The failures trade
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
throughout industry - the three day week - to save electricity.
Finally, Heath took the desperate gamble of calling an election under the slogan "Who rules Britain?" Labour won the election at a time of almost unprecedented class struggle, and solely on the backs of the miners and other groups of workers who had made Heath's continuing rule untenable.
At first, the new Labour administration (under Harold Wilson) was obliged to tread carefully. It immediately repealed the Industrial Relations Act and scrapped statutory wage restraint.
However, by the end of 1974 the Wilson government had produced the Social Contract -an incomes policy that would keep down wage settlements in exchange for a vague and illusory set of commitments to control prices, help the low-paid and pensioners, and introduce planning agreements with major companies.
Central to the "success" of the Social Contract was the support it received from the TUC. And central to TUC support was the backing of prestigious "left-wingers" like the Terrible Twins Hugh Scanlon of the AEUW and Jack Jones of the TGWU. The Social Contract succeeded (in the short-term) where "How could the rank and file militancy of the early '70s lead to four successive Tory general election victories? Because the labour movement never developed politics to match its economic militancy."
Heath had failed: in 1974 there were 14.8 million strike days. The following year it went down to 5.9 million and in 1976 it was 3.5 million.
Working-class living standards were attacked and the promises to the low-paid and pensioners were not fulfilled. Planning agreements were nothing short of a debacle: Chrysler simply broke its agreement with the government (after receiving generous hand-outs) by selling off all its British plants and the goverment stood by and let them get away with it: this was the reality of trying to control capitalism without challenging the foundations of capitalist How was it that the fantastic rank and file power of the early *70s - the militancy that had brought down Heath - could be dissipated into the deteats, demoralisation, and betrayal of the Wilson/Healey/Callaghan years of the Social Contract?
How could it lead to a Labour Government so miserable that it would be followed by four successive General Election victories for the Tories? Because the labour movement never developed politics to match its economic militancy. The problem still remains.
etween about 1971 and member International Socialists - the forerunner of today's SWP. In the late 1960s and early '70s IS had made a big "turn to the class" in an attempt to respond to the rising tide of class struggle by recruiting leading industrial militants. Arthur Harper was one of the jewels in the IS crown during this period: a former member of the CP, convenor of Leyland Tractors and Transmissions plant and a leading AEUW militant, Arthur was an important catch for IS.
Like many of the workers who took part in the great struggles of the early *70s, Arthur Harper's version of socialism was essentially based upon trade union "super-militancy": the appeal of IS to such people was that it supported militant action at shopfloor level more strongly than the CP and provided a vague perspective of achieving socialism (ultimately) via such means. It was, at bottom, a syndicalist approach summed up in Tony Cliff's description "do-it-yourself reformism".
A friend of Arthur Harper's remembers his negotiating technique: "Arthur would stride into the office, sit down at the table in front of the gaffers and read out the claim. The gaffers would then start bleating about how they couldn't possibly meet such extreme demands, the company's profits wouldn't allow it, he'd have to come up with something more realistic, and so forth. Then Arthur would simply turn his chair round and stare out the window, saying nothing. He'd just wait and wait until the gaffers broke down and started negotiating on his terms."
This is, of course, great stuf and we could use a lot more of it in these days of "responsible" "moderate" trade unionism. But for IS in the early "70s, such militant trade unionism was seen almost as an end in itself. Little effort was made to take worker militants beyond the limits of trade union consciousness and the idea of raising demands (like nationalisation under workers' control) upon the incoming Labour government of 1974. was simply sneered at by the IS leadership.
The major political force behind the militancy of the early 70s, the Communist Party, was even worse: like IS they glorified "pure" trade unionism and disdained to intervene in the Labour Party. Unlike IS, they were obsessed with gaining official positions within the unions and staying on good terms with "left" leaders like Jones and Scanlon.
Between them, the CP and the IS ensured that the best of the militants who had led the struggles against the Heath government, were left confused, disorientated and sidelined by the Wilson government. The CP couldn't even make up its mind to give full support to workers who fought the Social Contract (that would have meant making a break with Jones and Scanlon). The IS was at least clear on opposing the Social Contract and supporting all workers in struggle, but they had no answers to the new set of political problems posed by the Wilson government. "Pure" militancy was no longer enough - if, indeed, it ever had been.
Instead. Tony Clifi and the IS leadership embarked upon a grandiose scheme to transform the IS into the Socialist Workers Party, which would eventually displace Labour as the main political party of the British working class(!). This new turn involved a dramatic change in IS's approach to trade union work: instead of the Wilson government."
operating within the existing Broad Lefts, IS would strike out on its own under the banner of the National Rank and File Movement.
When, in 1975, the IS leadership decided to run a candidate against the Broad Left in the AUEW elections (after IS members had nominated the Broad Left candidate), it was the final straw for the majority of IS's industrial members. Arthur Harper was one of many who either resigned or were expelled over the AUEW affair. They attempted to form a new organisation, the Workers' League, but this soon collapsed. Most, like Arthur, remained active inside their unions and workplaces but their commitment to organised revolutionary politics was finished for ever.
IS let down a whole generation of militants like Arthur Harper - first by pandering to them and then by failing to provide a coherent political alternative to the Wilson government.
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser No. 520 page 10 LENIN
----- pull-quotes -----
"IS let down a whole generation of worker militants by failing to provide a coherent political alternative