Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Split vote in Coventry could help the Tories

Socialist Organiser no. 519, 2 April 1992 · scan pp. 2–4 · about 1,397 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

Neil Kinnock and Peter could hand Coventry SouthEast to the Tories.

Until a few months ago Coventry South East was a safe Labour seat, with a well-known MP whose dedication, competence and talent was admitted on all sides.

Then Neil Kinnock decided that the MP, Dave Nellist, was too left-wing. Seizing on Militant's stupid decision to contest the Walton by-election, ne expelleu Dave Nellist, la sympathiser of Militant.

Militant, claiming their miserable result in Walton as a great victory, decided to run candidates against Labour in the General Election, so there was pressure on Nellist to stand.

The latest opinion poll shows Labour at 32%, Nellist at 30% and the Tories at 28%. A Tory victory on April would be well within the usual margin of error. But it can be avoided if those left-wing groups now campaigning for Nellist sober up and back Labour Dave Nellist through the streets of Belfast.

The Student Campaign for Peace' organised by the National Union of Students and the Union of Students in Ireland was behind the march. The campaign aims to involve students across the region in debates and discussions on creating peace in the majority of Britain's academics will be backWing Labour on April 9th, according to an opinion poll published last week. The ICM poll gave Labour 57% of the academic vote in Further and Higher education with the Liberal Democrats

Scan page 3

Do the nationalists have the best tunes? Scottish workers from Caterpillar marching in London, 1987. Photo: Jez Coulson parliamentary manoeuvres blocked it. Now there is a big any left-wingers - from rhetoric which it finds electorally after the 1979 referendum, to that end, if the majority of there is an emerging West M socialist to Labour Briefing useful just now, the SP's because of a wrecking Scots want it.

- say we should vote for programme is a reactionary amendment in the Westminster And no socialist should be Independence within that EC he Scottish National Party nationalist pipe-dream of cross- Parliament which said that no frightened off from supporting a would let Scotland be nart of a Many left-wingers - from MV socialist to Labour Briefing - say we should vote for the Scottish National Party against Labour in Scotland, or at least for the more left-wing SN candidates.

In recent years the SNP has moved away from its old "Tartan Tory" image, and now pushes policies well to the left of Labour on the Poll Tax, Trident, and other issues.

Yet the SNP remains a nationalist, not a working-class party. SNP leader Alex Salmond says: "The SNP is not a hard-left or socialist party. it Scotland became independent the SP would continue as a social-democratic party"

Stripped of the radical Graham Bash Vladimir Derer Terry Eagleton Jatin Haria (Labour Party BlacklSectons, Jorothya Vacedo per Manno John Mcuror JohnaNIchbison Peter Tannel Membassin leer freque 15-01 cross section of the left who are pposecratbelt bour partie witch-hunt against Socialist Organiser. View expressed in articlesiare the responsin tooThe authorstand nonpf the AdAS6M Editorial Board. rhetoric which it finds electorally useful just now, the SP's programme is a reactionary nationalist pipe-dream of cross-class unity on the basis of oil revenues.

It is fundamentally a project for Scottish capitalism, trying to tie in the working class on the basis of hostility to the English. The first victims of an attempted SNP restructuring of Scottish capitalism would be the Scottish workers.

In Scotland as elsewhere in Britain, Labour is the party based on the bedrock working-class organisations, the trade unions. The SNP does not have that class basis. To encourage Scottish workers to hive off into nationalism is, for socialists, to give up on our central task, of developing, transforming, and revolutionising the labour movement. Whether Scotland separates from Britain or not, the economic and political integration of West European capitalism will continue. The labour movement will need to unite across the national Frontiers, as the offshore oil rig workers union OILC is now reaching out to Norwegian oil workers.

The last thing we need is for the trade unions and working-class political parties to be split by new frontiers. If Scotland separates, the labour movement should stay united across the border.

here are real issues behind T the nationalist upsurge. In March 1979, 53 per cent voted in a referendum for Scottish home rule.

Since then, the majority for home rule has become bigger and more stable. It is now up to 80%. Yet home tule was denied after the 1979 referendum, because of a wrecking amendment in the Westminster Parliament which said that no majority would count unless it was also at least 40% of the electorate; and the Tories will continue to deny it if they win on 9 April.

If we fight for socialism "from below", we must be consistent democrats. We must support the right of every nation to determine its own future. Even if Scottish socialists voted against home rule in the 1979 referendum, it is now an established, stable fact that the majority of Scots want home rule. They should have it.

Under pressure from Scottish opinion, the Labour Party has shifted to support a Scottish Parliament with tax-raising powers. Once this Parliament is set up, it will provide a means for the Scottish people to decide, through parliamentary elections, how far they want to separate from the rest of Britain.

Scottish workers who favour the SNP line of "Independence in Europe" should recognise that Labour's policy provides a toad and stable majority for home rule. to that end, Scots want it.

And no socialist should be frightened off from supporting a Scottish parliament because it might lead to independence. We want to keep the English and the Scottish working-class movements united, but we have no brief for the unity of the British state. To put undemocratic obstacles in the way of Scottish independence, it the majority of the Scottish people want it, can only harm working-class unity.

here has been a basic shift in - Scottish politics; and it is more than just the fact of Scotland with an anti-Tory majority being held under Tory rule for 13 years, a situation shared by Wales and parts of England.

In the coming weeks, Socialist Organiser will be opening a debate on this shift, its implications, and socialist policy on the proposed Scottish Parliament.

Historically, Scotland has not been an oppressed nation. It was integrated with England in a single state from 1707, and shared in tite spoils of the British Empire.

There were some movements for Scottish home rule in the late 19th and early 20th century, in the period when the British Empire was being reorganised on the basis of home rule for Canada, Australia, South Africa, and so on, but Scotland was not disadvantaged: Scottish finance capital was, and is, a disproportionately large segment of British finance capital.

But there is no more British Empire. Britain is no longer a Great Power, association with which brings privileges. And Organiser 53% voted for Scottish home rule in 1979, but European confederation, the EC.

capitalist Great Power yet have political autonomy.

The SNP's current slogan, likely to have more staying "Independence in Europe" power than its old grab-as-grabcan formula, "It's Scotland's oil!"

In many parts of Europe - in Belgium, in Italy, and most markedly in Eastern Europe -the trend towards a "Europe of regions" has been damaging and diceuntiva far tha martina alace ustupuve for tae worklig class movement, boosting local pettymindedness and narrowness. We should have no illusions; at the same time we have no reason to defend the existing state structures of capitalism.

Yes to self-determination! No the SNP! Maintain the existing cross-border unity of the labour movement, and build unity across Europe! Vote Labour on 9 April!

Tie vemanciation of thel youne cass saiso, te emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race.

Karl Marx spc dȘ urgenıser POB» BrO lanu di SeS ARA Mervsresk: Ornl-ogg 7965 4Miжr wateworwepywas Monday Editor: John 0 Mahony DEneey katriens utur P PDSE 540 oterl batidandst F0 T0 009 hegerer asm m ervspapana, Post Office artig epidowot racessariy reflect Mewsi auld areum a bersomal capacn

Scan page 4

Socialist Organiser No. 519 page 4 CAL AGHAN TOR

----- pull-quotes -----

ote Labour in SCOTTISH Scotland, too! INOW

Alvnsory Eidlitorial Board

*If we fight for socialism/from below, we mus be consistent democrats.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 519

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →