Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A school without fear

Socialist Organiser no. 519, 2 April 1992 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 1,348 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Television Martin Thomas reviev Summerhill at 70 Wwe heard the head teacher ithin the first few minutes saying, "This place is up shit creek"

Channel 4 TV's documentary on Summerhill school (Monday 30th) caught the school at a bad time: the children had just voted to abolish all school rules, as apparently they do every ten years or so.

The reviewers in the liberal press were horrified: "I did not get the impression that anyone learned anything except automatic obscenity, incessant violence, intermittent theft... " (the Guardian); "the pupils seem to spend their time swearing, bullying, make bows and arrows, decapitating rabbits, and 'pairing off'..." (the Independent). I guess that is a sign of how liberalism has shifted in recent years.

To me it did not look like that at all. I wish my daughter could go to Summerhill.

Summerhill is a school founded by the anarchist writer AS Neill in 1921, where all rules (apart from minimal ones for safety) are decided and enforced democratically by the children, currently aged between 10 and 16, and lessons are voluntaryGiven freedom, the children express aggression and hatred. Neill never believed that children are angels. "Their community sense — their sense of social responsibility — does not develop until the age of 18 or more."

But, he wrote, "a school that makes active children sit at desks, studying mostly useless subjects, is a bad school. It is a good school only for those who want docile, uncreative children who will fit into a civilisation whose standard of success is money"

A conventional school where children are forced to behave like «We will never learn to be free as adults unless we learn to be free as children. Even a small experiment in making that possible...is something to cherish." obedient little workers between lesson bells, and tacitly allowed to behave like brutes outside them, breeds fear, frustration, boredom, alienation and bullying.

What do the liberal journalists of the Guardian and the Independent think real children are like in conventional schools? What was unusual about Summerhill, from what I saw in the TV programme, was the absence of fear and bullying, and the absence of tension between children and teachers.

One little boy complained of ‹harassment" - whether rightly or not the programme showed us no

Scan page 14

ers, then she would push whatever laws to celebrate the sum ix new laws since 1980 have succes- They said that the leg sively narrowed the right to strike, to this had been set in c picket, and to organise. Law-making the miners' strike. Th has gone hand in hand with the action of coaches in the "Battle employers, police, and judges to beat arresting over 500. The Socialist Organiser No. 519 page 14 By / Chris Reynolds Chris Reynolds Sals need area of til i State, ince 1979 the Tories have systemati- ince 1979 the Tories have systematicrushing whole areas of civil liberty.

Two legal experts summarise the record:

• unprecedented extension of police powers;

• a far-reaching statute for the interception of communications by the state;

• wide-ranging restrictions on the freedom of assembly and public protest;

• major limitations on press freedom;

• extension of the powers of the security service;

• extraordinary powers to deal with the troubles in the north of Ireland.

(K D Ewing and C A Gearty, Freedom under Thatcher, Clarendon Press 1990).

Several new laws have strengthened the police and the state.

The Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 extended the powers of the police to stop and search people and to search premises. It empowered the police to detain people for up to 96 hours without charge.

The Public Order Act 1986 made six days notice to the police compulsory for all public marches, and widened the powers of the police to impose conditions on marches and protests, for example to decide where they can be held.

It created a new offence of "disorderly behaviour".

The Security Services Act 1989 gave MIS very wide powers of surveillance; an amendment to outlaw MIS surveillance of people involved in "lawful advocacy, protest or dissent" was specifically voted down. It also entitled MIS to obtain warrants to burgle premises from the Home Secretary, without having to consult a judge.

The Official Secrets Act 1989 entrenched, and arguably extended, the major powers of the notorious old Official Secrets Act of 1911.

Mostly, however, these laws only gave official approval to what the police and MIS were doing already. Meanwhile, the state power has strengthened its grip through a multitude of administrative measures, by the police or by the government, without any formal law-making or Parliamentary debate.

During the miners' strike of 1984-5, police operations were effectively centralised through the Association of Chief Police Officers. The police set up roadblocks, unilaterally banned miners from moving round the country, and imposed almost military rule in some Notts vilages.

Margaret Thatcher declared during the strike that if the police needed new powCIVIL LIBERTIE! they needed through parliament. answer is more police, more power.

Northern Ireland.

down trade unions in the workplaces at the factory gates.

But the increased effective power of the police operates in a much wider sphere than just trade union struggles. The police campaign against people wanting Timer solstice at Stonehenge is an examp sle.

In 1985 the police sel t up road blocks.

al precedents for ourt cases during ey smashed into of the Beanfield" i next year, there was a similar operatior 1: 400 adults and 100 children were forc ed into a disused airfield and evicted. 64 a irrests were made, and 129 vehicles impour nded.

In 1989, the police p sut a ban on the whole area within four miles of Stonehenge, and arreste id 250 people who tried to break the ban.

Court procedures hav e been tightened up. The right of defenc lants to challenge the make-up of juries has been severely restricted, and juries have been more closely vetted by the sta te.

In 1988, the right to silence of defendants was effectivel y abolished in The Tory Governm rent prosecuted Sarah Tidall, Clive P onting, and then the publishers of Spyca tcher, on grounds of "national security" . It has tried to increase its control ov er the BBC, and banned radio and telev rision from transmitting Sinn Fein speak ers. increased by 16,000 ince 19/9 police nu , and government Imbers have been spending on the p olice by 74% (in real terms). Though n umbers in prison have dropped a little in the last few years - since the Tories got alarmed by a series of prison rebellions - they still stand at 45,000, much higher in relation to population than in most other West European countries.

In January 1983 cops shot Stephen Waldorf as he sat in his car, in London, and nearly killed him: "mistaken identity", they explained. Since then several more people have been killed, or nearly killed, by the police, as they become more trigger-happy.

Crime figures are still increasing fast -and the Tories' only answer is more police, more powers for the police, and more prisons.

In 1981 the Tories introduced the British Nationality Act, designed to stop further immigration by black people to Britain. The Act defined three different types of British citizenship, only one of which allows holders to settle here.

This year they have followed up with the Asylum Bill, telling scare stories about a "flood of foreigners" . In fact last year only 45,000 people applied for asylum in Britain. Even before the Bill, Britain was one of the most illiberal countries in Western Europe for refugees. Tamils fleeing the slaughter in Sri Lanka found it easier to get into Germany than Britain, although many of them spoke English and there is an established Tamil community here.

The other area where the Tories have sharply cut into democracy and civil liberty is local government. The Greater London Council and other metropolitan authorities were abolished.

----- pull-quotes -----

still increasing fast and the Tories only

for the police and more prisons."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 519

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →