Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The worst film of '92?

Socialist Organiser no. 520, 14 April 1992 · scan p. 13 · about 880 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Shining Through f it had wings and gobbled, "Shining Through" couldn't be more of a turkey. We're not even half-way through 1992, but "Shining Through" must be the bummer of the year.

Remember the name David Seltzer. He adapted and directed is quu, su les me vue lu hala tha nna ta blame. "Shining Through" could have made a good film. Set in America and Berlin during World War 2, the novel by Susan Isaacs had pace and wit, and an appealing heroine, Linda Voss. Linda, a half-Jewish working class girl, has a giant inferiority complex, but through her dangerous work spying for the OSS (forerunner of the CIA) in Berlin, she comes to feel she's as good as anybody else. She also finds love.

Though the novel was a bestseller, Seltzer junks most of it, and replaces it with his own rubbishy plot. Characters are randomly altered, events hanged, the plot made to depend of two far-fetched coincidences - reducing the story to ludicrousness.

The finale, where Linda and Ed, her OSS boss, escape from Mammany chauld ha a rancina ucrany savulu ve a lousig scene. But Seltzer, obviously reared on TV, drops the book's neat climax, and goes for a shoot-out. By this stage, you're ready to shoot him.

The character of Linda is utterly trashed. She has one bristling feminist moment early on, then it's downhill all the way. Seltzer must hate his star, Melanie Griffith. He presents her, in turn, as a whiner, a dimwit and a dishrag. She's not even con"Shining Through is joke, not a serious film. With Linda fleeing the Nazis in evening gown and stiletto heels, a mo apt title would be Bimbo in Berlin."

scious at the end!

Seltzer never lets Linda show the faintest trace of the brains and competence she has in the book. In Berlin, she's so slow on the uptake that she endangers everyone she meets. In scene after scene she's dopey, paralysed, the last person to catch on. The role is unplayable, so it's no surprise that Griffith is appalling. Not only does the camera not love her, it's actively seeking divorce.

The film is so bad it's almost funny. No-one looks happy to be in it. John Gielgud keeps waving Linda away in horror, and Michael Douglas, who plays Ed, looks strained whenever Linda is around What I can't grasp is the mensaling in Sezer plagueer Linda in the home of a nice, soulful Nazi instead of the grubby little bureaucrat she was supposed to spy on. Seltzer uses Nazi Germany (Nazi Germany) as a kind of neutral backdrop for Linda to emote in front of, and he doesn't seem to realise that he's doing it. It's all uncritical, valueless: the Nazi parades are just an excuse for dressing up.

In one of Seltzer's invented bits, Linda squeezes out a tear in the wrecked basement where captured Jewish relatives had hidden, and the scene has no weight to it, no emotional force at all. You can tell Seltzer's just shoved it in for a quick tug at the audience's feelings, but it's so cheap and hackneyed you feel turned off.

Most films about the Nazis present them as bad. In "Shining Through" the Nazi's chief sin seems to be that they scare Linda.

"Shining Through" is a joke, not a serious film. With Linda fleeing the Nazis in evening gown and stiletto heels, a more apt title would be "Bimbo in Berlin".

If little green men came to earth and made a film about a woman finding herself by fighting the Nazis, it might be like "Shining Through". You could excuse them; they don't know the history. What's Seltzer's excuse? subject only to possible reprisals at the next election.

And yet it cannot be long now before it is technically feasible to have a system of direct democracy in which the people, even of a country the size of Britain, could, so to speak, "assemble» through TV electronics, listen to arguments, and vote on each major issue as it arises.

That might be a better use for TV than the way it is used now! Endless chatter and speculation around selective "mock elections" (opinion polls) and their interpretation, investigatio and extrapolation, occupie a vast amount of TV time during the election campaign. The fact that they mostly got it all wrong emphasises how useless it all was, but it would still be a wasteland even if they had managed to predict accurately the real vote on 9 April.

What the chatter, and the chatter about chatter, does the "democratic process" I do not know; but there is something feverish and unreal about politics on TV as the "experts" chatter, something hysterical even.

One of the few refreshing things I saw on TV during the election was Sir Peregrine Worsthorne on Newsnight laying into the other pundits and accusing them of setting hares running just to be able to chasi after them. He pointed out that two months ago they said that Labour had no chance and now, because Labour had won only 40 extra seats, they go on that is "finished".

TV, which could provide the technical means to extend democracy, has become a means for smoth ering and numbing all real political debate.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 520

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →