Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Proportional representation? Yes, but

Socialist Organiser no. 519, 2 April 1992 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,133 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

The call for a campaign to defend, extend and safeguard civil liberties is timely. But Charter 88 is the wrong platform for such a campaign, with the wrong people and the wrong methods.

The labour movement should launch a campaign for civil liberties; should have launched one long ago.

Nothing can be done hand-in-hand with the bigwigs of Liberalism. During the 1984-85 miners' strike, the Liberal-SDP Alliance criticised the Tories for not repressing the miners enough, for not using the law against them sufficiently! David Owen set the pace, but the future 'Liberal Democrats' did not dissent.

No wonder, then, that Charter 88 says nothing about workers' rights to organise, to strike and to picket. Its version of civil liberties is one divorced and abstracted from the class struggle. Hugo Young summed it up quite aptly in the Guardian: "The Charter 88 movement, founded to push for the Liberal Democrats' version of constitutional reform, is the stronger for having gathered significant backProportional Representation, Jocialists should support but oppose the current campaigns to define PR as the issue of the General Election.

Socialists must be consistent democrats. Without democracy, "socialism" can only be a lying label for one or another form of dictatorship by a new ruling-class elite But socialists are not religious worshippers of constitutional forms. I would be false and stupid to let the pursuit of one small improvement of Britain's parliamentary democracy -a democracy greatly warped and limited by the overwhelming wealth and power of the bosses in industry, finance and the media - override the struggle for all-round democracy in society and industry.

Proportional representation is normally a far more sensitive measure of registering electors' opinion than the system we now have in Britain. It allows each vote to have roughly the same weight, while the first-past-the-post system gives many votes no weight at all. In a word, PR is more democratic.

On the level of principle, socialists cannot be opposed to improving and extending bourgeois democracy, however small the extension may be. Therefore, on principle we must declare ourselves for proportional representation.

The arguments against this are weighty but short-term and narrowly empirical. Yes, proportional representation is being argued for by Labour's right wing. Yes, it is used b those who think it will ensure that there will never again be a majority Labour government. Yes, it is now linked to a campaign by many on the Labour right, and some on the left, too, who should know better, for a Lib-Lab government.

But to come out in principle against a bettering of the electoral system is not the best way to fight the right wing and the coalitionists. It is more likely to discredit the left.

In any case, how can PR be argued against outside the quite narrow circles of the left itself?

We are against bettering democracy because we think it will be bad for our party? Isn't that just another way of saying what the faint-hearts and coalitionists say: that Labour can't win? The left version is that we can win — but only with the rigged electoral system that the ruling class set up long ago... Yes, we can win! Yes, we can get an overall majority! We can win with socialist politics ane a crusading labour movement.

That's what we say now to Kinnoc and the other faint-hearts and trimmers. Or should we amend it to say: Yes, we can win — provided the ruling class doesn't marginally extend democracy? The idea is absurd. Yet that is what we would have to say in honesty, and if we don't say that all we are left with is mumblings and private intra-Labour arguments about which system is most advantageous to us — arguments we could not possibl use generally.

Socialists cannot in principle oppose PR; but there is nothing that compels us to make a religion of it — nothing that compels us to support the campaign for this small improvement in a grossly deficient system and say to hell with the consequences.

PR is now the cry of the coalitionists in the labour movement. The coalitiorists must be opposed and defeated. They must be told: yes, PR is good, but there are more pressing things before the labour movement.

They must be told that their campaign for PR not only detracts from the main question of fighting for a working class alternative to Thatcherism, but gives immediate advantages to the ruling class and its parties. That - rather than untenable opposition to PR as such — is the way to answer the coalitionists.

On that basis the left should say to those who want to distract us now with a campaign for a little bit of democratic tinkering — no, not now, not this campaign. Right now, the labour movement must fight to get rid of the Tories and to put in a government based on the working every unions and political parties. If the parties are bad, change them.

• Charter 88's "professional and hard-headed", "carefullybrokered" approach (as Michael Rustin puts it: New Left Review 191) has brought it a lot of money - from various foundations, and from the Guardian, the Independent, the Observer, the Economist, Time Out magazine and the Body Shop chain, which have sponsored its initiatives.

No doubt "radical" politics with millionaire funding is easier than radical politics with the sort of continual penny-grubbing whir Socialist Organiser and similar newspapers have to pursue. But the millionaires are not fools. They know that constructing a non-Labour alternative to Thatcherite strongarm politics benefits them, not socialism.

Scan page 8

How the millionaire press backs the Tories *Evenina St Mother and consultant in scathing whole affair" she was "absolutely disgusted with the where Jennifer was troated In the programme, baser "I certainly don't vate Labour and we feel we've been on Jennifer's case, an eight-year-old child actor was "We're absolutely disgusted with the whole attair. contrasted her with the fictionai case of a girt who was school and we're just trying to treat this as a notmal But Mr Ardouin said today: "I'm very surprised and TONIGHT'S WEATHER: WET LONDON, WEDNESDAY, 25 MARCH, 1992 attack on I ahn..

ESPICARE M today, saying day. "My husband ten't a Labour supporter.

The mother's words were really happened."

CELL THE VA MaNUur S INHS broadcast ATTA Party be very sad that it should have been portrayed this way. Et or cash problems. It was due to an administrative Lininoci Pander, suffering from "glue ear" ocity. in the computer. She sbould have been Der Closing a computer records was spotted when Bo Ardouin added: "Within any the lead not the mistake being discovered, the

----- pull-quotes -----

S. Day LIARTERSS.

DISGUSTING DISTORTED in action

Why I no longer lie about drugs — by Cecil Parkinson's daughter

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 519

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →