Taking the censor off pain
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Belinda Weaver reviews The Prince of Tides he Prince of Tides is an old-style, juicy Hollywood entertainment. Suspend belief, go along with it, and you may be surprised to find how much fun it is.
Though it's corny and "uplifting" I didn't feel manipulated: the film is honest in what it's trying to say. And it's saying plenty.
Set in South Carolina and New York, it's the story of Tom Wingo, a football coach and ex-teacher, whose life is falling apart. He's jobless and smoking too much, and his wife and daughters no longer know if he cares for them or not. He's wallen are hate his pushes them away. He hates his mother, and his twin sister, Savannah, a poet, has just tried to commit suicide.
So Tom goes to New York to try to help Susan Lowenstein, Savannah's psychiatrist, find the key to Savannah's self-destructive urges.
From here on, it's part love story (between Lowenstein and Tom), and part detective story, as Susan challenges Tom about his memories, and finally unearths the buried trauma that almost wrecked his family.
That it all ends happily, with Tom restored to his family, Savannah restored to life, and even Lowenstein's troubled relationship with her teenage son, Bernard, sorted out, doesn't spoil things. The film is all about, optimism, fresh starts, and "coming to terms" . It's about resolution, it's about redemption, but it's mostly about forgiveness.
At the end, Tom says that "no crime within a family is beyond forgiveness" , and we see him forgiving people wholesale - his adulterous wife, his violent father, him you re not vomiting by now, you'll be glad to know there are drawbacks. Lowenstein is played by Barbra Streisand with Fu Manchu fingernails, and she's pretty bad. It's her film, she directed it, so there are vanity bits for her strewn all through. She shows off her French (which actually sounds rather stilted), Tom tells her (endlessly) that she's beautiful, and she's the presiding saint everyone is grateful to.
Drawback two is the soundtrack - aural syrup of the most hideous kind.
But for me, the positive bits outweighed the schmaltz.
The film contrasts Tom with his mother, Lila. She's tough. "When I put something behind me, close the door" , she says. And that's her problem. She denies things, she buries them, and she makes her children bury them too, causing untold damage. The film condemns her denials, and it condemns her reinvention of herself, courtesy of a wealthy second marriage. American movies generally cheer on characters who escape their pasts; they're usually put up as role models. Not in this film.
The film can be taken metaphorically. The trauma that hits the Wingos can easily stand for traumas that come from within (such as incest, secretld abuse), Apart from the the Wingo children's upbringing was screwy enough to drive them mad. Tom's father was physically violent; his mother was dishonest and manipulative. Yet the forgiveness message still applies.
Tom feels his pain, he faces things, and exorcises them. This frees him to change.
Tom works for us because Nick Nolte makes him work. Nolte's face is weathered, but he's posed as an ideal — a he-man, but sensitive to culture and literature; enough of a kid to enjoy being silly with his daughters, but smart enough to know that teenagers like Bernard need to test themselves, to grow away from mothers and fathers. evidence to decide - but we saw the other children trying to sort out the problem, and the boy, a bit later, saddened because his parents were moving back to America and taking him away from Summerhill. The meetings at which the children decided and enforced their rules compared very favourably for reasonableness and coherence with many adult meetings I have attended.
Of course my daughter will not go to Summerhill, unless we make a socialist revolution within the next ten years or so: it has to charge fees, and so can only take children from well-off families (though in its early years it had mainly "problem" children).
Summerhill: the liberal horrified heart violinist husband.
Streisand has had a lot of stick for The Prince of Tides. With her six or seven houses and her megabuck lifestyle, Streisand could be seen as a latter-day Marie Antoinette looking down on people in misery and saying "Let them eat Freud"
But that's not the whole story. In a country like the USA, whose politicians deny reality, who reinvent themselves ever more flatteringly, who censor anger and rage, who only license false images and sickly false sentiments, a film that scorns all that, that condemns it, is good news, whoeyer makes it.
Of course, as Neill himself wrote: "Summerhill is an island...Hating compromise as I do, I have to compromise here, realising that my primary job is not the reformation of society, but the bringing of happiness to some few children."
Of course it would not bring instant utopia if we suddenly transferred the Summerhill regime to the schools in New York where they have armed guards in the playground.
Yet we will never be free as adults unless we learn to be free as children. Even a small experiment in making that possible, however partially and even for a few children, is something to cherish.
----- pull-quotes -----
And He's secure enough to stand up to Lowenstein's creepy, all-art-no-