Stalinism was pre- was pre- capitalist not post- not post- not post- capitalist
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Harry Holland, from New Zealand, contributes to our debate on the nature of the Stalinist states or a long time i accepted the •formulation of Trotsky, that the USSR in the Stalinist era was a workers' state bureaucratically degenerated. The actual course of recent events makes it very unlikely that his description was correct.
The ruling group there has fallen over of its own inner rottenness, with scarcely any contribution in a direct way from the oppressed themselves. The Communist Party is banned and the old order, with its nomenklatura, defeated, even if it strives to reconstitute itself as an ordinary bourgeoisie.
In Trotsky's formulation, the position of the bureaucracy in society in the USSR was analogous to the position of the right-wing leadership of a trade union working within a capitalist society. Both take over and pervert "their" organisation for their own benefit, and operate it against the interests of the rank and file. It was implicit in his conception that the struggle in the USSR to restore a healthy functioning to the state and society would involve the conscious struggle of the masses to remove the commanding group.
Nothing remotely approaching the dynamic he envisaged seems to have occurred in the USSR in recent times. While to a very limited extent real trade unions reasserted themselves and some economic strikes took place in that country, in every other respect exploited working people over the last four years took on none of the consciously combative characteristics of the proletariat of Russia in 1917 It seems today that a very large number of workers see the re-establishment of market capitalism as their salvation, and even those that do not seemingly have little faith in their class to act in its own interest. The vast majority of the people appear to have become ensnared by nationalist delusions, and reject the notion of internationalism.
Even on the level of symbolism it is clear that anything that speaks of the October Revolution brings only feelings of hatred and loathing on the part of most of the "lower orders" in the USSR. They vote, for example, to restore the feudal name Yekaterinburg in place of Sverdlovsk, and St. Petersburg in place of Leningrad.
In terms of Trotsky's trade union analogy, the rank and file at present show every sign of wanting "their" union utterly destroyed and not just taken out of the hands of the perverters. The last thing on their minds is to revive and restore to health their own "workers" state.
One is hard put to it to find any useful historical analogy for what is happening, but the closest would seem to be the political stance of the "sans-culotte" plebeians in France in the early 1790s. In all important respects this layer fell in behind the Jacobin petit bourgeois revolutionaries who sought to make a successful bourgeois democratic revolution. The uttermost limit of the political horizon of the "sans-culottes" was to support those Jacobins who tried, by means of the Law of Maximum, to control price rises.
In summary then, both the old "bureaucracy" and the oppressed workers have, to date, emerged as losers. There has been a dissolution of the old order without a revolutionary reconstitution of society. Such a position has come about before in history, and is indeed accounted for in classical Marxist theory.
The second paragraph of the Communist Manifesto specifically states: "Freeman and slave, patrician and plebeian, lord and serf, guild-master and journeyman, in a word oppressor and oppressed, stood in constant opposition to one another, carried on a fight...that each time ended, either in a revolutionary reconstitution of society at large or, in the common ruin of the contending classes."
The working class revolution in October 1917 destroyed the remnants of feudalism, and the existing capitalist class with its specific state machine. Arguably the victorious working class of 1917 either did not create its own state machine at all, or did so for only a negligible period of time.
What flowed from the inability of the working class in the USSR to create an ongoing state to serve its own interests was a power vacuum. In this void Stalin's autocracy established a state machine to serve its own interests, and in any situation where its perceived interests ran counter to those of the workers and farmers, the autocracy prevailed.
If one the ian. a system harkward comnarad to manitaliem/ administrators of this ruling state machine as hureaucratic collectivists, then the unremitting class war nature of the rulersruled relationship is obscured by the terminology. I agree with Martin Thomas that the words "bureaucratic collectivist" convey a sense that the totality of the system was post-capitalist.
It is plain, however, that in spite of the monstrous deficiencies of canitalism. in developed countries its inner coherence and strength is far and away stronger and more self-regulating than the abomination Stalin created. It would be a bizarre outcome if this should come about in a social formation that stands on its shoulders in history.
Yet again, if for about seventy years what existed in the USSR was a sub-species of capitalism, viz "state capitalism", then certainly no ordinary capitalist state has in this period just fallen apart of its own inner rottenness, without a conscious effort on the part of its opponents to achieve this result. For the state capitalist theory to hold water, a fundamental revision of one of Marxism's most basic tenets is demanded.
In point of fact, the Stalinist autocracy was able to create only a command economy, without any of the self-correcting mechanisms of the market. Billions of decisions have to be made to operate a modern developed economy, and the commanders of the USSR were simply incapable of making the requisite number of quality decisions to enable the system to work, without delegating an unacceptably large part of their power to those that they oppressed.
At a certain point the rulers of the USSR were simply unable to continue to rule in the old way and they, with the Mafia, now seek to build a "normal" capitalist economy with a normal bourgeois state machine.
come to the conclusion that what existed in the USSR for about seventy years was, in all essential respects, a pre-capitalist formation. It involved the savage unremitting exploitation of a plebeian class by a master class, but it had few, if any, of the defining characteristics of feudalism. If it is felt necessary to find an analogy from the past, I think that the Asiatic mode of production comes closest to the reality of the Stalinist economic system, though the comparison is far from exact and the cant phrase "sui generis" - of its own kind - is probably preferable.
The Asiatic mode of production was incompatible with private property in land, and it could not tolerate pluralistic centres of political power such as feudalism in its early and middle periods typically threw up. An autocracy served by an extensive corps of administrators was the necessary command structure over this economic formation, and became self-perpetuating over time.
Exploitation and oppression of the vast majority of the population (the rural producers) by state administrators was at the heart of the system. The novelty of the Stalinist formation was that it sought to develop, extend and exploit a class of industrial helots rather than simply suck surplus value from rural producers. Unlike the ruling group in the "Asiatic mode of production" system it felt compelled, for nearly the whole period, to develop and invest in ever more sophisticated science and technology. Its structures simply could not accommodate these developments, and it self-destructed f the above is correct, obviously part of Trotsky's theorising is impaired, but I am content that a careful reading of his writings proves beyond doubt that the essential logic behind his position was that the workers, inside and outside the USSR, should adopt a defencist attitude to that country when it came into hostile collisions with capitalist states. His degenerated workers' state description provided the underpinning for that stance.
Paradoxically, if a pre-capitalisti characterisation is accepted, it too would make it imperative, from the standpoint of Marxist theory, to arrive at a defencist position. After all, Trotsky himself called for a defencist position from the workers, and other exploited people of feudal Abyssinia when that country came under attack from a fascist imperialism. Similarly, he called for workers' defencism for China, a colonial country under attack from Japanese imperialism.
I believe that Trotsky arrived at absolutely the correct practical position as regards defencism, and the USSR, even if by a route that was flawed.
Scan page 15
mt acrpe abers fght on By Rob Dawber and This attack by management 1950s; the fight: " Yorkshire has Yorkshire to work at Markham reduced from 60,000 miners to The lack of people at the pit They are out to break us ready arkham Main pit, in All of this followed on from was explained by a mass meet- for privatisation. The lads are court action taken by manage- no wet Was one oute angry and ready to light. ment to declare the first ballot welfare. Ker Coates was optimistic that Friday. nical irregularity. This ballot 200-300 men was voling to arrived a packed meetine of the Yorkshire Area would vote On arrival, a lonely security produced a 75% a majority for return to work pending the of the yorkshire Area result would make this more of private contractors into the ballot for supportive action. shop were the only people in SHI MIN These men had been on strike announced that the Yorkshire sells goods to miners. mlptor This was provoked by manage- in favour of supportive selective the shilt turning up for work This dispute is vital. Unions each time by further manage- home, claiming there was no should immediately send in retired miners. This shop, The three donations and messages of supLIVES WAS WE DICIES! retired miners had no doubt This, added to the fact that casualties when industrial what was at stake. "Your lot are wages per shift were dropped again to be at the forefront in from £42.10 to £18.90 was a delending trade union rights; Management refused to con- RMT. "that's for sure - coal. clear attempt to provoke further AN NIS action. The men voted to strike possible backing.
ITWUNER Have ow Dee One week for goods bought, "but they are Northumberland, St piss wire Steve Clarke, the NUM dele- support to Kev Coates, NUM gate. and Ker Coates, the Branch Secretary, 98 Tranmoor the old", said another of the shown on it; now only three retired miners. remain. 54 have closed since ortan Sputii iork By a Central Be all wanted Labour to get in - but they haven't. Would Labour have solved all our problems? No a Labour government wouldn't have done what we needed, what the working class needs. It wouldn't have acted with the same loyalty to our class as the Tories show to theirs. But it would have given us more space to fight for what And!5revetke Yorkshire, was deserted last guard, plus three retired miners sight. The colliery Shop, money for charity.
"Last year we raised 30,000 for all sorts of charities, action began at Markham Main. tinue the facility of deducting taking money from the sick we want and, through the unions, it would have been more vulnerable to pressure from workers. So what happens now?
The Tories won so we can't do anything... Rubbish! In '89, Thatcher was at the height of her power with a majority of 100: we beat the company and the Tories then and we can do it again! We need to remind ourselves that we are enormously strong.
As tubeworkers, we have huge facilities from the NUM offices Main. was another. economic power. London is the financial centre of Britain and we can shut it down if we stand together.
The Company Plan affects everyone of us. Whatever our grade! Every section is faced with its own productivity package. Each one tearing up agreements that we use every day - agreements that protect us, that make the job bearable. The details vary from grade to grade, but the bottom line is if •HMN since wednesday ADr 1oln.
He mason ate caci action. one-day strike they would send there are 25% fewer staff, the ones who are still "lucky to have a job" will be working 25% harder.
And that "lucky to have a job" arrogance sums up the arrogance of management. If we let them get away with the Company Plan, we'll be giving a free hand to every third-rate, tinpot dictator on LUL.
With seniority abolished, being forced to reapply and requalify for our own jobs, with perfor16,000 since the 1984-85 strike.
to support them. However. be recognised that the election MY HIN ПОНІНИЕ DII ML. CIU Lane, Armthorpe, Doncaster, mance pay and personal contracts, management will have us over a barrel.
And management are implementing the Company Plan. They have insisted on continuing to implement the Plan while negotiations go on, and the only thing they are prepared to negotiate is "how to implement the Company Plan". The time for talking is past. Actions speak louder than words. We need to fight back now!
The first thing is to get a big Yes vote in the RMT ballot. A big majority will show management that we mean business and will give us all more confidence for the fight ahead.
ASLEF and TSSA must come off the sidelines. Their members must demand to be balloted as well. In any case, we must all respect the picket lines of any union.
We have a hard fight ahead of us, but it's one we can win as long as we remember: Unity is the key: if we don't stand together, we'll hang together! We need to throw out all of the Company Plan - nothing less!
The Tories will, no doubt, use the courts. We need to stop the Plan by any means necessary!
Since the miners' strike, assorted media pundits and new realists have written off the working class. The class struggle and the very existence of a working class have been derided as notions of an earlier and simpler age. Well, you can deny the existence of the class struggle, but it continues nevertheless!
For example, LUL personnel director, Straker, warned last week that if RMT took strike action, "there will be corpses".
The tube bosses are certainly in no doubt as to the existence Socialist Organiser No. 521 page 15 Shut down the system! of the class struggle! They know what they want and they're clear about what they're prepared to do to get it. Is this an exception? Not at all. What's striking about what's happening on the tubes is its similarity to what's happening in many other parts of industry.
The Company Plan would mean the introduction of teamworking, multiskilling, performance pay, personal contracts, contracting out and massive job cuts... to name but a few!
All of these would mean a huge increase in the rate of exploitation of workers. As workers we have to sell our labour power to live but, by selling our labour power, we are exploited. And it is that exploitation that gives rise to class struggle. This is the economic base on which modern capitalist society rests.
There are no two ways about it: as long as there is capitalism, there will be class struggle. Reports of its death have been greatly exaggerated!