Playing the union card
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-04-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
All the evidence is that the Tories' union card simply doesn't carry the weight it did in 1987, let alone 1979. In one breath, the Tories claim credit for the lowest strike levels in 100 years, while in the next, they attempt to revive terrifying images of untrammelled union power:
Even the poster's background illustration of a sea of hands raised at a mass meeting lacks credibility: since 1984 unions have been prevented from calling strikes on a show of hands and Labour has stated that it will not change that aspect of the law (nor the abolition of closet shops, restrictions on picketing, and compulsory ballots So would the election of a Labour government make any measurable difference to what is usually referred to as "industrial relations"? Without wishing to give credence to the Tory propaganda effort, the short answer has to be yes. Labour commitments like the minimum wage and equal rights for part-time workers have been given so much prominence that it is difficult to see how even Kinnock could simply renege on them without an almighty row. Leaders of public sector unions (notably: NUPE) have repeatedly stated that the implementation of the minimum wage is a precondition for any cooperaOther Labour commitments - like the pledge to reverse the government's Maastricht opt-out from EC employment law, the promise of improved maternity pay and a law banning age discrimination in employment -are less hard and fast, but they still provide unions with opportunities to exert pressure on a Labour government in a way that would never arise with the Tories.
A Tory victory, on the other hand, would give the green light to a whole new swathe of anti-union legislation: restrictions on the "check off" system of collecting union dues at source; a compulsory seven days "cooling off" period before any strike; the outlawing of workplace (as opposed to postal) ballots; and even the abolition of that employers' favourite, the Bridlington Agreement.
None of which means that a Labour victory will automatically usher in a new golden age of class struggle: in fact, a Kinnock government would present a whole new set of problems and dangers for rank and file trade unionists. In particular the "National Economic Assessment" (originally proposed by John Edmonds of the GMB and Alan Tuffin of the UCW would almost certainly be the "quid pro quo" for the introduction of the national minimum wage. This would be a thinly-disguised form of incomes policy, policed by the union bureaucracy, just like the Social Contract of the "70s. After 13 years of crude union-bashing it is all too easy to forget about the dangers of beer-and-sandwiches corpoBut one thing is for sure: another Tory victory would be a devastating blow to the self-confidence and morale of rank and file trade unionists, confirming the already widely held myth of Tory invincibility. A Labour victory would at least open up the possibility of a revival in shopfloor militancy. The Tories are nearer the mark than the silly ultra-lefts who say the election will make no Fi first, it looks as though the Tories are threatening an INSIDETHE insurrectionary general strike in the event of a Labour victory: "Labour UNIONS in, everybody out" reads the slogan on the latest Tory election poster. It is of course, a desperate bid to make industrial rela- By Sleeper tions and Labour's union connection an elecuon issue.
they can't have it both ways, can they?
for union elections). tion with a Kinnock government. ratism. difference to the class struggle.
Scan page 5
NO er PERMITS STANDING CStewan FOR WAS TESTS small businesses going bust, and 200 homes being Organiser