Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The truth be

Socialist Organiser no. 519, 2 April 1992 · scan pp. 8–10 · about 1,285 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

All the following are headlines used in the tabloids last week.

"Teachers, doctors, and middle managers will lose €1,579 a year".(Express, Wednesday 24 March)

The figure is for a single person earning t40,000 a year, whom the Express describes as a "modest" or "medium" earner. No teacher earns this amount, and only a tiny minority of head teachers. The case for doctors and middle managers is almost as unconvincing. If by "medium" earner, the Express means "average", the figure is around £14,000. Only 20% are above €27,000. Only a tiny proportion earn above £40,000.

*Neil Pay Clanger -may blow tax rise on wage hikes" (Sun, Monday 30 March)

To read the Sun you would imagine that Kinnock had promised the world to public sector workers. In reality his only commitment was to increase pub sector pay in line with pay in the private sector. John Major has made the same promise.

"Tories' five point poll lead" (Express, Thursday 25 March)

Scan page 9

laily Express Kinnock knock-on effect *If Kinnock wil →h broadcast is false, says doctor metimes FURY AT Truthahput anythi hind the headlines MAY TO A SLEEKER BODY Any Everyone knows that if you take ough polls some of them will be dly wrong. The Express just ot lucky" , with a sample with a v too many Tory voters. Their ponse - print the result in h-high letters on their front ge.

Labour lead starts to ide in see-saw polls" Lail, Thursday 25 arch)

Again, it's in the nature of pol at they go up and down. That esn't mean that people are anging their minds. There was evidence that Labour were on : decline.

I don't want one person hursday 25 March). A supposed quote from Jennifer nett's mother used as a adline. Not surprising, maybe, ing that she is apparently a - long Conservative voter. But if u read the article you will want d she said something completel ferent. "I don't want one -son to vote Labour as a result my child being used as a litical football."

Kinnock's adviser pays -p staff in bullion to Kinnook'y age For Earlier editions of the paper were quickly replaced to ditch a front page allegation that Labour peer Lord Hollick took personal payment from hıs company MAI in gold bullion to avoid payıng National Insurance. If the Mail changes its lead story after print, you can be pretty sure they knew they were lying. They continued t run a story suggesting that some senior MAI executives were paid in gold. You wonder how many Tories might be caught out if anyone cared to look. Lord Hollick is suing the Mail on Sun day for libel.

«Gas bills frozen and electricity prices cut" (Evening Standard, Thursday 25 March)

Halt he, halt distortion. Only people living in the London area will have their bills cut by 0.5%, and then only if they are paying by direct debit. Everyone else in London will face an increase, on top of last April's 10% price hike. All other electricity boards are increasing their prices.

True, gas prices are to be pegged at last year's levels. But what the article fails to mention is last year British Gas promised that thi year's price rises would be 5% below the level of inflation. Inflation is at 4.1%, so surely that means a 0.9% cut? Maybe we know where British Gas's chair got his £1,252 a week pay increase, which the Standard fails mention.

Make an average day in the life of a tabloid election campaign. Wednesday 25 March, was not exceptional.

THE SUN leads page 2 with "Kinnock "trying to lie his way to power'. " The whole article is little more than a reproduction of a quote from Norman Tebbit. It is backed with an article linking racist Tory comic Jim Davidson to black Tory candidate John Taylor, each saying how much they admire each other.

Strangest of all was an article stating "John Smith was dubbed "pooper scooper' last night after he tried to clear the mortgage row started by Neil Kinnock". All the dubbing was, of course, done by Sun hacks, not least because there was no "mortgage row"

The piece was a follow-up to thi Tuesday Sun headline, "Home Groan — You'll queue for a mortgage under me, says Kinnock", the Sun avoiding libel by not using quotation marks.

The story? Kinnock saying that credit controls were unlikely, but if they were necessary then people would prefer waiting an extra month or two for a mortgage to paying 15% interest on it. John Smith said he thought credit control unlikely.

A row? This was all doubly warped because it happened at same time as a very real attack Thatcher on the borrowing requirement in Lamont's Budget.

The two-page feature "Kinnock in rift with his best man" was another attempt to make a scandal out of nothing.

There was a small piece on the Jennifer broadcast, and in the interests of balance there was a twelve line piece stating without comment that Labour are committed to free dental checks.

THE EXPRESS was first to break the Jennifer story, comple with the consultant's claim that i was an administrative error rathe than NHS under-funding.

There was half a page on Neil Kinnock as "Labour's invisible man", because he missed a press conference, an "exposé" of his aides (it simply stated that they exist — so "honest John" Major has none?), and a rehash of a David Mellor speech.

The only article not an attack on Labour in the main body of the Express's election coverage was a picture of John Major shaking hands with a King Char Spaniel, with the headline "Maj is top dog now".

Elsewhere the paper carries a glowing profile of Thatcher and an article detailing what will happen as mortgage rates rise under Labour, how much your shares will fall under Labour, and how Labour will tax "medium earners" on £40,000 a year.

THE DAILY STAR contains the mortgage material again, while the DAILY MAIL has its own invisible politician story - this time Gerald Kaufman who, unlike Kinnock, is being kept out of the media's gaze. No mention of the fact that we haven't seen John Gummer a lot, we are unlikely to see William Waldegrave again, Thatcher has been shunted off Stateside.

Elsewhere the paper alerted readers to the effects of a 3% rise in National Insurance contributions on the spurious grounds that John Smith had said I have no proposals to increase them. I don't think it's a possibility..."

This was followed up by an *Action plan to beat Labour". advice to the rich on how to beat taxes.

Finally in its centre-page spread the Mail excelled itself with "Knocked out by Kinnock's knock-on effect" '. Taxes on the rich will mean they will no longer be able to afford gardeners, maids and nannies! So tug your forelock and do as your master says!

With the exception of one twelve line article in the Sun, every article was a clearly pro-Tory statement, often mere repetition of copy from Conservative Central Office (5 cases), petty personal sniping at Labour leaders (4 cases)

or groundless scare stories about Labour policy (4 cases).

The only other articles were a hymn of praise to Thatcher and John Major shaking hands with dog.

Scan page 10

Organiser

----- pull-quotes -----

SLIE KENTON'S ELIE KENTON'S LITE REVOLUTION LITE REVOLUTION

PETSEA BOUR'S KINHS ONTS

, vote Labour - Mum, [argaret Bennett". (Star,

oid tax" (Mail on Sun- y, 29 March) TELLY AD about a

sick little girl. Moll he ever tell the

Knocked out by the out by the day of the

Dog days for the Tories... al-on effect

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 519

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →