[* CENTRAL CORDERS LOTHIAN AND On 9 April…]
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
* CENTRAL CORDERS LOTHIAN AND On 9 April the Scottish National Party failed to win seats, but did gain votes. Now we face another five years of a Tory government refusi the Scottish home rule demanded by a big and stable majority in Scotland. How should socialists respond? Jim Kearns discusses the In the face of it, the lines of clearly drawn. The Tories defend the Union and offer no change to the present constitutional arrangement. The Labour Party and the Liberal Democrats promise a Scottish Parliament, with tax raising powers, in line with the proposals of the Constitutional Convention.
The Scottish National Party (SP) stands for full political independence within the EC.
Although the national question has had a long and chequered history in Scottish politics, this is unprecedented. In one recent poll, 50 per cent preferred independence in Europe and a further 26 per cent supported a devolved Scottish Consistently, over the last three years, over ou per cent of the Scottish people have supported some form of constitutional change.
This represents a sea-change in attitude, particularly among the working class.
The thirteen years of Tory rule have taken their toll on the lives of working class people in Scotland, as they have on the working class in the rest of Britain. The traditional industries of shipbuilding, coal, car-making and steel have been decimated. Whole areas have been devastated by consistent unemployment levels of 20 per cent and above.
The introduction of the Poll Tax in April 1988, one year Salr earlier than in England and Wales, reinforced working class discontent. The economic upturn of the mid-1980s largely by-passed Scotland.
There has been some development of new technology and service sector industries, but they have brought few jobs.
This picture of economic decline is not peculiar to Scotland. It has been replicated in Tyneside, Liverpool, etc. What is peculiar has been the effect on the political consciousness of a very large majority of the Scottish working The rise of nationalism is the end product of a process of accumulation over a decade longne Tory vote in Scotland has remained at around 20-25 per cent since 1979. The general view of the Tories as an Englishbased party inflicting devastation on Scotland has generated a political crisis of popular representation.
There has been a lot of flatulence talked about what constitutes Scotland as a nation, oppressed or otherwise. However, the overwhelming majority of Scottish people regard Scotland as a nation. They genuinely see themselves as politically disenfranchised.
Whether this represents a form of national oppression is largely irrelevant: it is a fact to be reckoned with.
Somedly sure bind ince the mid-1980s the completely swung behind the demand for a Scottish Assembly. The reasons for this have been varied, some less "honourable" than others, but one has been the dissatisfaction of a large section of the Scottish labour bureaucracy at being denied any real political power. The Labour Party has consistently won a large majority of seats in Scotland, only to be denied power at Westminster.
And the Labour leadership has been forced to respond to the groundswell of nationalist feeling.
proposal, formulated within the cross-class Constitutional Convention, is for a Scottish Assembly with tax-raising powers and control over the separate Scottish educational and legal systems.
What was once a powerful left in the Scottish Labour Party, organised in the LCC, has now disintegrated, sharing consensus with the right on the Scottish Assembly but with more emphasis on women's representation in the new Parliament.
A section of the old LCC formed Scottish Labour Action (SLA). SLA was to the left of LCC in their initial response to the Anti-Poll Tax campaign; but what most distinguishes them now is a more nationalist bent in political thinking and orientation.
The old anti-devolutionist current in the Scottish Labour ANTI DAI DuN Militant RA ARIAN WE BEATE + 00) * LEA POLL TA The introduction of the poll tax working-class discontent Party, which had been quite powerful, has now completely disappeared.
This overall picture has been replicated in the Scottish trade union movement.
Even Militant, not known for their political sensitivity, have undertaken a "Scottish turn" Scottish 1 Militant Labours demands include an elected Scottish Assembly with the peculiar proviso that it should have the power to nationalise "The leadership Scottish labour movement must hefty part of the responsibility for resurgence of nationalism. Its craven capitulation to the Tories for over a decade has led directly to a situation in which the SNP is now a serious contender in Scottish working-class the economy. They also call for Scotland to be made "ungovernable" if the Assembly is not granted.
Within the SNP there has been marked change over the last decade. The old "Tartan Tory" party of Donald Stewart is a thing of the past. On paper the SNP is by far the most radical of Scotland one year the major parties, well to the left of the Scottish Labour Party on a whole number of issues, including Ravenscraig, the Poll Tax and disarmament.
The SNP has targeted the working-class communities that are the basis of Labour's support. Their two-pronged strategy of independence in Europe and radical populism is proving increasingly attractive to working class youth, in particular.
low should Marxists national question in Scotland. Nationalism has reshaped Scottish politics. There is absolutely no point in ignoring its existence and hoping that it will go away. It won't.
The leadership of the Scottish labour movement must bear a hefty part of the responsibility for the resurgence of nationalism. Its craven capitulation to the Tories for over a decade, in local government, the miners' strike, Caterpillar, the Poll Tax, Ravenscraig, etc. has led directly to a situation in which the SNP is now a serious contender in Scottish working class politics. All this accepted, it is not sufficient merely "to expose the leadership", or say "we told you The Marxist response must be to advocate consistent democracy. What this means in practice is support tor some form of Scottish Parliament. The powers of that Parliament must be decided by Parliament itselt. It should be elected on the basis of proportional representation, preferably a variant of the Additional Member system.
The next Labour SHERIFF England and Wales reinforced Government should carry out its commitment to initiate the elections for a Scottish Parliament as a matter of priority. It should also hold a referendum on the national question, the options being independence, a Scottish Assembly or the status quo.
"or Marxists, class is central.
must argue for the maximum unity between Scottish and English workers.
The SP solution, stripped of its radical pretensions, is a reactionary nationalist pipedream of cross-class unity on the basis of oil revenues. It is Scottish capitalism in rohich they attempt to tie in the working class on the basis of hostility to the English. The first victim of an attempted restructuring of Scottish capitalism would be the Scottish working class itself.
With the ongoing integration of European capitalism, it is absolutely imperative that the British labour movement defends what unity it has, and attempts to forge new links across the whole of Europe. A victory for nationalism would seriously weaken the power of the Ibour movement both in Srtland and in the rest of Britain.
A Scottish Parliament may be merely the first stage in the nationalist logic towards independence. However, to oppose the democratic demand here and now for a Scottish Parliament would merely fuel nationalism. The future is fought out on the terrain of the class struggle, and Marxists must continually assess and reassess that terrain if we are to address ourselves to political reality.
Scan page 15
isel