[between the union and the Communist Party leadership…]
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
between the union and the Communist Party leadership. The liquidation of the ROH at the all-union conference of March 1990 was the logical conclusion of this process.
Civic Forum leaders announced that new unions would be formed on the basis of local Civic Forums and workplace strike alert committees. The for"We want to give him from Lidove noviny and, increasingly. the Socal Democratic Party.
period to approve the new law on state enterprises. This law removed all elements of enterprise self-management, like the work collective council, election of doesn't Council of Social and Economic Accord, which union bosses justify with Western union-style rhetoric of "social partnership" ignored Czechoslovak conditions, and is a failure.
The formation of OS CMS is a new chance for the trade union movement here. But the new union must be able to overcome the problems mentioned above. ment and employee-entrepreneur forms. Possible examples include the American ESOP system, or "The mechanisms of social partnership' cannot solve much in our present conditions. Given the the current time, 'social partnership" seems more like the corporatist system of the Mondragon co-operative work in Spain.
The demand for the widest possible co-management by workers at all levels of the economy gives the trade unions their specific character in our current conditions. Co-operation with those left political forces with selfmangement programmes will be to the advantage of both sides:
* Vrat'a Votava is president of Left Alternative (Leva alternativa), a coalition of small anarchist and Trotskyist groups, as well as militants from the Romany national minority. He is standing for election to the Czech Parliament on the Communist Party's Left Bloc list.
(Reprinted from Nase pracet, 20 March 1992; translated by Adam Novak) Karel Hynes, President of the Trade Union Association of Bohemia, Moravia, and Slovakia (OS CMS) talked to Adam Novak How did your union form?
We were founded in April 1991, ten months after the old federation (ROH) was dissolved. Trade union rights were more and more under attack. 56% of the 8 million original members had left the unions. The new federation (CSKOS) was not interested. 2,000 dissatisfied militants founded OS CMS to stop the erosion of trade union rights, to build up the unions, and to make them a real force in the land on social questions. We are a general union, because we don't want to further divide the union movement. By our first congress in October 1991 we had 120,000 members. We are growing slowly but steadily.
Leaders of the major federation, CSKOS, have dismissed you as "Red Unions", splitting the movement for political reasons...
I was, and am, a communist. But we have members from all political parties. Our union is not non-political; "non-political" doesn't mean anything, except maybe supporting the governmer
Scan page 9
Tragedy in s did not play any significant role in the Czechoslovak "Velvet Revolution" «We want-to be a reav force don soctal questions" We have policies on defending certain rights, but we are in no way a party union. We want the greatest possible union unity, and wherever possible a joint approach to management and the government. We have good relations with the Christian unions.
It's no secret that relations with the federation are worse. We have had one meeting with them, and will have another exchange of view soon. Ordinary people know unity is necessary, but some of the federation's union leaders are not interested.
How many staff do you have?
One staff member and one secretary. We don't want a large secretariat, we would rather create full-time posts for lawyers and other staff in the regions, at the source. The other trade unions have only industrial structures, and have abandoned the regions. This is a mistake. Regional organisation is very important for unemployment, education and other social questions.
One woman produces our newspaper Nase prace (Our Labour) as a part-time job. It has print run of 10,000. We want to go weekly as soon as possible. We are glad to have a growing number of correspondents; we want it to be a paper of the union members, to which the leaders respond, and not a paper of the union leaders.
What is your view of the -economic reform?
The economic reform is asocial, it doesn't take social questions into account. None of the governing parties had the current reforms in their electoral programmes. We simply cannot allow people to slide into real poverty through no fault o their own.
And privatisation?
Privatisation, originally one of the means to achieve the economic transformation, has become the sole goal of the transformation. We want the original reform programmes — equality of property and enterprise forms. We want to see the development of worker shares, ESOP, co-operatives, etc. Privatisation is becoming increasingly political and its critics attacked more and more sharply.
What about the coupon privatisation?
This was supposed to be something for the people, but the investment funds are more and more important, and many of them have foreign capital behind them -so this is another back door way for foreign capital to buy up our industry cheaply.
And foreign investment?
We are not against foreign investment. The issue is the conditions under which investmen comes. Foreigners must invest to produce, not to win markets or to speculate. A big problem is the government's policy of cheap labour to win investments. This is not good for us or for workers in the West, where it pushes down wages and weakens the struggle fo better conditions. This surely reinforces the need for us all to work together.
Why are there still virtually no strikes in Czecho-Slovakia?
Fear, pure and simple.
Everybody expects further job losses, and does not want to be the first. Also, don't forget that people are not used to these new conditions. Before work moved to the people. Now they have no work What will OS CMS do about the elections?
The union as such won't stand in the election. But 11 of our members will stand as union candidates, with our programme, on the lists of parties of which they are members; five with the Left Bloc, and others with the Liberal Social Union (a social democratictype coalition of the Socialist, Green and Agrarian parties). Entering parliament wasn't our original goal; we've been pushed to it by developments. We want to be at the source of legislation, and influence it.
The economic situation will certainly worsen after the elections. Do you think workers will become more militant and left-wing?
I think this is happening now, before the elections. There is however a danger that people disillusioned with the reforms will simply not vote. It is the job of the left to make them participate, no matter which left party they will vote for.
‹ab The imminent victory of the Muslim mujahedin in Kabu is bringing to a close a long and tragic chapter in the struggle of the urban middle class, and sections of the embryonic working class, in Afghanistan against the forces of a barbaric countryside.
Afghanistan's rural world is one thousand and more years behind the main towns, which ar oases of modern civilisation in a sea of tribal society. Large-scale massacres of their enemies are only too likely to be a part of the mujahedin victory, Yet there is more to it. The Muslim fighters' conquest of the capital, Kabul, is also the final episode in a heroic battle waged by the people of Afghanistan -the people as they are, which is not what socialists would like them to be - to stop themselves being subdued by foreign invaders. one of the factors which undermined From 1979 to 1988, the Russian empire tried and failed to conquer Afghanistan, using the people who are now losing control of the towns as its allies and puppets. Against the people of Afghanistan they used all the terrible techniques of repression developed by the other great imperialist predators of the mid 20th century against colonial peoples.
They did what the Americans did in Vietnam, what the French did in Algeria and Indochina, and what the Nazis had done in those parts of the USSR they overran at the beginning of the Second World War.
They slaughtered civilians, burned crops to control the supply of food to the guerrillas fighting them, napalmed villages.
By the early '80s, one in four of Afghanistan's 20 million people - that is, about five million people - had been driven over the Pakistan and Iran borders as refugees.
The Russian empire could generate enough energy and determination to win: to do that would have required more than double the 100,000 Russian soldiers continuously there, and Fghan soldiers outside ajibullah involved the massacre of immense numbers of Afghanis. The faltering USSR never got more than a garrison control in Afghanistan's cities, and then it got bogged down. The bloody failure in Afghanistan was one the factors which undermined and then brought down the Stalinist system.
For eight and a half years, the Russian occupation overshadowed everything else. The fact that the Afghan regime the Russians left behind them when they withdrew in 1988 did not co lapse for over three years indicates that it was not only a creature of the Russians. A version of that regime had been in power before the Russian invasion. It came to power in a coup in April 1978 organised by the Afghan CP (the "People's Democratic Party", PDP), which was heavily middle-class and con trolled the key segments of the officer corps of the air force and the army.
Many of those who made that PDP coup in 1978 had made an earlier coup, overthrowing the king, in 1973, only to see power slip from their hands. They turned to the PDP, as did the professional middle class That turn to Stalinism was prepared for by the fact that from the mid "50s onwards Afghanistan was in close military alliance with the USSR, confronting Pakistan which was allied to the USA. The officers and technicians of the air force, the tank crews, and so on, were trained in the USSR.
Over time they adopted the goal of creating a Stalinist state Afghanistan to modernise the country.
But all those developments were happening in the towns. The PDP failed to raise the people of the countryside against the priests and landlords. Within months of the April 1978 coup, the landlords and the priests had roused the people against the "infidel" regime.
Civil war and brutal intraStalinist faction-fighting and purges within the airforce and the army brought the regime to the verge of disaster. To avert that, the USSR invaded over Christmas 1979.
Nine years later they left. Now the town-based armed forces and secularised professional classes who allied with the USSR, and thought they could modernise Afghanistan by Stalinist methods of state terror and forced-march industrialisation have come to the disaster they looked to the Russians to stave off in 1979.
Theirs is the tragedy of a class. which took power in conditions where it could not realise its programme because of the backwardness of the society which they live.
Kabul before the fall of
Scan page 10
In this, the second of a series of excerpts from State and Revolution, Lenin explains how, in even a full parliamentary democracy, without any monarchy or House of Lords, capitalist class rule continues behind the scenes of apparent equality. The worker has one vote, and the capitalist has one vote; but the capitalist also has power through the ability of his wealth to influence state officials, affect government finances, control the media, and None of this means that Lenin thought parliamentary democracy was irrelevant and unimportant. He was writing for a Marxist movement which had long focused much of its energy on fighting for and utilising parliamentary democracy, and "bending the stick" towards recognition of the limits of parliamentary democracy as long as capitalist power over the means of production remains * In contrast Monater Stalinist distortions, Lenin takes it as obvious that "the political form" of socialism must be "the most Organiser so on. complieterdemocracy."
ENE АБЛА
INSTRUMENT FOR THE EXPLOITATION OF THE KISSI MOLASS For the maintenance of the special public power standing above society, taxes and state loans are needed.
"In possession of the public power and the right to levy taxes," Engels writes, "the officials now stand, as organs of society, above society. The free, voluntary respect that was accorded to the organs of the gentile [clan] constitution does not satisfy them, even if they could gain it.... " Special laws are enacted proclaiming the sanctity and inviolability of the officials. "The shabbiest police servant" has more "authority" than the representatives of the clan, but even the head of the military power of a civilised state may well envy the elder of a clan for the "unforced respect" of society.
Here the problem of the privileged position of the officials as organs of state power is raised. The main question indicated is: What is it that places them above society? We shall see how this theoretical question was answered in practice by the Paris Commune in 1871 and how it was slurred over in a reactionary manner by Kautsky in 1912.
"Because the state arose from the need to hold class antagonisms in check, and because it arose, at the same time, in the midst of the conflict of these classes, it is, as a rule, the state of the most powerful, economically dominant class, which, through the medium of the state, becomes also the politically dominant ciass, and thus acquires new means of holding down and exploiting the oppressed class." Not only were the ancient and feudal states organs for the exploitation of the slaves and serfs, but "the modern representative state is an instrument of exploitaBourgeois demecracy in Chile was oider than in most European countries, but when a left-wing government headed by Salvador Allende was elected in 1970 ail hell broke loose. The middle classes foliowed the bourgeoisie into open revolt; the CiA deliberately set out to destabilise the government. Then in September 1973 Chile's armed forces organised a coup. The labour movement was puiverised and tens of thousands of its militants were killed, tortured and imprisoned. The fear of such a coup paralysed the Labour Government of DICTADUE the mid- 70s: the trade union leader Jack Jones admitted it publicly. In the early *80s, fear of what then Labour leader Michael Foot called "the stormtroopers helped stop Labour fight back with direc action against Thatcherism.
LENIN
tion of wage labour by capital. By way of exception, however, periods occur in which the warring classes balance each other so nearly that the state power, as ostensible mediator, acquires, for the moment, a certain degree of independence of both." Such were the absolute monarchies of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, the Bonapartism of the First and Second Empires in France, and the Bismarck regime in Germany, Such, we may add, is the Kerensky government in republican Russia since the commencement of its persecution of the revolutionary proletariat, and at a moment when, owing to the leadership of the petty-bourgeois democrats, the Soviets have already become impotent, while the bourgeoisie is not yet strong enough simply to disperse them.
In a democratic republic, Engels continues, "wealth exercises its power indirectly, but all the more surely, " first, by means of the "direct corruption of officials" (America); second, by means of "an alliance between the government and the Stock Exchange" (France and America).
At the present time, imperialism and the domination of the banks have "developed" into an extraordinarily fine art both these methods of upholding and giving effect to the omnipotence of wealth in democratic republics of all descriptions. If, for instance, in the very first months of the Russian democratic republic, one might say during the honeymoon of the "socialist" S.R.'s and Mensheviks joined in wedlock to the bourgeoisie, Mr. Palchinsky, in the coalition government, sabotaged every measure intended for curbing the capitalists and their marauding practices, their plundering of the treasury by means of war contracts; and if later on Mr. Palchinsky, upon resigning from the cabinet (and being, of course, replaced by another quite similar Palchinsky), was "rewarded" by the capitalists with a lucrative job bringing in a salary of 120,000 rubles per annum, what would you call that? Direct or indirect bribery? An alliance between the government and the directors syndicates, or "merely" friendly relations? What role do the Chernovs, Tseretelis, Avksentyevs and Skobelevs play? Are they the "direct" or only the indirect allies of the millionaire treasury-looters?
The reason why the omnipotence of "wealth" is more sure in a democratic republic is that it does not depend on a bad political shell of capitalism. A democratic repubtic is the best possible political shell for capitalism, and, therefore. once capital has grasped this very best shell (through the Palchinskys. Chernovs, Tseretelis and Co.), it establishes its power so securely, so surely, that no change, either of persons, of institutions, or of parties in the bourgeois democratic republic, can shake this power.
We must also note that Engels is most definite in calling universal suffrage an instrument of bourgeois rule. Universal suffrage, he says, obviously taking into account the long experience of German Social-Democracy, is "the gauge of the maturity of the working class It cannot and never will be anything more in the present-day The petty-bourgeois democrats, such as our Socialist-Revolutionaries and Mensheviks, and also their blood ocT 18 The police protect the bosses party brothers, all the social-chauvinists and opportunists of Western Europe, expect just this "more" from universal suffrage. They themselves share and instil into the minds of the people the false idea that universal suffrage "in the present-day state" is really capable of ascertaining the will of the majority of the working people and of securing its realisation.
Here we can only take note of this false idea, only point out that Engels' perfectly clear, precise and concrete statement is distorted at every step in the propaganda and agitation of the "official" (i.e., opportunist) socialist parties. A detailed exposure of the utter falsity of this idea which Engels brushes aside here is given in our further account of the views of Marx and Engels on the "present-day" state.
taking into account the long experience German Social-Democracy, is 'the gauge of the maturity of the working class. It cannot and never will be anything more in the present-day Engels gives a general summary of his views in the most widely read of his works in the following words:
"The state, then, has not existed from all eternity. There have been societies that did without it, that had no idea of the state and state power. At a certain stage of economic development, which was necessarily bound up with the split of society into classes, the state became a necessity owing to this split. We are now rapidly approaching a stage in the development of production at which the existence of these classes not only will have ceased to be a necessity, but will become a positive hindrance to production. They will tall as inevitably as they arose at an earler stage. Along with them the state will inevitably fall. Society, which will reorganise production on the basis of a free and equal association of the producers, will put the whole machinery of state where it will then belong: into the museum of antiquities, by the side of the spinning-wheel and the bronze axe."
We do not often come across this passage in the propaganda and agitational literature of present-day Social-Democracy. But even when we do come across it, it is mostly quoted in the same manner as one bows before an icon, 1.e., It is done to show official respect for Engels, and no attempt is made to gauge the breadth and depth of the revolution that this relegating of "the whole state machine to the museum of antiquities" presupposes. In most cases we do not even find an understanding of what Engels calls the state machine.
4. THE WITHERING AWAY OF THE STATE AND VIOLENT REVOLUTION Eare so wildly known the yare 'ngels words regarding the are so widely known, they are so often quoted, and so clearly reveal the essence of the customary counterfeiting of Marxism into opportunism that we must deal
----- pull-quotes -----
depth of economic decision-making at
fascist Italy, Spain or Portugal."
"The bloody failure in Afghanistan was
and then brought down the Stalinist system."
and Lenin on parliamentary democracy under capitalism Engels and Lenin on parliamentary democracy under capitalism "Wealth has power indirectly,
KELLY MONTEITH 1Z Z
"Universal suffrage, he says, obviously
CONSERV col