[By Jim Denham orry to keep banging question…]
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-05-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
By Jim Denham orry to keep banging question just won't go away: to what extent did the tabloids contribute to Labour's election defeat? The question is central to the post-mortem now beginning within the party and it is of even more significance to those of us whose vision of socialism goes beyond election results. If the influence of the Tory tabloids was strong enough to deny Mr Kinnock's ultra-respectable New Model Labour Party electoral victory at so propitious a time, what are the chances for the kind of socialism that requires the working class to break with ruling class ideology altogether?
The common-sense view expressed by Kinnock himself in his resignation speech) is that the torrent of Tory propaganda disguised as "news". , and the downright lies about Labour policy that issued from the tabloids throughout the campaign, had a decisive effect. If it didn't. why would they bother! Come to that, why would Heineken spend millions on newspaper ads telling us that their lager refreshes parts which other beers cannot reach?
Then there is the evidence of the opinion polls: a survey by Mori shows that 4 per cent of Sun readers switched to the Tories in the last week of the campaign. That kind of swing would have been decisive in the 21 marginals that gave Major his majority. Against this is the fact that the same survey showed that 2.5 per cent of Mirror readers also switched to Tory in the same period, while readers of the Daily Mail (whose anti-Labour propaganda was, if anything even more vehement than that of the Sun), registered only a 2 per cent swing.
The great danger of blaming it all on the press is that it lets the Labour leadership off the hook: it wasn't their tailure to put forward a convincing and inspiring alternative that lost them the election - no, it was the all-powerful Tory press!
This is an attractive argument for many Labour supporters who are (rightly) outraged by the overwhelming bias and blatant dishonesty of the press. But it doesn't explain how it was that Labour won in against a press that was scarcely less hostile. And (as more than one i Tory commentator has noted) it implies a pretty poor view of the intelligence of the majority of working class people.
"The great danger of blaming it all on the press is that it lets the Labour leadership off the hook: it wasn't their failure to put forward a convincing and inspiring alternative that lost them the election - no, it was the all-powerful Tory Of course, the press is overwhelmingly biased against Labour, and it is very often blatantly dishonest. We need to think about what should be done about it. The temptation is to rush towards restrictions on press freedom that would, in fact, be counterproductive for the left. The British press is already restricted by a range of legal and regulatory restrictions that recently shocked a visiting newspaper editor from Estonia.
One proposal that would have no damaging effect on press freedom, but would greatly restrict the tabloids ability to lie and distort, would be to require that party political broadcasts be clearly distinguished from "news" and be marked with some sort of health warning (eg. "this is not a news item. It is a Conservative Party press handout slightly re-written). In fact, the Press Complaints Commission code of practice already requires papers to "distinguish clearly between comment, conjecture and fact" . It is about time that it was enforced.
Andrew Knight, the chairman of News International, has been at the forefront of the Tory-supporting media's rush to deny that their bias in any way influenced the election result. News International's Sun likewise insisted that there was "not a word of truth" in Neil Kinnock's claim that the tabloids played a major part in the Tory victory: "It is flattering of him to suggest we have so much power. Like so much else he says, it is also untrue" , protested a Sun Could this be the same Sun newspaper that on April 11th ran the front page headline "It's the Sun wot won it" and boasted that "Triumphant MPs were queuing yesterday to say "Thank You My Sun' for helping John Major back into Number 10"?