Have Wor but Yu Wont Win the War
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
from the a the need 1 and begir ravages t have infli ment. TE tacks now freshly, f reality of condition have poli Faced workers make th capitalisn the fount gle, perience capitalist The tri movemer organisin Beyond 1 Left is Sectarian they thin suppressi whom tr middle-c who havi to Scotti stunts, a tonal rel the wor iftermath of the miners' defeat to start from where we are 1 step by step to repair the hat 13 years of Tory rule icted on the labour movele new wave of Tory atN. getting under way poses or millions of workers, the the class struggle - and in is in which our enemies tical power. with those attacks, many will be forced to begin to leir own evaluation of n and thus to drink from ain of socialist knowledge. eople need a lead in strughelp in drawing the true conclusions from the exof conflict with the archTory Government. agedy of the British labour at now is that there is no ig centre for such activities. the official movement, the fragmented and divided. is who are so confused that ik they gain ground when i right wing succeeds in ing those on Labour's left le sectarians see as rivals; lass cliques and coteries e lost their bottle and look ish Nationalists, sectarian nd panaceas like "proporpresentation" instead of to king class and its movebattle. but vou won't win the war". This message, in 1985, is still valid today. ment; the ex Communist Party and a whole spectrum of erstwhile socialists and Marxists who were on the right of Neil Kinnock in the election, because they advocated votes for the Liberal Democrats — that is the "left' now.
There is no centre to the existing left, no group or organisation big and representative enough to give direction and purpose to a fight back. If such a centre existed now, much could be done that now seems impossible.
İt is not merely objective conditions, such as the economic slump, that paralyse us. In the past such conditions have not entirely paralysed socialist activity. It was in 1922, during the depths of the depression immediately after World War 1, that the foundations were laid for the great left-wing rank-and-file movement in the trade unions - the so-called "Minority Movement" - which won the affiliation of one quarter of all organised trade unionists in the early and middle 1920s.
It was the Communist Party -the real Communist Party and not the Stalinist entity which has now evolved beyond the right wing of the Labour Party - which made that possible. Such things would be Jonn marris.
possible now, as would such crying necessities as a unionisation drive in the 'New Technology' industries, if there were an alternative lett wing centre able to do the job despite the wretched character of the official labour movement, Labour Party and trade unions alike.
Why the left is now in such a state is beyond the scope of this letter, as is the 'crisis of socialism' of which it Turn to page 4 The mancipa int alu e lal chuan 158 also HId MARDUMiS ückoyi oyasex orrads Karl Marx PO BoyPęBT kondon SEL5 4NA Vewsdesk: 071-639 7965 Lakest date fortreporte y ondayı Editor: John O' Mahony Published by: WL Publications Ltd, PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge Registered as a newspaper at the Postdicel Arjy ep tame negessard rafsene and are im d versunal capacity?
Scan page 4
John Edmonds had been plotting for Smith nce before the 1987 Organiser election. Photo: Stefano Cagnoni. From page 3 page is part. The question is what are we to do? We put it to you, Comrade Benn, that socialists should not resign themselves passively to just doing nothing for 5 years as the Tory juggernaut rumbles through the Welfare State once more looking for things to flatten. We must not let the Tories continue to fight their enemies one by one, front by front. begin organising the rank and file to fight within the Labour Party and the various trade unions.
The different trade union branches, stewards' committees, trade union district committees and so on could be brought together, would begin to create the feel and texture of a movement, and then begin to generate that confidence the divided and atomised sections of the labour movement, deserted by the official structures of Yorkshire NUM and others which would be likely to respond to your initiative, you, Comrade Benn, could act as the catalyst to bring such a movement together.
In the first place, it would be a matter of bringing together an organising committee to build for the convention. Such a committee would try to coordinate the efforts of the existing left wing groups, building something bigger and more representative than any of Benn, but yourself and those you can influence, could hope to initiate this work on the scale that is required. For ourselves, we would, of course, put our resources into such work. So would many others on the left.
There are millions of British workers - many of whom did not vote on April 9 either because the struggle against the Poll Tax cost them their vote or because Kinnock's mimicry of the Tories made voting seem