Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[but all the more surely seizing state power…]

Socialist Organiser no. 521, 23 April 1992 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 1,386 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

but all the more surely seizing state power, the proletariat something in the nature of a thereby "puts an end to the state as "Hegelian weakness" on Engels' state." It is "not good form" to pon- part. As a matter of fact, however, der over the meaning of this. these words briefly express the Glossary feudal society, the kings (that is, Magerate spi alisa demeemn The Paris Commune in 1871: against the lords who resisted Democrat" meant Marxist, not, M1250 as it does today, liberalstate in then-divided Germany) Ethe capitalist. The then-Marxist invaded France in 1870-71, the wal resen кокі збасс!

ch government said ame Tand IIl in France (1799-1815 had an impressive record of nine weeks. Bismarck in Prussia/Germany Elections.

Kautsky: Leading writer of the (1862-1890). The state Feudal state, serfs: The serf tot-of who used socialist phrases, ie. in was a peasant of the Middle LOTI this context, supposed socialists Ages, holding land under an te 31 на 283 WON HOPK enor the industrialists and merchants. SUCH OF THEN tr Keras instead of denouncing the whole overlord himself might owe who w war as a battle between thieves.

whole structure was called * 911 VVIK "feudalism" overthrown) and October 1917 Na/n with them in detail.

We shall quote the whole argument from which they are taken.

"The proletariat seizes state power and to begin with transforms the means of production into state property. But it thus puts an end to itself as proletariat, it thus puts an end to all class differences and class antagonisms, and "The state is an organisation of the exploiting class at each period for the maintenance of its external conditions production, that is, particularly for the forcible holding down of the exploited class in the conditions of oppression (slavery, villeinage or serfdom, wage-labour) given by the existing mode of production."

thus also to the state as state. Moving in class antagonisms, society up to now had need of the state, that is, an organisation of the exploiting class at each period for the maintenance of its external conditions of production, that is, particularly for the forcible holding down of the exploited class in the conditions of oppression (slavery, villeinage or serfdom, wage-labour) given by the existing mode of production. The state was the official representative of the whole of society, its concentration in a visible body, but it was so only in so far as was the state of that class which its time represented the whole society: in antiquity, the state of the slave-owning citizens, in the Middle Ages, of the feudal nobility, in our time, of the bourgeois. When ultimately it becomes the real representative of the whole of society, it renders itself superfluous. As soon as there is no social class to be held in subjection any longer, as soon as class domination and the struggle for individual existence based on the anarchy of production existing up to now are eliminated together with the collisions and excesses arising from them, there is nothing more to repress, nothing necessitating a special repressive force, a state. The first act in which the state really comes forward as the representative of the whole of society - the taking possession of the means of production in the name of society - is at the same time its last independent act as a state. The interference of the state power in social relations becomes superfluous in one sphere after another, and then dies away of itself. The government of persons is replaced by the administration of things and the direction of the processes of production. The state is not "abolished,' it withers away. It is by this that one must evaluate the phrase 'a free people's state' with respect both to its temporary agitational justification and to its ultimate scientific inadequacy, and it is by this that we must also evaluate the demand of the so-called anarchists that the state should be abolished overnight." (Anti-Duhring. Herr Eugen Duhring's Revolution in It may be said without fear of error that of this argument of Engels' which is so remarkably rich in ideas, only one point has become an integral part of socialist thought among modern socialist parties, namely, that according to Marx the state "withers away" - as distinct from the anarchist doctrine of the "abolition" of the state. To prune Marxism in such a manner is to reduce it to opportunism; for such an "interpretation" only leaves a vague notion of a slow, even, gradual change, of absence of leaps and storms, of absence of revolution. The current, widespread, mass, if one may say so, conception of the "withering away" of the state undoubtedly means slurring over, if not repudiating, revolution. Such an "interpretation," however, is the crudest distortion of Marxism, advantageous only to the bourgeoisie; in point of theory, it is based on a disregard for the most important circumstances and considerations indicated, say, in Engels' "summarv" argument which we have just quoted in full. In the first place, at the very outset of his argument Engels says that, in the workers took over Paris for tribute to a higher lord. The Absolute monarchies: As

ORRYS

Generally, it is either ignored altogether, or is considered to be "After 'the state has taken possession of the means of production in the name of the whole o society, that is, after the socialist revolution, the political form of the 'state' at that time is the most complete democracy." and trade grew in the cities of the top feudal lords) strengthened their power and asiers the emerging capitalist class 419361-701 auda Po between February 1917 (when (when the workers, led by Lenin serfdorn. Socialist Organiser No. 521 page 11 experience of one of the greatest proletarian revolutions, the Paris Commune of 1871, of which we shall speak in greater detail in its proper place. As a matter of fact, Engels speaks here of the proletarian revolution "putting an end to" the bourgeois state, while the words "withering away" refer to the remnants of the proletarian state system after the socialist revolution. According to Engels, the bourgeois state does not "wither away, "but the proletariat "puts an end to" it in the course of the revolution. What withers away after this revolution is the proletarian state or semi-state. Secondly, the state is a "special repressive force." Engels gives this splendid and extremely profound definition here with the utmost lucidity. And from it follows that the "special repressive force" for the suppression of the proletariat by the bourgeoisie, of millions of the working people by handfuls of the rich, must be replaced by a "special repressive force" for the suppression of the bourgeoisie by the proletariat (the dictatorship of the proletariat). This is precisely what is meant by "putting an end to the state as state." This is precisely the "act" of taking possession of the means of production in the name of society. And it is self-evident that such a replacement of one (bourgeois) "special force" by another (proletarian) "special force" cannot possibly take place in the form of "withering away." Thirdly, in speaking of "withering away," and the even more graphic and colourful "dying away of itself," Engels refers quite clearly and definitely to the period after "the state has taken possession of the means of production in the name of the whole of society," that is, after the socialist revolution. We all know that the political form of the "state" at that time is the most complete democracy. But it never enters the head of any of the opportunists who shamelessly distort Marxism that Engels is consequently speaking here of democracy "dying away of itself," or "withering away." This seems very strange at first sight; but it is "incomprehensible" only to those who have not pondered over the fact that democracy is also a state and that, consequently, democracy will also disappear when the state disappears. Revolution alone can "put an end to" the bourgeois state. The state in general, ie., the most complete democracy, can only "wither SRs and Mensheviks:

Russia. Chernovs, etc: their German Social-Democracy. When Lenin was writing, Social building up its score in General Social-chauvinists: Chauvinists Poletes Cransi

Scan page 12

Socialist Organiser No. 521 page 12

----- pull-quotes -----

ATIVE PARTY FRENCE

po Wittet Oper ardens bus.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 521

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →