Taking socialists
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
"The biggest mobilisation our rights and the constitution since the suffragettes," is how Chai 88 bills its countrywide meetings with the General Election candidates on 2 April. Or are they an elaborate diversion? Gerry Bates reviews the issues.
Charter 88 is a call for a new, tional settlement in Britain. The name is intended to associate it with the anti-Stalinist Charter 77 in Czechoslovakia, and with the People's Charter proclaimed by the British working class in 1838; but Charter 88's signatories, when it appeared on 29 November 1988, were drawn more from the Establishment than from the people.
It was a broad range of the Establishment, though: from leaders of the Democrats (Roy Jenkins, Des Wilson,) through a wide range of showbiz people, writers, and academics, to figures of the literary Marxist left (Perry "Either Charter 88 is a stalking horse for a Labour/SLD pact, or it is simply an overblown 'Disgusted of Hampstead" Jetter to the Establishment Anderson, Robin Blackburn, Darcus Howe, Ralph Miliband Sheila Rowbotham, A. Sivanandan) and two right wing trade union leaders (Gavin Laird of the AEU and John Ellis of the ing among Labour activists".
It is very much "the Liberal Democrats' version". It omits not only trade union rights, but also repression in Ireland, the increasing aggressiveness of the police, the poll tax, and much else. On most issues it does cover, Charter 88 is vague.
On one point, and one point only, Charter 88 is suddenly precise: "Create a fair electoral system of proportional representation".
Yes, proportional representacion would be fairer than the first-past-the-post-system. But when this one element of democratic reform appears in sharp relief, with all else shrouded in fog or completely off the scene, the socialist signatories of Charter 88 are being taken for a ride by the Liberal Democrats.
Charter 88 was initiated by the magazine New Statesman and Society. Its editor, Stuart Weir, was sacked as editor of the Labour Party journal New Socialist for advocating a Labour/Alliance pact. Charter 88 cannot but be a new attempt to float the same project.
Weir's editorial announced the Charter like this: "It will initiate, we hope, a new and historic reforming alliance of citizens of the libertarian left and the democratic centre in Britain, outside, between and within the political parties..."
Very high-flown; but not very different from the way that the disastrous "Popular Fronts against Fascism" were explained in the 1930s.
Either Charter 88 is a stalking horse for a Labour/SLD pact, or it is simply an overblown "Disgusted of Hampstead" letter to the Establishment press. Trendy left: designer Katherine Hamn socialists to justify suppor our arguments are used by Wing Charter 88.
• Democratic rights are important, so it is worth having a broad alliance for democratic rights even if it is silent on social But Charter 88 is a very selective version of democratic rights, and a very selective sort of alliance (Establishment-oriented, with no democratic or accountable organisation). Democratic rights are important, but they do not belong to a world separate from social issues. We cannot organise seriously for democratic rights in alliance with the fanatical opponents of trade unionism!
• PR is vital for the left, because it will allow us to elect MPs to the left of Labour.
It is "parliamentary cretinism" to give so much priority to getting a couple of MPs elected for a left of-Labour party which anyway does not even exist yet. Such a project is compelling only for those socialists willing to face the rigours neither of fighting within the Labour Party nor of activity i an extra-parliamentary left organisation like the SWP, Militant, or the Alliance for Workers' Liberty; they hope that PR will somehow pull a left-wing parliamentary party into existence (with high positions for them, without them having to do too much work.
• "Citizens' movements" like Charter 88 are a new form of politics, more radical than discredited old party politics.
US politics has very weak political parties, but lots of citizens' movements, coalitions, alliances and pressure groups. The result: politics is an even more sordid business of horse-trading, corruption, and manipulation than in Western Europe, where parties are stronger. The working class cannot organise to change society through a patchwork of citizens' alliances, let alone elitist, Establishment-oriented ones like Charter 88, but only through trade
----- pull-quotes -----
Four arguments that do noi hold up