The brains behind the stitch-u Secretary, John
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Even before the 1987 General Election, Edmonds was busy constructing an alliance of right-wing general secretaries (notably Bill Jordan of the AEU and Eric Hammond of the EETPU) to oust Kinnock and replace him with John Smith. Edmonds' plan was scuppered by Ron Todd of the TGWU, who stayed loyal to Kinnock (he is a T&G member, after all and by Smith himself, who had a badly timed heart attack. "Brains" Edmonds was forced to abort his coup and stick with Kinnock for But this year's election was Kinnock's last chance, as far as the towering intellect of the trade union movement was concerned. Even before the election was called, Edmonds began reassembling his "Smith for leader" alliance and let it be known that in the event of a Labour defeat, the GIB-sponsored Smith would make his bid, even if it meant standing against Kinnock.
Laird and Jordan naturally agreed, but the TGWU remained a problem. Edmonds' sweetener for Bill Morris was the proposal that Margaret Beckett, a T&Gsponsored MP, should be Smith's running-mate as depuMorris denies that he made any deal: *The TWU doesn't do deals like that under my leadership — and if I was doing a deal I should want the bigger half in any case". This may or may not be the case, but the facts are that Beckett was persuaded to stay in the race by pressure from Morris and the entire trade union hierarchy is now lined up behind the Smith-Beckett ticket.
The great irony of all this is that Edmonds, together with Jordan and Laird, has been to the fore in moves to dismantle the union block vote within the Labour Party and to replace the electoral college with one-person-onevote. Yet, in their haste to install Smith, they claim that they cannot even ballot their members because it would Not that most union members would be very excited by a ballot on the Labour leadership: Smith the machine man versus Gould who clearly wants a deal with the Liberals and Livingstone backed by the Sun and opposed even to Smith's modest redistributionist tax proposals.
going to disappear - just become less open and less One piece of relatively good news in these depressing with its workforce was carried by a wafer-thin majority of 168 (out of a total workforce of 26,000)
That was despite the backing of all the shop-floor unions, including "left-wing" TGWU officials. introduced gradually and by stealthy into the existing British motor industry. The Rover deal is the first example of a wholesale "package" being presented "take it or leave it" proposal to the workforce.
The sweeteners for accepting the scrapping of all demarcations and the introduction of "production teams" (otherwise known as "quality circles") are sing status with white-collar employees, "jobs for life" for existing employees, and the end of clocking:
The strength of the opposition to the des despite ahe GMB's General Edmonds, likes being known as the "brains" INSIDETHE of the trade union movement. URMONS And he has never made much cecret of the fact that BAUCER OCUICE VA SAT AOVE SE he regards Neil Kinnock as an intellectual lightweight whose only saving grace was By Sleeper his vigour in purging the Labour Party of undesirable left-wingers. the duration. ty leader. cost too much money. democratic.
ballot.
Up until now, " work methods have been unanimous union backing — has force management to issue a statement stres "proceed slowly". In other words, the continues despite its lack of leadersh moment.
We must organise. We must begin to fight back! Yes, you may say, but what can we do?
What we can do is to organise a national convention of the class struggle labour movement, Labour Party rank and file, Trade Unions, Trades Councils, minority groups, to coordinate the fight back against the Tories and, immediately, against the new Tory offensive. The official labour movement will not do this; no existing left wing entity is within a respectable distance of being able to do it. The convention of the left, which could discuss what to do and begin to create unofficial networks, could begin to do this work.
Such a thing would not counterpose itself to the existing official movements, Labour Party or Trade Union; on the contrary, one of its central jobs would be to Faster, it seems, is this mime, not Christmas.
In pantomime, you will recall, everything is turned upside down and inside out. The "principal boy" is a woman, the Dame a man.
Events are larger than life, and sometimes an arch comment on life. Characters are stereotyped, wear colourful costumes, and have funny names. Animals, and sometime inanimate objects, talk. Actors wink at the audience, mug for them, and talk to them out of the sides of their mouths. The audience, which is assumed to be childlike and innocent, is expected to respond on cue with hisses and boos and choruses of "yes" or "no""
• Where else but in a ridiculous political pantomime would the arch-Tory Sun throw its support behind the "left-wing" candidate for leader of the Labour Party?
This character has a trick moustache and a whining — obviously false — South London voice. (Privately, no doubt, he speaks with an Eton baritone). He is known variously as Red Ken, Red Leicester, Cheesy Red, the future Lord job Redken, or just scumbag Where else b midi the labour movement, rarely now feel.
There have been a number of such gatherings in the history of our movement, and at crucial turning points in its history. The famous Leeds convention of July 1917 comes to mind, but there are others.
But who could call such a gathering, Comrade Benn? Not us in the Allance tor Workers' Liberty — we lack sufficient numbers and we lack the necessary authority. Not any of the existing revolutionary' groups, for similar reasons, and for other reasons too, not least, the narrow-minded sectarianism which dominates most of them. Not any of the middle class 'socialist' groups, You, Comrade Benn, could do it! Together with the Campaign Group of MPs and labour movement bodies like - perhaps - the Labour's Establishment has stitched up this election.
They are holding it in an indecent rush, to forestall Labour Party and trade union discussion of their failure in the General Election.
After Tony Benn challenged Kinnock for the leadership in 1988, the Party leaders imposed a rule that to stand a candidate must first have the backing of 20% of Labour MPs, or 55 MPs.
Yet the left needs to contest the election and challenge the Establishment, whatever the dif ficulties.
Tony Benn is both the best and the obvious candidate. He could probably - given reasonable time - have got over the "55 MPs" barrier. He has been the standard-bearer of the Labour left for the last two decades. He is a man of political integrity. It is possible to respect him while disagreeing with him (as SO does on many issues), and he is widely respected.
No other left-wing candidate would be likely to do as well as Benn.
The task for all those who want to see the left throw off its paralysis is to organise for Benn, that is, to organise enough grass-roots support to persuade Benn to stand. The timetable laid down by Labour's Establishment is brutally short; bat that, as we argued in last week's SO, m Need to do 100 1 5 Situation Dound ed Leicester Livingstone and grimacing for the media, proI the left canur leader, playas he did when he cardboand not really a can not got and apport of them could build singlehandedly.
In 1980, the Rank and File Mobilising Committee for Labour Democracy did what the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy was doing but - with the central participation of the CLPD -did it on a vastly greater scale. You will recall, Comrade Benn, that, for a period of about a year, we succeeded in creating comprehensive unity of all the forces of the British left, unity greater than anything which has existed in many decades.
That is what we should try to do again now. We can do it! The cry: *Stop the Retreat!' backed up by an organising drive - that is now what the labour movement needs. It is what the left, scattered, divided and in many respects simply demoralised, needs.
No-one else, Comrade 55 MPs (unless one of the Establishment candidates sees a Establishment candidates sees tactical advantage in having Livingstone in the contest).
His is a pseudo-candidacy, all wind and publicity - in fact, come to think of it, all you would expect a Sun candidate to be.
He uses Sun tactics, too. He told a well-attended meeting of the London Labour Left last Wednesday, 15th - lyingly, I believe - that Benn had seriously urged him to stand. His friends in the audience attacked Jeremy Corbyn, a possi ble left-wing candidate and one with better claim to the "left" colours than Livingstone could have. At the end of the meeting, after the chair's summing-up, Livingstone's manipulating sycophant John Ross was allowed to push through a snap vote for the meeting to endorse Livingstone.
Instead of helping to prepare the way for a serious candidacy, Ken Livingstone and his friends rushed to occupy the space a serious candidate would need, and settled in to enjoy the publicity of a pseudo-campaign. The effect of the Livingstone nonsense is to diminish the chances of a serious left candidate standing.
And what is this leftwinger's political platHe criticises Labour's election campaign for its tax proposals! He is the Sun candidate here, 100Labour's leaders were ineffec eve in combatting the Tory campaign that Labour would bring tax rises, but that was not because of the detail of the Shadow Budget, which, according to the Institute of Fiscal Studies, would have left those on between 400 and £499 a week a bit better off on average, and seriously hit only those on more than £1000 a week.
Livingstone's line — *you should not have threatened to pointless to them: they need a lead from the labour movement; the labour movement needs them. A regenerated labour movement would be able to draw them around itself.
You are, Comrade Benn, and you have been since the 270s, the single most influential figure on the British lett. The responsibility as well as the opportunity to take this initiative is yours.
We urge you, Comrade Benn, to help us set up an organising committee to build a rank and file convention sometime in the early autumn.
Now is the time to stop the retreat!
John O'Mahony for After he had sold the London left down the river as leader of the GLC, Ken Livingstone posed for the press in a cardboard crown and sceptre raise the taxes of the rich" -as the platform of the left wing candidate is as daft as anything you could see in one of last Christmas's pantomimes.
All Livingstone is doing is recycling Tory propaganda. In fact he is just recycling the rubbish the Sun churned out during the election campaign!
In the early 1980s, when he led the Greater London Council, Livingstone relied entirely on a high tax-rate to keep him out of trouble and as an alternative response to Tory cuts, as against that advocated by the serious left: fight the Tories!
Livingstone will not be a candidate. And no real Left can develop around this Murdochsponsored pantomime campaign of the future Lord Redken, Sun columnist and Sun candidate on a Sun platform for leader of the The Left needs Livingstone like it needs the Sun, or like we need the proverbial hole in the head.
More on Ken Livingstone's candidacy: page 12
Scan page 5
Organiser
----- pull-quotes -----
Still, it goes to show that Labour remains the party of the trade unions, and the trade union connection is not
HE ROLITICALI FRONT