Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Shoot the messengel

Socialist Organiser no. 521, 23 April 1992 · scan p. 6 · about 1,125 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

le morning atter "Labour would at least have addressed the issues that neighbourhood office told the past decade.

priority and I would be very would at least have A regular reader of this coording to at least one column, the election result has proved me wrong, wrong, wrong about the tabloids: their crude, unrelenting anti-Labour propaganda does have a real effect, after all.

And in this election it was decisive. Neil Kinnock said so, the Sun boasted of it, and many Labour activists believe they experienced it on the knocker. Call Lord McAlpine to the witness stand:

"The heroes of this campaign were Sir David English, Sir Nicholas Lloyd, Kelvin Mackenzie and the other editors of the popular Tory press. Never in the past nine elections have they come out so strongly in favour of the Conservatives. Never has their attack on the Labour Party been so comprehensive. They exposed, ridiculed and By Antonella Mancini awoke on Friday morning, 10 April, and heard my sisSter, who lives in the flat below me, cry out, "Oh no, not the Conservatives!"

I knew then that Labour had lost. I didn't want to get out of bed but had no choice. My 10 month old son, oblivihumiliated that party, doing each day in their pages the job that the politicians failed to do from their bright new platforms." (Sunday Telegraph, 12 April).

Coming from the former Treasurer of the Tory Party, this testimony certainly carries weight: no wonder Neil Kinnock made bitter response to it in his resignation statement.

Then there is the Basildon Factor (aka the Essex Man effect): we are reliably informed that half the electors of Basildon read the Sun. Simon Hoggart of the Observer got his pocket calculator out and concluded that it took just one in 18 Sun readers to switch their vote as a result of believing their paper, to give the Tories victory in that key C2 marginal.

The evidence seems overwhelming: so why am I so resistant to the idea that the Sun, Express, Mail and Star are Wot Won It for the Tories? First of all, there is a considerable body of evidence, accumulated over many years, to show that tabloid readers have a healthy disregard and distrust of their papers' bias.

Secondly, the chief witnesses - Kinnock and McAlpine - both have their own reasons for wanting to boost the importance of the tabloids: Kinnock because he was the victim of a particularly nasty ous to the past few weeks of the election campaign, cried out to be ted. For him it was just another day, For the first time since his birth I felt a great feeling of remorse - what kind of a world had I brought him into? I wanted to apologise to him.

As a single parent and a student, I have felt the effects of the Tory decade of cuts. Having to live on an absolute pittance, I find each day a balancing act between whether I can afford a few pounds for the electricity budget key or a bus ride to college, which, thanks to privatisation, now involves two bus journeys instead of one, and therefore extra costs.

I have exams in two months' time and have to juggle my work-load around my son's hours. I would love to be able to afford to send him to a nursery for a couple of hours each week, but instead have to rely on the goodwill of friends. His name is on a waiting list for a coun cil-run nursery, but my local personalised campaign and McAlpine because he's an unreconstructed Thatcherite who wants to downgrade the Major team who ran the official Tory campaign.

But, crucially, the "blame the tabloids" (or "credit the tabloids" , if you're Lord McAlpine) explanation is a profoundly pessimistic conclusion for anyone who believes that the working class can change society: are the 10 million people who buy the Tory tabloids all gullible fools? Or even one in 18 of them? What price a "socialism" that takes so dim a view of the raw material it has to work with?

I have my own expert witnesses. Here is Tony Benn in Monday's Guardian: "It is no use blaming the media, the pollsters or the image-makers, for they are all responding, in their own way, to the clear and accurate perception that Labour had consciously decided to limit its appeal to those who wished to see the political, economic and social status quo better managed, but not fundamentally altered. In other words, don't shoot the messenger."

Of course, resisting the argument that the tabloids won it for the Tories is not to deny that the British press is overwhelmingly pro-Tory and that their bias was on display for all to see throughout the election campaign. should matter - like education"

me that extreme cases get luckv to get a place at all.

This is all small fry compared to those people who have lost their jobs, their homes, their will to fight.

I am fortunate to have a roof over my head and a good support network of friends, but I do despair of the future; the state of schooling, my job prospects after university - my degree subjects, sociology and anthropology have come under a lot of attack during Tony Benn And yet it seems that the Tories now regard the grotesquely biased press as the norm by which the broadcast media should be judged - and have, therefore, concluded that the BBC is a repository of pro-Labour propaganda.

On the Sunday before polling day the Sunday Times reported unnamed Tories fulminating against the BBC: "Just wait and see what they'll bloody get when we are re-elected" , said one "leading figure".

No matter that the BBC cancelled the Panorama programme and systematically played down the polls in the run-up to the election; no matter that John Birt has spent the last five years attempting to appease the Tories by imposing a "neutrality" on television and radio news and current affairs that has made most of it pathetically bland: the Tories are out for blood. And, unlike Neil Kinnock, they have the bullets I to shoot the messenger.

A Labour government addressed some of the issues that should just be a matter of course in a decent society.

After the initial post-election blues I now feel, not dejection, but a great desire to do something - I'm not quite sure how or what I can possibly do. But certainly I hope that by the time my son starts full-time schooling people wake up to what Conservatism means for most of us and have the sense to boot the Tories out.

----- pull-quotes -----

PRESIS GANG

WOMEN'S EYE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 521

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →