Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

OPPORTUNITY Why Labour lost

Socialist Organiser no. 520, 14 April 1992 · scan p. 3 · about 1,188 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

The media-oriented "image"-building was no substitute for political campaigning and probably only made Labour appear tacky and untrustworthy. Photo: Joh The media-oriented "image"-building was no substitute for political campaigning and probably only made Labour appear tacky and untrustworthy. Photo: John Harris The General Election of 9 T April could have marked the turn of the tide for the labour movement.

The Tories could have been defeated. The dead weight of a long decade of major working-class setbacks could have been sloughed off.

That chance has gone. Labour lost the election. The Tories have a majority of 21 seats, for 43% of the vote. They look secure for five years.

This Tory victory is therefore -it must be said plainly - a very grave defeat for the working class and for the labour movement. We will pay a heavy price. The recovery of labour movement selfGreham Bash Madimniri Derer Terry Eagleton Jatin Hariei(Labo Pate Black Sectionsi Dorpthy Macern Joertarino John Mcllroy John Nichtbisow Peter Tatihlell Mew ber softbe itineery onemutte assedrawe Cromebrom торь Бестоко ike delt whomn pposedrtoi tíne d lngown Parte witch-hunt against Socialist Organiser. View expressed in arțiçlesre the responsioli noii authorsæandı notmointhe Ablvisbrr Titpripk Board confidence and combativity w ill be slower, more drawn-out, and fraught with difficulties. W did the Tories hy did Labour lose? Why win? The short answer to that question comes in two parts.

Neil Kinnock and his friends did not seriously campaign against the Tories over the last five years, as an opposition that meant business would have done, seizing on issues like the poll tax. And Neil Kinnock's Labour Party appeared before the electorate as an untried and untrustworthy gang of Tory understudies, concerned only to win votes at any price.

The voters chose to stay with the Tories they knew rather than take a risk with the "me-too" pale-pink pseudo-Tories who staff Labour's front benches.

The nasty personal attacks on Kinnock were effective because Kinnock does appear in political life with the brand of the turncoat and the traitor on his forehead. He is a man who has, for political advantage, trimmed and changed and abandoned all the political opinions he formed when he was honestly thinking about political issues, and not about how best to gather votes.

Neither Kinnock nor the Labour Party could have had a convincing reply to the jeer that Kinnock was not to be trusted. Ironically, the very alacrity with which Kinnock embraced and adopted fory and Liberal policy, abandoning his own previous views, destroyed his credibility as a man to be trusted with any policies at all!

When Labour's leaders rushed to endorse calls for the Government to use public money to compensate the speculators who had got their fingers burned at Lloyds of London, a lot of people who agreed decision not to compensate must have been convinced that this Labour front bench of bellycrawling ex-radicals was hysterical and unbalanced, not only by socialist standards, but by any standards of proper political behaviour.

When the Kinnock front-bench gang of former leftists, having shed their own souls, slithered around Westminster, the spectacle was revolting, and not only to socialists. When Kinnock made his speeches "Neil Kinnock and his friends did not meant business have done."

about "dying for his country", or about "serving democracy" : Or about how he "loved" Britain as much as Glynis, they were embarrassing not because he was insincere - probably he was being completely sincere - but because he was plainly speaking under compulsion and duress, saying what the tabloids wanted him to say (and much good it did him with them!)

Kinnock and his team might have got away with it if they could at the same time have offered alternatives to the Tories' policies, and if they had put up a fight on issues where everyone knew the Tories were wrong. But Labour's central policies have been only marginally different from those of the Tories, and they have been a woefully wet and wimpish Opposition. The consequence is that they appeared to the electorate as anespecially tacky gang of politicians on the make, willing to say and do almost anything to win office.

The Thatcher era opened with an unemployed Liverpudlian, Alan Bleasdale's fictional Yosser Hughes, capturing the imagination and sympathy of Britain with his desperate plea: "Gi's a job". The Kinnock era closed with Labour's leaders winning only the disdain and contempt of large numbers of Labour's natural supporters with the cry, "Gi's a vote"

Socialist Organiser said all this throughout the campaign and over the long pre-election campaign.

We warned that Kinnock's policy of sitting tight and hoping that the Tories would lose the election, tipping the ripe apples and plums of office into the arms of the waiting Labour Party, was irresponsible. It meant passive speculation rather than a struggle to win and to create the majorities necessary for victory.

When John Major took over from Thatcher 18 months ago, he said that he could win the election despite everything because the Tory Party was "one of the greatest fighting machines in Western Europe". . That was and is true. And Labour responded to that machine by mimicking the noises its engines made, as if that could give them its power; and they stood gawping as it bore down on them, with the confidence of idiots that Major's tank was certain to run out of fuel. They got everything ridiculously wrong.

This is the short, immediate answer to the question, why did Labour lose. But the labour movement which is now trying to orient itself after the fourth successive Tory victory needs to look at the more basic explanations also. Those Harris explanations lie not only in the nature of the Kinnock-led Labour Party, and in its inept pertormance against Major, but in the political system under which we live.

Consider what really happened in this election. The labour movement which found itself compelled to go into battle under the leadership of the Kinnock gang did not fight just a political party: it fought the dominant forces in our bourgeois society. With odd exceptions like the Financial Times -whose readers will not have followed its advice to vote Labour! - the entire Establishment gathered around the Tory party.

TheFinancial Times itselt, doing an opinion poll of top bosses, found that 92 per cent of them backed the Tories, with 7% Liberal and just 1% Labour.

The Establishment's control over our lives does not depend on elections. The decisions which shape Turn to page 4 The emancipation ofthel workingıclass Isialso whel emencipetion orlak/ human beings without distinction of sex or race.

Kari Marxe восмой Urgeniser PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Newsweek: 011609 09650 Leestate forepoes: Monday. Editor: John O Mahony Published by: WL Publications Ltd PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA kanterlya TwdantPress, Edenbridge Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Articlerk/owon gecessarily reflect the viewsror Socialism Organiser and aren a personal capacity

----- pull-quotes -----

Ablvisony Fiditonia Broand

with the Tory Government's final WHY LABOUR LOST

seriously campaign against the Tories over the last five years, as an opposition which

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 520

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →