Alienation, Armani sex and Sartre
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Lads appropriate taminar images to stays totally cool and deadpan, kind to Elizabeth's mother, Hanna, while everyone around him is the woman who saw Faber off in fantasies. The film shows But once Faber meets to us through Faber's jaundiced Elizabeth, Faber's daughter, falling Elizabeth, cliche sets in. Their eyes - this woman who's trying to In 1859, Joseph Cowen took control of the Newcastle Daily Chronicle and transformed what had previously been a Whig paper into a radical newspaper that condemned the evictions of the miners and their families by pit owners and opened its pages to miners' leaders. Thomas Burt, secretary of the Northumberland Miners Association wrote a letter to the Newcastle Daily Chronicle arguing the miners' case. Burt was invited to the Chronicle's offices, where he was told, "the columns of the Chronicle are always open...for the defence of the miners and their right to combine."
The Chronicle was to play an important role in supporting the 1871 engineers strike for the ninelour day, one of the most important industrial disputes ir nineteenth century Britain. From an early stage in the strike Cowen instructed the Newcastle Daily Chronicle's editorial staff to "keep a sharp look-out for news from the engineers. Tell Burnett [one of the strike leaders] we will print all he wants, printed in the way of news." Free copies of the newspaper were provided for circulation in other engineering centres.
Engineers' mass meetings on the Town Moor ended with cheers for the Newcastle Daily Chronicle.
Todd poses a number of "what ifs", the most important of which is: "What if Cowen had become the leader of what was to become the Labour Party?" Engels is quoted as saying: "A proletarian radical party is now forming under the leadership of Joseph Cowen, an old Chartist, half, if not a whole Communist, and a very fine fellow... " This was said at a meeting held in London in 1891 to discuss the formation of "an independent working class party".
Unlike the "Marxists" of his Belinda Weaver reviews Voyager Venturor's wet dream. 1E3 oyager is a fortysomething infuriating.
It's about a man, Walter Faber, forced by work to travel a lot, who doesn t care were ne goes because his lite doesn't mean anything. Faber's early voice-overs about chance and coincidence are trite, but they prepare us for the corny coincidences to come - that he'll fall for a young girl who will turn out to be his long lost daughter. And you thought it only happened in Dynasty...)
The film opens with Faber feeling alienated in Athens airport. Faber is played by Sam Shepard in specs, and he's posed like Arthur Miller. It's as if director Volker Schlondorff were trying to borrow Miller's integrity, the way that TV sell us things.
What is Schlondorff selling? His panicking. in love with him, and casting herself into his arms. If this isn't wishful thinking, what is? Schlondorff has turned the Lolita syndrome on its head, and used Shepard's handsomeness and deadpan cool to make it credible.
All through the film, women fling themselves at Faber. He doesn't have to try; he just is, and they want him. It's a male fantasy.
Schlondorff's use of women as props for the Faber ego is not the tim's only talling. The whole "philosophical" basis is shaky. Faber is meant to be an outsider, Camus's Outsider, no less, complete with alienation, and all the world weariness he can summon up.
All very well, except that hauling in the philosophers doesn't mean a thing. Schlondorff may think he's up there with the philosophers, that he's putting their ideas on the screen. But he's not. He's just putting a fancy name to Faber's self-absorption.
The film's early scenes have some zip. In a plane crash, Faber romanti idyl predicta ble - sl face, his mus ings life, etc., etc.
"Schlondo turned the Shepard's handsomeness and deadpan cool to make credible... It's male fantasy.
The film is nowhere Athens at the start. She's presented is a hingly lots of hi : fresh about her rest for near clip his wings by forcing him into marriage and parenthood - and she comes across as shrill and harsh and rigid. Schlondorff doesn't even try to put how she feels on to the screen - presumably he doesn't know, and couldn't begin to guess -so all we get is Faber's reactions and given his stunted emotions, all we see is evasiveness.
What is the excuse for this one sidedness? Schiondorff's failure of imagination? Faber treats Hanna cruelly, not just in the early days when he deserts her (hiding beind the fiction that it's her choice), but later, in Athens, when Elizabeth is ill in the hospital. He offers no words of comfort; he's too preoccupied with himself.
Faber is an emotional miser. When women ask him for anything, he hides behind his blankness. Schlondorff poses this as a tragedy (for Faber) when it's really a tragedy for everybody but Faber, that the tragedy lies in the damage and hurt he causes other people.
Voyager is set in a male universe, where a man who loses a lover of a few days (even if she is his daughter) gets more sympathy than the woman who raised her from an infant.
Alienation is such a swanky, romantic affliction. European films of the fifties were full of it - worldweary men abounded, all moaning on about life's emptiness, etc., etc. Schlondorff is obviously nostalgic -Voyager is set in the fifties. But can anyone really work up any sympathy for Faber? Even men? Even unreconstructed men? Isn't "incapacity to feel" just a little bit self-inflicted, like blocking your nose and then complaining you can't breathe?
Alienation doesn't stop Shepard from looking good or going places in Armani suits or even having love and sex. It serves as an alibi when he wants out of anywhere. A very convenient ailment!
I suspect Voyager will be a hit with all the Sam Shepard wannabes and all the pseuds who "love" European films and "hate" Hollywood. But Hollywood is more honest than Voyager. When it sells sex, it sells sex. It doesn't haul in Camus and Sartre and call it philosophy
----- pull-quotes -----
syndrome head, and