Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Good news from West Belfast 0 the election is the defeat of

Socialist Organiser no. 520, 14 April 1992 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,126 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

"When fights, the labour movement can around the core of th labour movement to legislation against extreme exploitation and in favour of working-class organisation, and for welfare provision, which superimposed elements of "the political economy of the working class" (the expression is Karl Marx's) on the still-dominant political economy of the bourgeoisie.

When it fights, the labour movement can win. It can, and did, win enough people around the core of the labour movement to gain overall electoral majorities. It did that in 1945, despite the tremendous advantage that Churchill's war leadership gave the Tories, and despite a vicious and dirty • Тогу campaign (they alleged that Labour would set up an authoritarian state "with its own Gestapo" , and so on).

The Labour leaders of that time were a long way fromSO 's idea of socialism, but they were honest reformists. They did not go into that election pleading with the electorate for the chance to show that they could make a better job of carrying through Tory policies than Churchill could, nor rely on the tacky arts of the Public Relations consultants or on political beautycontest razzamatazz to sell the same policies as the Tories under a different label and with pink packaging instead of blue.

When it fights when it represents something distinctive -the labour movement can win. Kinnock did not fight. He shadowboxed. The US-style rally before a big hand-picked audience in Sheffield was Kinnock's best idea of fighting - it was as it, like superstitious savages, Kinnock and his advisers believed they could conjure up a triumph by mimicking it in advance.

Kinnock did not represent anything politically distinctive. Even Labour's pledges on the Health Service were tepid and conditional, "as resources allow"

In these circumstances, all the natural advantages of the Establishment's party, the natural party of government, won the election for the Tories. Even the slump worked for them: because Labour had no distinctive policy to win people to, and because Kinnock was palpably untrustworthy - if he could not be trusted to stick to his own chosen beliefs, how could he be trusted with Margaret Thatcher's or John Major's beliefs — many unhappy people thought it safer to stick with the natural party of capitalism. reason why Labour lost the his is the basic, underlying election. Kinnock's craven, passive, Tory-mimicking politics enhanced and strengthened every one of the natural advantages the Tories always have.

If a Labour victory would have been the beginning of the turning of the Tory tide that has flowed for 13 years, lavouring and encouraging working-class action, is this fourth Tory victory likely to lead to the opposite?

Probably not. The Tory press brouhaha that the election signifies the death of socialism is no more than a continuation of the longterm bourgeois campaign to achieve just that, the death of socialism: it is an attempt to improve on their election victory by further pulverising the Labour Party: it is a form of pressure on the Labour Party to go further to the right and finally to cut its links with the trade unions.

Most of the arguments in the press are rhetorical and spurious. For example, the jeering rhetorical question they throw at Labour: if you can not win in a slump, when can you ever win?

In the given circumstances, the slump triggered an additional need for safety and caution in those not wiped out by it. Something similar happened in the 1935 election (and in 1931, though that was complicated by the defection of the Labour leader Ramsey MacDonald to the Tories).

Labour is in a much improved position in Parliament. The official Labour Party argument that the Party is well-placed to win in the next election is — other things being equal — not entirely spurious.

And the Tory victory is a victory for a Toryism that has felt compelled to moderate its Thatcherism in order to survive electorally. It is a Turn to page One piece of good news from Gerry Adams, president of Sinn Fein, in West Belfast, and the election of Joe Hendron, another nationalist.

If you want to know why, consider the scene at the count.

West Belfast includes both the Catholic and the Protestant heartland - the Catholic Falls and the Protestant Shankill. They are separated by only a few streets - and by a great wall erected by the British authorities to prevent sectarian fighting.

Adams seems to have lost because some Protestants voted "tactically" for Hendron to put Adams out.

As the results were announced, Adams's supporters set up a great chant directed at Hendron and his friends: "UDA! UVF!" That is, it wa the votes of such people which gave Hendron the seat. That is, further and inescapably, that all Protestants are UVF or UDA.

In response, Hendron, a constitutional nationalist and a long-time member of the Social Democratic and Labour Party, denounced all the paramilitary organisations, Catholic a: well as Protestant, reeling off a long string of initials - IRA, UDA, INLA UVF, IPLO.

Adams then jeered that Hendron had the seat, but Sinn Fein had the "nationalist" vote, that is, the Catholic vote, as if Protestant votes must count for less.

It was a revolting spectacle of cruc Catholic sectarianism, which showed up the blatant communalism under Sinn Fein's Republican mask.

It recalls an incident six years ago, after the London-Dublin agreement was signed giving Dublin a political say in the running of Northern Ireland. The SDLP and its leader Jot Hume were among the behind-the-scenes architects of the agreement; Sinn Fein, like the Protestant politicians, was a bitter opponent of it.

In the face of the big Protestant protest movement that followed, Sint Fein proposed - and the SDLP gleefully refused - a common electoral front to the SDLP! Given that Sinn Fein and the SDLP were in opposite camps on the issue of the day, the common front could only be on the basis of Catholic-sectarian headcounting.

Sinn Fein says it is a Republican movement, based on the ideas of Wolfe Tone, whose central idea was the unity and equality of all the people of Ireland, Protestant and Catholic alike. The SDLP is a bourgeois party; it is nevertheless a lot nearer to the unitybuilding politics of real Trish Republicanism than are Adams and his gang of armed Catholic communalists.

US threatsi NOT BE MY NATT SULT NEE Subscribe!

Introductory offer: 10 issues, post free. Send E5 (cheques and postal orders made out to "Socialist Organiser")

Name.

Address Return to S.O. (Subs), PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Scan page 6

Socialist Oganiser No.520 page 6

----- pull-quotes -----

win. It can, and did, win enough people

gain electoral majorities. It im 1945."

SOGALIST decisively Troops out of the Gulf!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 520

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →