Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

"Don't let the leaders gut the party'

Socialist Organiser no. 520, 14 April 1992 · scan p. 7 · about 1,719 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

We must fight for the NHS. Photo: Paul Hermann, Profile From page 5 Toryism from under whose feet the Thatcherite monetarist and free-market certainties have been blown The true measure of what Kinnock is, even in his own reformist terms, is found in the fact that he did not even dare to pick up and run with the banner of resurgent Keynesianism - the old basis of Labour's post-war politics, now undergoing a certain revival in bourgeois circles as the monetarists are discredited.

No: the labour movement has, because of the Kinnockites, missed a great opportunity to defeat the chosen party of big business and put into government the party still based on the trade unions, and that is a grievous failure: but it does not leave the labour movement positively worse off than we were before the Politically, the Tories have been forced into a degree of retreat. For sure, the National Health Service is not safe in Tory hands, but when John Major, after the election, emphatically pledged that the Tories would not scrap the NHS, he was not only repeating the old lying Tory denials of what they have already done; he was also registering, on behalf of post-Thatcher Ternation of mory NeS polic conIf Labour's leaders had any go in them, they would now begin to fight the next election by launching a great single-issue crusade for the National Health Service.

There now for the Labour left? Left-wing candidates like Jeremy Corbyn, Bernie Grant, and Dennis Skinner got exceptionally high swings in their favour.

They proved that where left-wing policies are advanced they can win the support the right-wing secondclass Toryism of Kinnock failed to win.

That is the proper lesson to be learned from Labour's defeat in the election. The dominant forces in the Labour Party will not learn that lesson; they will use the election defeat they have brought down on our heads to argue for more of the policies that brought defeat.

They will argue that Labour must complete its transformation into a continental-style *social democratic" party, exclude the trade unions from politics, commit Labour irrevocably to Owenite policies, and do everything to make itself into a replacement for the now-defunct SDP except adopt the name. (And who can be sure even about that, if they get their way?)

And what will the Labour left do? The broad Labour left has been crushed not only by the repressive regime that Kinnock and his friends have imposed on the party in recent years - with the banning of newspapers such as SO - but also by the great and paralysing wish in the ranks of Labour and the trade unions to get the Tories out at any cost, and not to question what Kinnock says and does if only it works. That mood has made honest rank-and-file members of the Labour Party, reluctantly and not without heart-searching, endorse or vote for the expulsions of socialists.

The election defeat will not necessarily put an end to that mood now, any more than it did in 1987. It may even intensify it.

Yet the resignation of Kinnock, and the offensive of the right wing to pull the party turther their way, must reopen the question settled in favour of Kinnockism in the mid180s. The central question is: what is the Labour Party? Where is it going?

Is it to cease being the party of the labour movement and become a mildly "left" depoliticised machine - perhaps financed by the state, as in so many European countries political parties are — for electing careerists to Parliament? Or will the party, in the wake of its fourth election defeat, take stock of itself?

The entire logic of recent Labour Party history suggests that it will continue down the last bitter stretch of the road on which the renegade socialist Kinnock has led it.

Many Labour Party leaders -not only the Right, but also a section of the "left" who have lost confidence in the working class and in Labour as a working-class party - will argue that Labour should make its central concern between now and the next election a campaign for Proportional Representation, coupled with a commitment to coalition which will bind any future "Labour" government to what its Liberal coalition partners will accept.

Yet they may not prevail. The left may be able to ensure that they do not. We may be able to prevent the tremendous historic defeat for working-class politics that such a transformation and destruction of the old Labour Party would represent.

There is an important parallel here. When in October 1959 Labour lost its third General Election in a row, the Party leaders round Hugh Gaitskell decided to make Labour a continental-style social-democratic party. They immediately launched a vestige of so sm. i looked ill all nothing could stop them.

Then, slowly, the rank and file of the party and the trade unions, even trade union leaders, asserted themselves against Gaitskell. They refused to let the leaders gut the party.

That can happen again, despite the different situation the labour movement finds itself in. It can be made to happen.

Now is the time for the left to reopen the whole series of questions closed in the Labour Party for the last five or six years. Tony Benn should stand for the leadership and use the leadership contest to take the campaign into the unions.

There are technical difficulties — Benn would need the backing of 55 Labour MPs to stand - but they are not insurmountable. The Left in the Party should start now to argue that we must challenge John Smith, or whomever else the right wing chooses as Party leader. A now 1 10 0gt as an ac nd the hard left? The doleft now is to accept as an accomplished fact the complete loss ~IT_ THE 76RY of the Labour Party and the elimination of mass trade-unionbased - albeit reformist -working-class politics in Britain.

Every serious socialist for many decades has argued for transcending and superseding the old mass working-class politics, replacing the structures created by the trade unions at the beginning of this century with a reorganised labour movement that would consistently and comprehensively pursue the class struggles of the working class and aim, by way of taking state power, at the complete elimination of the bourgeoisie. Only then, we argued with tragic accuracy, could the gains of the reformist working class movement be made secure.

The transformation of the Labour Party now aimed at by some of its leaders is a transformation entirely in an opposite direction. That would be an unmitigated defeat for the working class, a tremendous historical setback.

The "revolutionary" socialists who can contemplate that with either pleasure or resigned acceptance are hopeless sectarians, people unable to relate to or deal with the working class and the labour movement as they really are. The "revolutionary" triumphalism "we told you so" - with which a sect like the SWP contemplates what is happening to the Labour Party conceals a paralysing defeatism. Their refusal to do anything more in the election than mouth "vote Labour" - for catchpenny opportunist reasons of not offending people - is based on the same defeatism.

For more than a decade, SO has repeatedly had to tell these people that their real political ancestors -whatever about their claims to be "Trotskyists" - are the ultra-left Shose sopere. HivetuComay: whose refusal to taint themselves with any connection with the Social Democrats (counter-revolutionaries" as indeed they were) implied, as Trotsky told them, giving up on the struggle to stop Hitler, and accepting in advance the inevitability of Nazi victory over the German workers.

For the entire period of Thatcherite rule, the "anti-Labour" socialists have masked a passive acceptance that nothing could be done against the Tories with superrevolutionary (and, of course, true) self-righteous denunciations of the iniquities of the Callaghan-FootKinnock Labour Party.

Serious Marxists do not give up on the working class or on its mass political movement like that. Serious socialists do not tell workers that nothing can be done with the existing labour movement. They tell them to struggle within their own organisations. Those who say "I give up" may build sects; they will not help the working class to emancipate itself from capitalist ideas or reformist leaders and organisations.

The lesson for the sectarian left, even at this late hour, is: do not abandon the mass labour movement to those who will now try to carry out the will of the ruling class and complete the transformation of the Labour Party! Join the Labour Party! Those who do not share the hardboiled sectarianism of the SWP, but have let themselves be driven out of the Labour Party in disgust over the last period (and many of them turned out to canvass for Labour in the election) should come back into the fight now.

or ourselves, we in the Alliance for Workers' Liberty will continue to advocate these ideas in the trade unions and in the Labour Party:

There is another central lesson to be drawn from the condition the labour movement finds itself in now: the need for socialist education and propaganda.

People do not become socialists automatically, faced as they are with the power of the bourgeoisie and their Tory Party, and living in a world dominated by institutions and economic processes that constitute an intense and persistent form of "propaganda" for acceptance of this capitalist society as the normal and only possible society. They need help. General socialist education in the labour movement is at its lowest ebb in decades. We need to integrate activity in the labour movement to promote the immediate interests of the working class with long-term explanation of what socialism is.

The collapse of Stalinism, the vacating of the field by many of those who have misrepresented socialism for so long, has cleared the way for a resurgence of the real socialism of Karl Marx, Frederick Engels, Rosa Luxemburg, Lenin, and Leon Trotsky.

The Alliance for Workers* Liberty exists to take that socialism into the working class movement and fight for it there.

----- pull-quotes -----

Haveriheart Support your NHS

"If Labour's leaders had any go in them, they would now launch a crusade for the NHS.

FIGHT GRADING NU OFFI

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 520

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →