Livingstone offers quack radicalism
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
The one-time champion of farhimself as the defender of middle-income earners", reported the Evening Standard in its article on Ken Livingstone's candidacy for the Labour leadership.
For once this Tory rag was fairly accurate. Ken Livingstone presents himself as a man with an economic miracle-cure. If Labour undertakes to carry out its Party conference policy of cutting military spending to the West European average, then, says Livingstone, it can find money for reforms without taxing "middle-income earners", and thus win back votes lost! the tax rises John Smith proposed in th Shadow Budget.
Livingstone is quite right to insist that Labour should cut military spending, and to point out that military cuts would free resources for reforms. 500 new hospitals could have been built for the cost of the Trident nuclear weapon programme.
Beyond that, however, Livingstone's pitch is charlatan demagogy.
Firstly, military spending cuts would not be a miracle-cure. They would free resources, but only over time. Demobilisation, re-equipping of factorie producing military goods, and re-trainin of workers, would cost - unless Livingstone proposes just to throw all the workers from military production, and the soldiers, on the streets without dole or redundancy money!
Could a Labour government say: *Restoring the Health Service will have to wait three years, until we can cash in the military spending cuts"?
Even longer-term, the military spending cuts would release, at maximum, about 3 per cent of national output to add to the 40 percent or so that currently goes through Government hands. The odd 3% would be very useful, but nowhere near an adequate lever for the reconstruction of industry and public services.
A cut in military spending to the West European average would permit, best, "West European average" capitalism, not anything socialist.
Not without reason did Marx and Engels make their second demand in the Communist Manifesto: "A heavy progressive or graduated income tax". It is utter quackery to claim that any socialist policy is possible without seizing the wealth of the rich, confiscating the means of production, and taxing at least the richest 15% or 20% - and, as it happens, it was only that top 15-20% (currently taking some 40% of household income, or more than the bottom 60-odd per cent) that the Shadow Budget proposed to hit with tax rises. That Shadow Budget would have left people on £400 to £499 a week a bit better off on average, and seriously hit only those on more than £1,000 a week.
The nonsense appears even worse if you envisage a socialist policy on an international scale, which would have tr include taxing the richer countries to finance rapid development programmes in other countries.
ivingstone's economic demagogy amounts to an attempt to propose "radical" economics without class struggle. His miracle cure would allow progress without attacking the wealth or income of the top 15 or 20%. According to Livingstone at the "London Labour Left" meeting on 15 April, Britain's high military spending is dictated exclusively by American interests, and so Livingstone has managed to reduce the struggle for socialism into one against American influence, with no fight necessary between the classes in Britain!
Military spending cuts should be supported. To present them as the key socialist advance is dishonest windbaggery.
Secondly, Livingstone evades and diverts attention from the basic reasons for Labour's defeat.
The Tories, who have raised taxes for the average household, defeated Labour, who were proposing to cut taxes for most households. The reason for that must be something more than the tax rises Labour proposed for a minority!
The Tories used the slump to boost themselves. They warned that "you can't trust Labour". The Tories were the tried and-tested "natural party of government" for capitalism. They said that each individual should hold on to their own, not experiment with Labour's expensive and unreliable plans for restoring public services.
Against that appeal to bedrock bourgeois selfishness and caution, Labour had little to offer, and did not look as if it could be trusted even on thai little.
The Tories "coded" their message in a lying campaign about a Labour government costing everyone £1,250 a year in tax.
To reduce problem of the appeal to the basic prejudices instilled capitalism to the detail of the Shadow Budget is to miss the point. To suppose that the answer is some clever economic gimmick - so many billion pounds gained from military cuts without offending anyone! - is to evade the problem of bringing the Labour Party to such a state of mind and body that it can counterpose a "political economy of the working class" (in Marx's phrase), of "social production controlled by social foresight", to "the blind rule of the supply and demand laws which form the "Livingstone's economic demagogy amounts to an attempt to propose "radical economics without class struggle... Livingstone has managed to reduce the struggle for socialism to one against American influence, with no fight necessary between the classes Britain."
political economy of the middle class".
Thirdly, Livingstone looks to the wrong section of society. The so-called "middle-income" people who would be hit by the Shadow Budget were in fact the top 15-20%. The great majority on less than about £25,000 a year stood to gain.
Livingstone (like the Tories!) makes much of figures of £19,000 or 20,000 fol "average male earnings" in the SouthEast. This "average" is misleading. If ter people get 510,000 a year each, one gets £20,000, and one gets £120,000, the average for all twelve is £20,000, but the person on £20,000 is not an average earner". In any case, the person on £20,000 would be better off from the Shadow Budget!
The Tory press, seeking sympathetic examples of people who would be hit by Labour's tax rises, cited doctors, head teachers, middle managers, and police inspectors. They could have added lawyers, accountants, City dealers, highrank computer experts, maybe a few skilled manual workers doing exceptionally long hours, and small employers or self-employed tradesmen.
Labour can and should win over some of these people. But they cannot be central. In the first place Labour has to respond to and mobilise the other 80 per cent!
Fourthly, Livingstone's economics expose him as utterly inconsistent and unreliable.
Only a few years ago, when he was local government, Livingstone was a keen supporter of high taxes, and not just for the top 20%! He argued that it was progressive for Labour councils to levy high rates (property taxes), becau they would be squeezing middle-incom people and businesses to provide services for the poor, who would be protected by rate rebates.
Jeering hostility to better- off workers and the middle-class ("moremiserable-than-thou"') is as stupid and counterproductive for socialists as centring our policy on the interests and desires of those better-off people.
The common thread for Livingstone is that both policies - the high-tax polic of yesteryear and the low-tax policy of now - are attempts to seem radical whil evading class struggle.
Scan page 13
how he came to be so popular with the working class, Cowen replied: "Well, this is the explanation. While you have been sitting at home in the cold nights with your feet comfortable on the rug before your drawing room fire I have been for 20 years travelling about, in sunshine or storm, to every Tyneside place or distant colliery village, talking to the pitmen, assisting in establishing their humble institutions, and giving them what information was in my power; and it now comes to pass that they happen to remember it, and be grateful for it." ber (Sam Shepard) CULTURAL FRONT (Julie Organiser
----- pull-quotes -----
THE POLITICAL ECONOMY "T left causes is now styling