Lenin on how the state is a machine of class rul Why the system is bi tim
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
ELA33 CONTRADICTIOIS works of Marx and Engels on That is now happening to possible, in order that the reader Marx's teaching has, in may form an independent opinthe course of history, ion of the totality of the views of happened repeatedly to the the founders of scientific socialteachings of revolutionary ism and of the development of thinkers and leaders of those views, and in order that oppressed classes struggling for their distortion by the now During the lifetime of great documentarily proved and clearrevolutionaries, the oppressing ly demonstrated. stant persecution, received their widely read of Engels' works, teachings with the most savage The Origin of the Family, malice, the most furious hatred Private Property and the State, and the most unscrupulous the sixth edition of which was campaigns of lies and slander. published in stuttgart as far After their death, attempts are back as 1894. We shall have to made to convert them into translate the quotations from Varx: the state is the product of irreconcilable class Labour's leaders see politics as a level playi field, giving equal chan to Labour and to the Tories. They assumed that, with the Tories making blunder after blunder, Labour would as long as they avoider blunders themselves.
But in truth the entire structure of politics is biased in favour of the chosen parties of the ruling class - in Britain, the Tories. The State is not neutral; it is a class state. Labour can win elections -let along change society only by campaigning "against the grain" of existing society.
Lenin explained the class nature of the state clearly and concisely in his pamphlet The State and Revolution. This is the first of a series of extracts.
A THE STATE ASIA PRODUCT OF THE ECONCILABILITYOF emancipation.
classes meted out to them concontradictions harmless icons, to canonise them, so to say, and to surround their names with a certain halo for the "consolation" of the oppressed classes and in order to dupe the latter, while at the same time emasculating the content of the revolutionary teaching, blunting its revolutionary edge and vulgarising it. At the present time, the bourgeoisie and the opportunists within the working-class movement concur in this "doctoring" of Marxism. They forget, obliterate and distort the revolutionary side of this teaching, its revolutionary soul. They push to the foreground and extol what is or seems acceptable to the bourgeoisie. All the social-chauvinists are now "Marxists" (don't laugh!). And more and more frequently, German bourgeois scholars, but yesterday specialists in the annihilation of Marxism, are speaking of the "hey are, Gerated the workho unions which are so splendidly organised for the purpose of conducting a predatory war!
In such circumstances, in view of the unprecedentedly widespread distortions of Marxism, our prime task is to re-establish what Marx really taught on the subject of the state. For this purpose it will be necessary to quote at length from the works of Marx and Engels themselves. Of course long quotations will render the text cumbersome and will not help to make it popular reading. but we cannot possibly do without them. All, or at any rate, all the decisive passages in the the subject of the state must without fail be quoted as fully as dominant "Kautskyism" may be Let us begin with the most the German original, as the Russian translations, although very numerous, are for the most part either incomplete or very unsatisfactory. Summing up his historical analysis, Engels says:
"The state is, therefore, by no means a power forced on society from without; just as little is it the reality of the ethical idea,' 'the image and reality of reason, as Hegel maintains. Rather, it is a product of society at a certain stage of development; it is the admission that this society has become entangled in an insoluble contradiction with itself, that it has split into irreconcilable opposites which it is powerless to conjure away. But in order that these opposites, classes with conflicting economic interests, might not consume themselves and society in fruitless struggle, it became necessary to have a power seemingly standing above society that would moderate the conflict and keep it within the bounds of 'order'; and this power, arisen out of society but placing itself above it, and alienating itself more and more from it, is the This expresses with perfect clarity the basic idea of Marxism concerning the historical role and the significance of the state. The state is a product and manifestation of the irreconcilability of class contradictions. The state arises where, when and to the extent that class contradictions objectively cannot be reconciled. and, conversely, the existence of the state proves that class contradictions are irreconcilable. It is precisely on this most important and fundamental point that the distortion of Marxism, proceeding along two main lines, begins.
On the one hand, bourgeois and particularly petty-bourgeois ideologists, compelled under the weight of indisputable historical facts to admit that the state only exists where there are class contradictions and the class struggle, "correct" Marx in such a way as to make it appear that the state is an organ for the reconciliation of classes. According to Marx, the state could neither arise nor maintain itself if it were possible to reconcile classes. According to the petty-bourgeois and philistine professors and publicists it appears that the state does reconcile classes (very frequently they benignly refer to Marx to prove this!). According to Marx, the state is an organ of class rule, an organ for the oppression of one class by another; it is the creation of "order,' which legalises and perpetuates this oppression by moderating the conflict between the classes. In the opinion of the petty-bourgeois politicians, order means precisely the reconciliation of classes, and not the oppression of one class by another; moderating the conflict means reconciling classes, and not depriving the oppressed classes of definite means and methods of struggle to overthrow the oppressors.
For instance, the Tories revolution of 1917, the question of the significance and the role of the state actually arose in all its magnitude as a practical question demanding immediate action and, what is more, action on a mass scale, all the Socialist-Revolutionaries and Mensheviks immediately and completely sank to the "According to Marx, the state is an organ of class rule, an organ for the oppression of one class by another; it is the creation of 'order' which legalises and perpetuates this oppression by moderating the conflict between classes."
etty-bourgeois theory that the "state" "reconciles" classes. Innumerable resolutions and articles by politicians of both these parties are thoroughly saturated with this petty-bourgeois and philistine "reconciliation" theory. That the state is an organ of the rule of a definite class which cannot be reconciled with its antipodes (the class opposite to it is something the petty-bourgeois democrats will never be able to understand. Their attitude towards the state is one of the most striking manifestations of the fact that our Socialist-Revolutionaries and Mensheviks are not socialists at all (a point we Bolsheviks have always maintained) but petty-bourgeois democrats with near-socialist phraseology.
On the other hand, the "Kautskyite" distortion of Marxism is far more subtle. "Theoretically," it is not denied that the state is an organ of class rule, or that class contradictions are irreconcilable. But what is lost sight of or glossed over is this: If the state is a product of the irreconcilability of class contradictions, if it is a power standing above society and "alienating itself more and more from it," then it is obvious that the liberation of the oppressed class is impossible not only without a violent revolution, but also without the destruction of the apparatus of state power which was created by the ruling class and which is the embodiment of this "alienation." As we shall see later, Marx very definitely drew this theoretically self-evident conclusion as a result of a concrete historical analysis of the tasks of the revolution. And - as we shall show in detail further on - it is precisely this conclusion which Kautsky has "forgotten" and distorted.
Scan page 11
first international organisation [advocates of "people's" as of mass working class parties]. opposed to workers Author of numerous works of revolution, with mass support Foundations of Christianity and Split under the impact of the The economic doctrines of Karl Russian revolution with a Despite his valuable work in the counter-revolution.
radical reformist notion of"war be led by the bourgeoisie. The revolution, and pointed to the defend working-class rights in a existing state as a vehicle for revolution that must not Kautsky opposed the Bolsheviks Only aftera lengthy period ol and pioneered a version of the suite for worker move re USSR. placed on the agenda. ETC.
"ngels continues: "In con-tradistinction to the old agentile (tribal or cian] organisation, the state, first, divides its subjects according to territory.
"Such a division seems "natural" to us, but it cost a prolonged struggle against the old organisation according to clans or tribes.
"The second distinguishing feature is the establishment of a public power which no longer directly coincides with the population organising itself as an armed force. This special public power is necessary because a self-acting armed organisation of the population has become impossible since the split into classes.... This public power exists in every state; it consists not merely of armed men but also of material adjuncts, prisons and institutions of coercion of all kinds, of which gentile [clan] society knew nothing."
Engels further elucidates the concept of the "power" which is termed the state, a power which arose from society, but places itself above it and alienates itself more and more from it. What does this power mainly consist in? It consists in special bodies of armed men which have prisons, etc., at their command.
We are justified in speaking of special bodies of armed men, because the public power which is an attribute of every state "no longer directly coincides" with the armed population, with its "self-acting armed organisation."
"Every revolution, by destroying the state apparatus, clearly demonstrates to us how the ruling class strives to restore the special bodies of armed men which servi it, and how the oppressed class strives to create a new organisation of this kind, capable of serving not the exploiters but the exploited."
Like all great revolutionary thinkers, Engels tries to draw the attention of the class-conscious workers precisely to that which the predominant philistinism regards as least worthy of attention, as most habitual and sanctified by prejudices that are not only firmly rooted but, one might say, petrified. A standing army and police are the chief instruments of force of the state LENIN power. But can things, indeed, be otherwise?
From the viewpoint of the vast majority of Europeans at the end of the nineteenth century whom Engels was addressing, and who had not lived through or observed at close quarters a single great revolution, things could not be otherwise. They completely failed to understand what a "self-acting armed organisation of the population" was. To the question of why there arose the need for special bodies of armed men, placing themselves above society and alienating themselves from it (police and standing army), the West European and Russian philistines are inclined to answer with a few phrases borrowed from Spencer or Mikhailovsky, by referring to the growing complexity of social life, the differentiation of functions, and so forth.
Such a reference seems "scientific," and splendidly lulls the man in the street to sleep by obscuring the most important and basic fact, namely, the split of society into irreconcilably antagonistic classes. *selface it armed higanisatihe of the population" would differ from the primitive organisation of a stick-wielding herd of monkeys, or of primitive man, or of men united in clans, by its complexity, its higher technique, and so forth; but such an organisation would still be possible.
It is impossible, because civilised society is split into antagonistic and, moreover, irreconcilably antagonistic classes, the "self-acting" arming of which would lead to an armed struggle between them. The state arises, a special power is created - special bodies of armed men; and every revolution, by destroying the state apparatus, clearly demonstrates to us how the ruling class strives to restore the special bodies of armed men which serve it, and how the oppressed class strives to create a new organisation of this kind, capable of serving not the exploiters but the exploited.
In the above argument, Engels raises theoretically the very same question which every great revolution raises before us in practice, palpably and, what is more, on a scale of mass action, namely, the question of the relation between "special" bodies of armed men and the "self-acting armed organisation of the population." We shall see how this question is concretely illustrated by the experience of the European and Russian revolutions. But let us return to Engels' exposition.
He points out that sometimes, for example, in certain parts of North America, this public power is weak (he has in mind a rare exception in capitalist society, and those parts of North America in its pre-imperialist period where the free colonist predominated), but that, generally speaking, it grows stronger:
"It [the public power] grows stronger, however, in proportion as class contradictions within the state become more acute, and as adjacent states become larger and more populous. We have only to look at our Glossary Kautskyism: Karl Kautsky was known as the "Pope of Marxism". He was the leading thinker in the Second International 1889-1914 [the Marxist theory including The Marx. He edited Marx's Theories of Surplus Value.
presenting and popularising Marx's ideas, Kautsky also helped introduce distortions into the theories he championed. He advocated a of attrition" rather than socialist transformation.
"state capitalist" analysis of the st present-day Europe, where class struggle and rivalry in conquest have tuned up the public power to such a pitch that it threatens to devour the whole of society and even the state."
This was written not later than the early nineties of the last century. Engels' last preface is dated June 16, 1891.
The turn towards imperialism - meaning the complete domination of the trusts, meaning the omnipotence of the big banks, meaning a grand-scale colonial policy, and so forth - was only just beginning in France, and was even weaker in North America and in Germany. Since then "rivalry in conquest" has made gigantic strides-especially as, by the beginning of the second decade of the twentieth century, the whole globe had been completely divided up among these "rivals in conquest, " i.e., among the great predatory powers.
Since then, military and naval armaments have grown incredibly and the predatory war of 1914-17 for the domination of the world by England or Germany, for the division of the spoils, has brought the "devouring" of all the forces of society by the rapacious state power close to complete catastrophe.
As early as 1891 Engels was able to point to "rivalry in conquest" as one of the most important distinguishing features of the foreign policy of the Great Powers, but in 1917, when this rivalry, many times intensified, has given rise to an imperialist war, the social-chauvinist scoundrels cover up the defence of the predatory interests of "their own" bourgeoisie with phrases about "defence of the fatherland," "defence of the republic and the revolution," etc.
Social Chauvinisma Label for thoselinithe workersi movemem nho nallied to thief own nurine Class duringithe saugniemor World WarOne.
Socialist Revolutionaries (SRs): Radical populists amongst the Russian peasantry.
section of the left going over to the Bolsheviks and the right to Mensheviks: Right wing of the Russian Socialist movement. They argued that the coming anti-Tsarist revolution was to role of the Marxists was to challenge capitalistiproperty.
Scan page 12
economy" of the working class" in Eastern Europe, workers who Terry Fields election campaign:
Struck and came on to the streets to For a long time now. the only ocialist Organi Tuberty is launching a he Alliance for Workers' he Alliance for Workers"
campaign to renew and spread the ideas of socialism.
The whole labour movement. desperately needs such a campaign.
Labour has been living off "inherited capital" for decades. The official labour movement has done nothing to argue for and educate people in the basic ideas of socialism.
For workers even to vote Labour - to vote for a labour-based alternative to parties backed by the ruling class and attuned to the capitalist system - they must be convinced in some way, to some extent, of a socialistic "political economy" of the working class" opposition to the profit-first - da chen munfit fioct political economy of capital.
There is nothing automatic or effortless about workers coming be convinced of that. Bread and butter rebellion against capitalist exploitation is built into the system, and it generates the germs of socialism; but much more is needed to create an effective socialist movement.
It took some 150 years of argument, education and struggle for the British working class to move from its first trade union battles to a majority working class. vote for even a pale-pink Labour Party. The American working class has not even made that step yet. In Eastern Europe, workers who struck and came on to the street overthrow their rulers are now supporting capitalist-oriented governments.
The ruling ideas are normally ideas of the ruling class. The people who own and control the factories, the offices and the media have hundreds of tricks and gambits to hook working class people to accepting the system.
Even today, in Britain, more people say they want "socialism" (however that is understood) than want capitalism. That body of support for the basic idea of changing society was built up over decades, through hundreds of pamphlets, newspapers, meetings, - what leaflets and arguments. leaflets and arguments.
For a long time now, the only people who have done anything to boost and expand that body of support - to maintain, update and spread the arguments for socialism - have been the far left, through newspapers like Socialist Organiser. Official Labour has been parasitic on what we have done; it relies on a body of support for socialism, but does not promote or arouse it.
The far left has been weak. A lot of the work done to spread socialist ideas has been compromised or discredited by the collapse of Stalinism in Eastern Europe, because the socialists doing that work had illusions, to one degree or another, in the "socialist" pretensions of the East European systems. The "inherited capital" of the labour movement is decaying.
EMEONITHE 'erry Fields' campaign in I consitency in the Caneral constituency in the General Election was based on the same mixture of political dishonesty meeting consisting of Militant supporters and members of the Socialist Workers Party.
So much for the political dishonesty. Now for the pelitical incoherence. And of that there was no shortage.
"We need Labour government. Everything is there to be won but each seat will count... We won this seat for Labour in 1983 and 1987. Let's keep it like that... We need unity to defeat the Tories", stated one of his leaflets.
But keeping Broadgreen a
----- pull-quotes -----
ased against Labour e tor
SRECIAL B SOF RMED MEN PRISONS.