Lenin: the will
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Thisı tribute Lenhiwasi wattenı in il19/23 —-when enin was itki incapaciaterl benstroke— boKanl Radekra Polish revolntowar/active nn ntlue Bollskewk Partyr avd etithe timesonemf l hedendens offtine Itisıtimely now, on thes 122nd emnarenserymof eninis birthwm April II8Z/Diäit eplbesppwerf Mllyan the picturesof Le ninafashiomablentorlay xasaa somiherss deolpgues casuallysno if icinputhenlues awd happrness ofrealıpepp lentomabstvacimutop assor "When Lewin nasito decilezom amampontam guestion, hendoes not khin krokalstrecn historicad categories…. _Jherthi mosmiltheneffech oftthenmeasuremo the pe santesp-andrspmand on the orker such-emdLenin with Trotsky (left) and Kamenev in 1920.
rptskyisti lelit opposhron.
ruthless powerupolince.
such..."
Like everything else in nature, Lenin was born, has develmoped, has grown. When Vladimir Ilyich once observed me glancing through a collection of his articles written in the year 1903, which had just been published, a sly smile crossed his face, and he remarked with a laugh: "It is very interesting to read what stupid fellows we were!"
But I do not here intend to compare the shape of Lenin's skull at the age of 10, 20 or 30, with the skull of that man who presided over the sessions of the Central Committee of the party or the Council of People's Commissars.
Here it is not a question of Lenin as leader, but as a living human being.
PB Axelrod, one of the fathers of Menshevism, who hates Lenin from the bottom of his soul, related, in one of the tirades with which he sought to convince me of the harmfulness of Bolshevism in general and of Lenin in particular, how Lenin went abroad for the first time, and how he went walking and bathing with him. "I felt at that time", said Axelrod, "that here was a man who would become the leader of the Russian Revolution. Not only was he an educated Marxist - there were many of these - but he knew what he wanted to do and how it was to be done. There was something of the smell of Russian earth about him." Pavel Borisovich Axelrod is a bad politician; he does not smell Lenin of the earth. He is one who reasons at home in his own study, and the whole tragedy of his life consists of the fact that at a time when there was no labour movement in Russia, he thought out the lines upon which such a labour movement should develop, and when it developed on different lines he was frightfully offended, and today he continues to roar with rage at the disobedient child.
But people often observe in others that which is lacking in themselves, and Axelrod's words with regard to Lenin grasp with unsurpassable acuteness precisely those characteristics which make Lenin a leader.
It is impossible to be a leader of the working class without knowing the whole history of the class. The leaders of the labour movement must know the history of the labour movement - without this knowledge there can be no leader, just as nowadays there can be no great general who could be victorious with the least expenditure of force unless he knew the history of strategy.
The history of strategy is not a collection of recipes as to how to win a war, for a situation once described never repeats itself. But the mind of the general becomes practised strategy by its express study; this study renders him elastic in war, permits him to observe the dangers and possibilities which the empirically trained general cannot see.
The history of the labour movement does not tell us what to do but it makes it possible to compare our position with situations which have already been experienced by our class, so that in various decisive moments we are enabled to see our path clearly, and to recognise approaching danger.
But we cannot get to know the history of the labour movement properly without being thoroughly acquainted with the history of capitalism, with its mechanism in all its economic and political phenomena. Lenin knows the history of capitalism as do but few of Marx's pupils. It is no mere knowledge of the written word -here comrade Riazanov could give him five points start -but he has thought out Marx's theory as no one else has done.
Let us for instance take the small pamphlet which he wrote at the time of our conflict with the trade union movement - in it he calls Bukharin a syndicalist, an eclectic and a great sinner in numerous other respects. This polemical pamphlet contains a few lines devoted to the differences between dialectics and eclectics, lines which are not cited in any collection of articles on historical materialism, but which say more about it than whole chapters from much longer books.
Lenin has independently grasped and thought out the theory of historical materialism as no one else has been able to do, for the reason that he has studied it with the same object in view by which Marx was actuated when creating the theory.
Lenin entered the movement as the embodiment of the Will to Revolution; and he studied Marxism, the evolution of capitalism, and the evolution of socialism, from the point of view of their revolutionary significance. Plekhanov was a revolutionist too, but he was not possessed by the Will to Revolution, and despite his great importance as a teacher of the Russian Revolution, he could only teach its algebra and not its arithmetic. Herein lies the point of transition from Lenin the theorist to Lenin the politician.
Lenin's way of knowing the Russian actuality is another point in which he differs from all others who have stretched out their hands toward the sceptre of leadership of the Russian proletariat. Not only does he know Russian reality, he sees and feels it as well.
At every turning point in the history of the party, and espe'''..here was a man who would become the leader of the... revolution. Not only was he an educated Marxist... but he knew what he wanted to do and how it was to be done. There was something of the smell of the Russian earth about him... ' "
cially at the moment when we seized power and the fate of 150 million people hung on the decisions of the party, I have always been amazed at Lenin's store of what the English call "common sense" . It may be remarked that when we are speaking of a human being of whom we are convinced that his like will not recur for a century, it is but a poor compliment to praise his common sense. But if is just in this that his greatness as a politician lies.
When Lenin has to decide on an important question, he does not think of abstract historical categories, he does not think of ground rents, of surplus values, of absolutism or liberalism. He thinks of Sobakevitch, of Gessen, of Syfor from the Tver Province, of the Putilov worker, of the policeman on the street, and he thinks of the effect of the measure on the muzhik (peasant) Sydor and on the workman Onufria, as bearers of the revolution.
Marx, in the introduction to his Critique of Political Economy, states that history only sets itself such tasks as it can fulfill. This means, in other words, that only he who grasps what tasks are historically capable of fulfillment at a given moment, and who does not fight for the desired, but for the possible, can become the instrument of history. Lenin's greatness lies in the fact that he never permits himself to be blinded to a reality when it is in the process of transformation, by any preconceived formula, and that he has the courage to throw yesterday's formula overboard as soon as it disturbs his grasp of this reality. Lenin's greatness lies in his aiming at goals arising out of realities. In this reality he sees a powerful steed which will carry him to his goal, and he trusts himself to it. But he never abandons himself to his dreams. This is not all. His genius contains another trait: after he has set himself a certain goal, he seeks for the means leading to this goal through reality; he is not content with having fixed his aim, he thinks out concretely and completely everything necessary for the attainment of that "History offers no second example of such a transition from subterranean revolutionist to statesman... And that this leader should be the only one universally recognised as leader, the human touch was required...
aim. He does not merely work out a plan of campaign, but the whole organisation of the campaign at the same time.
How all this happened to be combined in him, God only knows (Comrade Stefanov and the Commission for combating religion will kindly excuse.) History has her own apparatus for distilling brandy...
For fifteen years we looked on while this man was fighting over every comma in the resolutions, against every "ism" invented
Scan page 11
to revo ution Vis. For Lenin every such during the last twenty-five "ism" has always been the embodiment of some real enemy, existing either in or outside classes or in the working class, but in any case in reality. These "isms" were the feelers of reality, and he absorbed the whole of this reality into himsell, studied it, thought it out until the finished miracle appeared, and the underground man proved himself the most earthly man of Russian reality. History offers no second example of such a transition from subterranean revolutionist to statesman. This combination of the characteristics of a leading theorist, politician and organiser has made Lenin the leader of the Russian Revolution. And that this leader should be the only one universally recognised as leader, the human touch was required, the quality which has made Lenin the beloved hero of the Russian Revolution.
He himself tries to convince us that man requires absolute truth. For many people the truth is deadly, it is deadly even for many classes. If the bourgeoisie were to grasp the truth about itself, and were permeated with this truth, it would be defeated already, for who can go on fighting when the truth of history tells him that he is not only condemned to death, but that his corpse will be thrown into the sewer?
The bourgeoisie is blind and dumb to its fate. But a revolutionary class needs the truth, for truth is the knowledge of reality And it is not possible to dominate this reality without knowing it. We form one part of this reality: the working class, the Communist Party. And it is only if we are able to judge of our power and our weakness that we can judge of the measures to be taken to ensure final Lenin tells the proletariat the truth, and the truth only, however depressing it may be. When workers hear him speaking, they know that there is not a single glib expression in all his speech. He helps us to inform ourselves on reality.
At one time I was living at Davos with a Bolshevik workman dying of consumption. At that time the right of self-determination of nationalities was. being debated, and we Polish communists were opposed to Lenin's views. The comrade of whom I speak, after having read my theses against Lenin, said: "What you have written is perfectly convincing to me, but whenever I have been opposed to Ilyich, it has always turned out afterwards that l was wrong."
This is how the leading party functionaries think, and this is the reason of Lenin's authority in the party; but the workers do not think so. They do not feel bound to Lenin because he has been in the right a thousand times, but because, if he has once been in the wrong, if a mistake has been committed under his leadership, he admitted openly: "We have made a mistake, and therefore we have been deteated here; this mistake must be made good in such and such a manner.
Many have asked him why he speaks so openly of mistakes made. I do not know why Lenin "A great class, itself needing absolute truth, loves... a leader who is himself a truth-loving human being... who tells the truth about himself. From such a leader the worker can bear any truth, even the hardest."
does it but the results of this course of action may be plainly seen. The workman is much too enlightened to believe in redeeming saviours any longer. When Lenin speaks of his mistakes, he hides nothing, he leads the worker into his own laboratory of thought, he makes it possible for the worker to take part in forming the final decision, and the workers see in him the leader who represents their laboratory, the embodiment of their class struggle.
A great class, itself needing absolute truth, loves with its whole heart a leader who is himself a truth-loving human being, one who tells the truth about himself. From such a leader the worker can bear any truth, even the hardest.
Human beings have faith in themselves only when they conceal nothing, when they know everything about themselves, AAC POI Bor 823.
pmdon= SIE1.5-41VA even the most unfavourable possibilities, and yet feel that they can say: in spite of everything... Lenin helps the working class to a full knowledge of every decaying and decomposing element of its own existence and yet enables it to say in the end: I am His Majesty the Proletariat, the future ruler and creator of life.
On this day of the 25th anniversary of the party which not only bears responsibility for the destiny of the sixth part of the globe, but which is at the same time the main lever of proletarian victory, the Russian communists, and every revolutionist among the proletariat of every country, are filled with the thought and the wish that this Moses, who has led the slaves from the land of bondage, may pass with us into the promised land.
Footnotes:
Axelrod, Plekhanov Menshevism:
Axelrod was one of those with George Plekhanov, organised the pioneer group of Russian Marxists in exile in Switzerland in the 1880s. After 1903 the Russian Marxist movement divided into a left wing ("Bolsheviks") and right wing ("Mensheviks"); Axelrod and Plekhanov supported the right wing.
Riazanov:
David Riazanov, the Bolsheviks' great expert the writings of Marx and Engels.
"Our conflict with the tr union movement":
In 1921, when the Russia workers' state was sorepressed and in economic chaos, at the end of the w against the counterOrganiser revolutionaries and foreign armies, the Bolshevik party debated trade union policy.
Bukharin and Trotsky advocated the "militarisation of labour" to restore industry Lenin successfully insisted that the trade unions must able to represent workers' interests independently if necessary against the "workers' state with bureaucratic deformations". Bukharin:
Nikolai Bukharin, a Bolsher leader, an ally of Stalin in 1925-8 but later purged because of his opposition Stalin's forced- march industrialisation and collectivisation.
Syndicalist:
One who sees socialism coming exclusively through trade-union struggle. Bukharin's policy in 1921 implied a merger of the trai unions with the state. Dialectics and eclectics: Dialectics is an approach which sees reality as in a process of development through contradictions.
Eclectics is "on the one this, on the other hand th "Historical materialism" term sometimes used to describe Marxism.
Debate on nationalities: Lenin advocated the right of nations to self-determination. Polish Marxists, under the leadership of Rosa Luxemburg, argued that this "right" was utopian nonsense in a world where capitalism was creating bigger and more integrated economic territories.
Scan page 12
e best weekend Socialist Organiser No. 519 page 12 Workers wherty-y2
----- pull-quotes -----
Miore-abput Lenin-and linie-real astor y of-the Rusistan Revolution e=50p+ Bon kom
and the October revolution A Workers' Liberty pamphlet 50p