[Celebrations in the City. Labour had no alternative…]
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Celebrations in the City. Labour had no alternative capture the imagination of our side alling into liberal ideas According to Kenneth Baker, proportional representation would only help the fascists.
David Morris, the Conservative ex-MP for Birmingham Yardley, seems to have a different view on the subject.
Early on Friday morning the Right Hon member found his 2,500 majority converted into a Labour majority of 162.
Who was to blame? Morris left the local press in no doubt where he was pointing his finger - at the National Front, who scrape together 192 votes.
All natural Conservative voters, whined the ex-MP..
Taylor Someone else who lot about "natural Conservative voters" is John Taylor, the black Tory candidate for Cheltenham.
But the Liberal Democrats were laughing all the way the polling stations.
The Liberals already have a record of racisn in Tower Hamlets, and their candidate in Cheltenham, Nigel Jones, described himself as "the local man". '. No-one was in very much doubt what he meant.
At least David Alton (who was not allowed on the TV by Liberal Central Office) will have some company the pariah section of the backbenches.
Donald's have be ha little softer on the British establishment. Last week their outlets were giving away a free copy of the Daily Mail with every McBreakfast.
Research suggess that 7% of "don't knows" who read the Mail are persuade to vote Conservative. Is th worth a seat in the Lords for Ronald McDonald? deep blue sa he Devil or the which would you choose?
The Devil is played by the SWP, doing a very passable impression of anarchism. Publicity te their "Marxism '92" features a picture of Big Ben crumbling, or rather exploding.
Have the SWP
planted a bomb there? Has their "Labour or Tories - it makes no difference" spiel turne their minds and led them to throw out the whole of bourgeois democracy?
There are certainly no hints of workers" power in the publicity, no alternatives to Westminster. It is just pictorial form of the o anarchist slogan "Smash the state"
The great blue sea played by socialist. "Vote to break the British state" , Is pre-election front page proclaimed. Exactly where you have to put your cross to do this is a topic for after-dinner conversation. C mouldering in his gerry Healy lies agrave, but his "dialectics" go marching Ken Livingstone MP startled voters in Brent East by telling them that the candidacy of the "Leninist" group in his constituency was "an MI5 plot"
If so, Britain's secret state is a spent force: the "Leninist" candidate got just 96 votes. Labour won Brent East with a greatly increased majority. It's a pity we did not have a mon sensible candidate.
Livingstone learned his "police conspiracy" mania while working closely with Gerry Healy in the early 1980s.
The SWP playing at being the Anti-Christ PRESISIGANG spare a to ought For eeling a little depressed Spare a thought for Robert Harris, the lone pro-Labour columnist on the Sunday Times.
Comparing himself to Last, the tragic hero of Evelyn Waugh's A Handful of Dust (trapped forever in a jungle clearing, forced to read aloud the entire works of Dickens to a lunatic, over and over again) Harris comments:
"This is roughly how I feel this morning, contemplating my future career as a political columnist: 1,200 words a week, week in, week out, stretching into the 14th, 15th, 16th, 17th and maybe even - God preserve us - the 18th successive years of Conservative rule, all of them under the leadership of John Major. I ask you: what kind of life is that?"
Harris's explanation for this sad state of affairs is simple: we are a nation of liars. "The cynics were right after all. People may say they would prefer better PLATFORM By Mark Nevill Martin Thomas in his fourth paragraph - *l wish I could send my daughter to Summerhill" - con demns his article, "Summerhill at 70".
The vast majority of us can't afford private education, be it Summerhill or a local prep school. But, with Summerhill, this isn't the main issue. What is, though, is the type of community which enables children best to develop and empower public services, but in the end they will vote for tax cuts. At least some of them had the decency to feel too ashamed to admit it."
I predict that this sort of explanation for last Thursday's debacle will achieve some currency in leftish circles. It chimes in with the noises already being made by the likes of Martin Jacques, to the effect that Labour can never win while it retains the vestiges of its traditioncommitments to collectivism and redistribution - everything, in fact, that makes it a distinctly working-class party. The spirit of Essex Man, we will be told, has risen from the Dagenham Marshes to permeate the very soul of the British electorate.
The other obvious explanation is no more encouraging: it's all the fault of the tabloid press.
David Hill, Labour's Director of Communications, described the tabloid campaign as "the most vituperative attack on any political party I have ever seen" . There is certainly plenty of justification for bitterness on this score. The dirty, snarling, personalised anti-Labour and anti-Kinnock barrage of the Sun, Daily Mail, Daily Express and Daily Star reached new depths in the last week of the campaign.
Academic studies of the 1987 election have shown that the Tory tabloids influenced about 2% of undecided voters: in a lot of key marginals that 2% would have been crucial. A themselves socially.
Whilst recognising Summerhill's inadequacies in S Neill's "compromise" , what we have to realise is that at pre sent and in any future society, adults will and must take decisions for children. Within that, children need to thrive, challenge, feel free and, above all, be happy.
Any Marxist parent, child car worker or anyone who has an understanding of children's needs and development, will understand the need, the responsibility which goes in placing boundaries and decisions upon children. Without this, the child risks emotional and physical harm.
Whilst agreeing with some of the philosophies of A S Neill which enable children to make decisions empowering themselves and to have equal status with adults, what we saw at Summerhill was only partly the above. -Yes, some were highly articulate and I was impressed by the conduct of the meetings. But what I also saw, which Martin Thomas didn't, were unhappy children, potential violent, cruel adults along with one or two spoilt brats.
The decapitating and bullying incidents which were arrogantly quoted by Martin Thomas, say more recent survey of the Tory-held marginal Basildon showed that 50% of homes read the Sun compared with only a third that take the Mirror. Perhaps Saturday's Sun was right to boast: "It's The Sun Wot Won It!" , claiming that its puerile anti-Kinnock front page had been prominently displayed throughout Basildon on polling day.
But the press is scarcely less hostile to Labour these days than it has been in previous elections this century. If we subscribe to the popular leftist myth of an all-powerful Tory press, we cannot explain Labour ever having won an election. That said, given the importance of Tory marginals in the South East, and the evidence of a distinct pro-Tory swing in the final days of the campaign, it may be that on this occasion the tabloids did make a crucial difference.
But the fundamental reason for Labour's failure cannot be explained by either the spectre of Essex more than what he discusses.
Whilst at school myself, bullies bullied, there was violence to animals from dissecting fish to shooting cats. The differenc was that we would do this between ourselves, when no adult was around. When found out by adults, we were reprimanded by a good shout right through to a bruising beating.
Looking back now, it wasn't necessarily being told I was wrong but the method with "Every system of care education and society imposed on children without consent. As Marxists we want a society without abuse oppression towards children...
which I was made to correct my ways. Directly after the decapitating incident, where was the criticism, who explained to the boys that what they did was cruel and violent? Will Martin Thomas go out to the woods and teach his daughter similar acts? I think not.
This then takes Man stalking the land, or the invincibility of tabloid propaganda.
As in 1987, Labour is acknowledged by friend and foe alike to have won the campaign at the PR level. What Neil Kinnock and his team failed to do was convince the electorate that they offered a worthwhile alternative to the Tories.
And all the slick marketing, triumphalist rallies and soft-focus videos in the world won't persuade the punters to buy a product that they don't believe it. A lecturer in marketing from Cambridge University drew a cruel but apposite parallel in this week's Independent on Sunday: "Business history is strewn with expensive marketing campaigns that failed. One of the most famous is Fords' Edsel which, although the most hyped car to date when it was launched in the 1950s, flopped. Labour's campaign now joins it."
So the tabloids may have made some difference. But not the crucial difference. first paragraph. "I wish send my daughter to Summerhill". This would be hi decision, not the child's. Rather than accuse the press of liberal. ism (of which they are guilty) 1 think Martin Thomas's approach to Summerhill falls into liberal ideas.
Every system of care, education and society is imposed on children without consent. As Marxists, we want a society without abuse or oppression towards children, whether this i through the family, with an ope network to the egalitarian community which we want, or a community-based family where responsibilities and care are shared throughout the community.
This is an important debate, something which has been left off the Marxist agenda for many years.
Obviously Martin Thomas wasn't attempting to take on this debate but, coming out with such an article, siding with the outdated and now very much liberal ideas of Summerhill, rather than with any serious Marxist attempt to come to terms with the oppressive famil unit and the ongoing abuse which occurs to children in our society. This certainly doesn't help the debate in a socialist paper.
Scan page 7
Socialist Organiser No. 520 page 7