their previous offer of s we go to press, the employers may be about to offer the 5.4%, but the union leaderships have publicly said that they now expect more (at least 5.8-6%) and would be unlikely to get the rank and file to accept what was in any case only halt the original claim.
The strike is the first in the public sector for 18 years, and the strike funds of the OeTV contain about DM 600 million. The union has calculated it needs 1 million DM a day to support 10,000 strikers, which would enable it to support a strike of some weeks, which is long by German standards. The leadership has decided on the tactics of a rolling strike, using sectors which have an immediate impact, such as transport and post, and focussing on the large cities. The strike is highly centralised and control over who comes out is in the hands of the union leadership, who have consciously aimed to avoid unpopular actions by, for example, not calling out medical personnel in hospitals. While there are some strike committees and mass meetings organised at a local level, there is as yet little way for the rank and control of the strike.
The strikes do not involve workers in the Eastern half of Germany. They are unable to go on strike and have an agreement by which they should reach Western wage levels automatically by 1994. The employers are now talking about delaying its implementation.
Even if wage levels were equalised, there are still many differences in working hours, overtime pay and holiday pay.
"The economic crisis has forced East would reach Western levels within five years now looks like sick joke."
The danger of not involving the East German public sector workers in the strike is that it will merely seive to accentuate the already existing divisions between Eastern and Western workers.
he economic crisis has forced Kohl to play for high stakes. In the East unemployment is running at 3 million (30-40%) and in January industrial production dropped by another 5% there. Kohl's election promise that the East would reach Western levels within five years now looks like a sick joke. State debt has rocketed to abou: E445 billion, and interest rates are high and likely to remain so.
As Britain is now in the Exchange Rate Mechanism, which is underpinned by Germany's helplessness. As usual, the social democratic politicians are torn between their role as employers in the nine provinces (in the West) and their own clientele. (Sound familiar?)
The effects of reunification are undoing the post-war industrial consensus in Germany, which has been the cause of the traditionally low level of industrial struggle there. In the past it has been possible to pay for higher wages and more state expenditure out of higher productivity and profits gained from Germany's successful competition on the world market.
Now neither the state nor the employers are willing to continue doing this in the face of the costs of reunification, which they hoped to offload onto the working class.
The Economist sadly states that after reunification, it was hoped that an influx of badlypaid workers from the East would force down West German wage rates. Instead, it continues what Is happening is that highly paid West German workers are creating pressure to bring Eastern wage rates up to Western levels. The conflict about the redistributive impact of reunification will continue for some time and it is unlikely that the "spring of discontent" will be the end of the issue.
For years, the "German model" was held up by bourgeois commentators as the solution to the "English disease" of striking. Now Britain has the lowest number of days lost through strikes since recording began, while Germany is undergoing a record wave of industrial action.
So now is the time when British trade unionists should start looking to the "German model" as an inspiration and a path of march for their own struggles.
Scan page 8
The Labow leadens said-direct action contradicțed
----- pull-quotes -----
Kohl to play for h stakes... his elect promise that the